To address the "why should you keep US citizenship?" question: If you move abroad, you won't be able to get citizenship in the country that you reside in for a number of years (depending on where you go), and in many cases, your US citizenship is what makes it easy to get a work visa or residence permit in that foreign country in the first place. So, even if you actually intend to renounce your citizenship, you still have about 5-10 years of living abroad and dealing with the tax implications before you can become a naturalized citizen in the place that you move to.
I'm not trying to argue whether it's fair or unfair to impose the tax on citizens living abroad, just that the logistics don't make the proposal of renouncing ones citizenship so simple.
We don't get any real benefits abroad, and we get charged for everything. Let's say you need something notarized - many places won't accept a foreign notarization, which means you have to go to the embassy. You know how your bank will usually notarize documents for free? The embassy charges you $50 - per signature.
Want to renounce your citizenship? That'll be $2,350.
You managed to end up in the wrong place and civil war breaks out? The US will make some effort to help you, but it wont' come free. U.S. law 22 U.S.C. 2671(b) (2) (A) requires that any departure assistance be provided "on a reimbursable basis to the maximum extent practicable.” This means that evacuation costs are ultimately your responsibility; you will be asked to sign a form promising to repay the U.S. government. (http://travel.state.gov/content/passports/en/emergencies/cri...)
And if you do renounce your citizenship, you risk not even being allowed back in the country to visit family. --People who have done so have been denied visas by the US supposedly because they aren't well enough established in their new country. And yes, this can even happen in the event of family emergencies. So giving up US citizenship could prevent you from visiting a parent or other family member on their deathbed - not something most people want to think about.
By the way, you speak of giving up citizenship like it's a small thing. Once you do this, you can never get it back.
'US Persons' in the context of this law is not the same as US citizens. It may include family members or business partners of citizens, or even of family members of former residents. It even affects many people who have no personal connection to the US, in some cases even people who have no right to enter the US without a visa if at all.
Fatca requires financial institutions to find and report any such US persons among their customers, and report their details to the US. This can be problematic, not just because so many US persons aren't even aware they are considered US persons, but also because in some countries banking privacy laws make it illegal for banks to record such information of their customers. These banks are now torn between following their local law and following US law. As a result, just offering certain services to US persons may carry a significant risk.
Double taxation only exists in Aethopia and the US.
Read this blog: http://www.overseas-exile.com/
Protection? Yes, maybe that's the reason. To support the US military efforts and budget.
On a side-note: If I would applied to the US greencard, and then decided to move back to Germany, I would have to pay double income taxes. To Germany and to the US. You don't even need to be US citizen.
8.7 million abroad. 3,417 renounced citizenship.
Or, .039%.
I'm going to take a stab at this and guess that's some of the 1% right there who had millions stashed abroad. Maybe the tax law was painful to them, but for the rest, it's hardly a crisis.
The real question is how many people would like to give it up, but can't, because obtaining citizenship where they live is extremely tough and because the US is unusually vindictive towards people who try and renounce. They can even retroactively undo your renunciation if they decide you did it for tax reasons.
Seen from one angle, US citizenship looks a lot like modern slavery. You're born into it, it's difficult to escape, you get no benefit out of the relationship and no matter where in the world you run to your 'owners' will demand a slice of the fruits of your labours.
I certainly wouldn't presume or preach to others with regards to how they view their country, however:
1. We (I'm an expat as well) pay little taxes to the U.S. because of the foreign earned income credit. The paperwork is onerous, yes. But it's not as bad as some make it out to be, unless you're in an exceptional income bracket.
2. A U.S. passport is a powerful thing. And as the OP mentioned, the benefits are real. We look after our own. http://www.passportindex.org/byRank.php
3. Many U.S. expats wouldn't dream of renouncing their citizenship, because it simply means more to them than that.
It's more than residency, it's identity. And it's something we pay into. Many Americans will tell you...they don't like a lot of taxes...but they /will/ pay taxes, and they expect everyone to. It's a "we're all in this together" bit. Even if you're abroad, and you're paying a paltry amount, you're still chipping in.
Just something many of us do.
This is the part that often (note: not always) leads to valuing an American higher than a non-American. I have real problems with that. 911 is virtually celebrated, while larger tragedies the world over are not. What makes an American soldier's life more worthwhile than a baby born with Aids in some African backwater? If you believe all the flag-waving, nationalism. Otherwise media.
And I get that small number of deaths is a tragedy, a large number is a statistic. That doesn't change the reality - a life is valuable no matter who's it is, and where that person lives.
I'm a citizen of the world. I was born in Africa, have lived in the US, and now live in Europe. I rate myself as no better or worse than anyone else on this planet, including Americans. Most of all I'm insanely grateful to not be American.
AFAICT most of the money isn't spent here, it's parked here as a hedge in case something goes south in the home country, usually in real estate holdings. The biggest effect I can see is that housing in the city is too expensive for the locals now so families are being driven out into rural areas.
It's not like federal income is an admission fee. Or a direct tax on something the citizen uses (like a toll road). You benefit just as much from the government building a VA hospital, AIDS research, or a US carrier stationed near Syria.
You don't suddenly stop being an American when you go live somewhere else.
This law may have been well-intentioned but it has some very toxic fallout for innocent people.
I've worn te uniform of the US military and paid my 'dues,' yet to imply that an overseas American is any less American is offensive. When I am outside the US, I do not consume a single taxpayer funded service. All consular services for the most part are self-funded. If the time comes when I need the Marines to come bail me out, send me the bill and I'll pay cash; otherwise the IRS can leave me the hell alone. I am a proud American, but I despise the Democrats who passed FATCA along with the class warfare rhetoric that led to it. To Democrats, overseas Americans are presumed to be money launderers, drug dealers or tax evader. I am neither yet the burden of proof is on me. Did you know when Insend money to the US, I must provide proof of the fund's origins? I have to prove my innocence in order to use my own money! FATCA is worse than the NSA -- it's a license to violate my financial sovereignty.
My biggest complaint is the paperwork. Besides FATCA, there is also the FBAR filing requirement. You need to report every foreign bank account that has more than $10,000 in it. This amount hasn't changed since the 70s.
American citizenship has real benefits, especially if you're rich enough to pay expat taxes. The U.S. protects you and your property everywhere in the world. My dad was stuck in Yemen when the civil war there broke out. His hotel was shelled. That blue passport was his ticket out on a C-130.