This seems hardly worth 'denouncing' American citizenship. Can you explain?
I feel like threads like these really illustrate the difference between someone on HN and the average person.
You aren't paying twice. That's the point. Assume the US has a 30% tax rate in your bracket. Poland has a 35% rate for that same bracket. Then as an American expat, you would pay 35% in taxes. If Poland had a 25% rate, you'd pay 30% (25 + 5) in taxes. You aren't paying 65% of your income in taxes. You aren't paying twice.
> On the most basic level - Poland has absolutely no "right" to any of that money.
Then Poland has the right to say you are no longer a Polish citizen that can take advantage of Polish embassies or move back to Poland at any time as a full citizen.
It seems perfectly sensible to me.
And yeah, I'm not totally sure about your example. I'm quite certain that I would pay 30% of my income in Poland, and then US would want a further 30% of the remaining amount, IRS would not care that I have already paid income tax in Poland.
It's not sensible if none of your other coworkers have to worry about this and they're all foreign citizens as well. It's a stupid tax policy that is basically a shakedown.