News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by edward on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:02AM (#10393158)
In 2010 when I lived in the San Francisco I ordered my broadband from Comcast, but I didn't pay for the TV package.

I added a splitter to the Comcast coax cable, then plugged one wire into the cable modem and the other into the back of my TV. Network TV channels for no extra cost.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by joezydeco on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:15AM (#10393242)
In 2012 there was an FCC vote to allow cable operators to encrypt the local channels as well. Your clear QAM signals are pretty much gone now, especially after the analog channels were allowed to go dark.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by zaroth on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:03PM (#10393920)
Is there any chance a grassroots effort could get the rule for clear QAM local channels restored? It seemed like such a reasonable trade-off for giving the cable operator a local monopoly, to provide free and clear HD broadcast channels which my TV could display so nicely without any external boxes. It was so sad watching the channels drop out after they started encrypting them :-(

In South San Jose you need a "pretty big" antenna to receive a decent line-up of OTA channels being broadcast from north San Fran... A smaller powered antenna even up on the roof would not pick them up clearly.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by joezydeco on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:22PM (#10394051)
Given the current economic climate and the lobbying power of the cable companies, this would be a very uphill battle if not impossible. They also shot down Aereo, which would have been a cheaper solution for you.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by mercora on Thursday October 15, 2015 @11:07AM (#10393582)
A year ago i canceled cable TV subscription in Germany because i had most important channels anyhow via DVB-T. I had internet subscription for years with them and was satisfied so this had to be kept working.

Knowing a bit about how these cable networks work inside the building i was curious to see how they will implement this. I thought they might have a filter for all those just having internet subscription but this could only work with certain types of wiring inside the building and also depends on access to the equipment which is not always available to them.

Then i thought they might replace the wall socket either with some filter build in or just missing plug for the TV. But again this is only possible when they are allowed to access the equipment or maintain their own. Also this seemed to be rather expensive. The basic cable package doesn't cost that much and the provider outsources all kinds of installation related tasks. I would guess using this rather weak method would pay for some years of Basic TV package subscription.

Long story short, i waited several months and nothing happened. I still watch cable TV like i did before. But as is said, its possible that they are able to cut you off on some kind of installations. But its also questionable if the cost of this would be adequate.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by gbarnes on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:09AM (#10393204)
I cut the cord 6 years ago, and just found out last month that this was an option. TWC literally has an option to add network channels to an internet only package for $10/mo. I wonder how many people they're ripping off with that.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by baldfat on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:18AM (#10393258)
I pay LESS than $10 for all the basic cable channels on Fios (I HATE Verizon and DON'T recommend them due to dishonesty in every area I ever had to deal with them (Hidden also means dishonest, but I delt with absolute lies)) same thing with my other carrier. For $4 more I even get ESPN.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by mosburger on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:51AM (#10393483)
It's still free for me w/ TWC. I have them only for broadband, but happen to get Clear QAM network channels anyway free of charge. Wonder how much longer they'll be doing that where I live.

I've even purchased an eyeTV tuner and hooked it up to an old Macbook Pro I had laying around, and basically made a DVR w/ guide for the network channels.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by mjklin on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:31AM (#10393338)
I'm able to do this with Comcast, but the channels available look really bad on my tv.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by greg5green on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:23AM (#10393282)
This was technically stealing.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by jerf on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:38AM (#10393386)
There's precedent for things that get delivered to you being yours to use, even if you didn't order or pay for them. While I am aware that it is absolutely not the same thing, there is a law that anything sent unsolicited to you in postal mail is yours to keep, no questions asked. This is to prevent a type of now-dead fraud that involved doing that, then billing people for it.

It's really the responsibility of the cable provider to correctly filter services, if they want to charge for them. And you'll probably find that if you call up and try to "complain" about this, that they'll do nothing and tell you to do as you like, as it isn't even worth their time to bother about... putting a rather low bound on the degree of harm you're "inflicting" on them even in the worst case.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by kbenson on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:46AM (#10393447)
I understand your point, but I think there's a difference between the cable company "correctly filtering service" and a person getting additional hardware to bypass the cable modem demarcation. It does get muddied by them allowing customer cable modems, which means there's not a clear a demarcation point anymore.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by kileywm on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:42PM (#10394199)
There may be a terms of use clause forbidding splitting like this but it almost certainly isn't a demarcation issue, so there is no real 'bypass' that I am aware of.

The demarcation is generally clearly marked (plastic box often called a 'network interface device') and is almost never located at the modem itself.

Typically, the legal demarcation is on the exterior of houses. For a multiple dwelling unit (apartment complex) or commercial building, the demarcation is usually inside. ISPs try to choose a demarcation that is accessible from the outside, so as to not require being allowed into the building to test signal leading to the premise. This cuts down on cancelled repairs due to 'no access'. My point in all this is that for most coax and twisted pair services, the indoor wiring is usually the property owners and not the ISP's, especially at the point where it connects to the modem. For someone to add a splitter to wire that is their responsibility and property is almost certainly legal.

I worked for one of the bigger ISPs up until last year, so I speak only from my personal experience. For more details:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demarcation_point

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by kbenson on Thursday October 15, 2015 @05:01PM (#10395961)
> The demarcation is generally clearly marked (plastic box often called a 'network interface device') and is almost never located at the modem itself.

Yes, but if cable companies always provided and required you use their cable modems, then there would be a clear demarcation point, the cable modem. Whether it's usually inside or outside is irrelevant (and "usually" in this case is debatable. I've worked at multiple business locations where it's inside, because there is a location dedicated for it). Of course there isn't a clear demarcation at the cable modem, as many cable companies allow you to use your own cable modem instead of theirs, which is why I said the issue is "muddied".

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by lfowles on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:05PM (#10393931)
I remember being told by my cable company that network channels were free of charge with internet service. Of course, they were on crazy channels I have to have the TV autoscan for. And now they're probably encrypted and I'd have to rent a cable box for $8/mo.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by jp555 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:06PM (#10393934)
Doesn't stealing - technically speaking - mean taking another person's property without an intention of returning it? Duplicating someone's property without their permission is copyright infringement, not stealing. You're making more of it, not less of it.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by icebraining on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:12PM (#10394414)
The SCOTUS agrees with you (in Dowling v. United States). Dowling prevailed, because while he committed copyright infringement (for profit!), he didn't steal.

Technically.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by pkaye on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:35AM (#10393365)
The (compressed) picture quality for the basic network channels I'm paying Comcast for is technically stealing from me. And they will charge you extra if you get broadband without the basic TV channels. I ended using an OTA antenna regardless.