Re:Why ‘Mom’ and ‘Dad’ Sound So Similar in So Many Languages
by princeb on Monday October 12, 2015 @11:02PM
(#10378345)
japanese falls completely outside this generalization.
edit: on further investigation mama and baba are used very informally but it appears these are loanwords.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why ‘Mom’ and ‘Dad’ Sound So Similar in So Many Languages
by Steko on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:20AM
(#10378806)
Japan is a linguistic minefield and defies generalization. In Ainu 'nanna' is mother and in Okinawan it's 'anma'. In Old Japanese there's 'haha' (and variants - 'papa' appears to have been prevelent in Old Japanese, see link in cousin post) and 'amo'.
Also note: while 'mama' is a loanword it's overwhelmingly what babies call their mothers in Japan i.e. it has outcompeted other words likely for the same reasons as said in the article.
Re:Why ‘Mom’ and ‘Dad’ Sound So Similar in So Many Languages
by euske on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @01:10AM
(#10378648)
Traditionally, they were "o-toh" for dad and "o-kah" for mom. You might add "-chan" or "-san" or remove the "o-" prefix, depending on your taste.
Personally, a phrase like "every language" immediately flags a BS sign to me.
Re:Why ‘Mom’ and ‘Dad’ Sound So Similar in So Many Languages
by ss248 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:30AM
(#10378832)
Kids use okasan/otosan only when they are talking about third party mom/dad. They use haha (which make even more sense, according to article) or chichi when speaking about their own mom and dad.
Re:Why ‘Mom’ and ‘Dad’ Sound So Similar in So Many Languages
by princeb on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @03:00AM
(#10378933)
haha and chichi are more formal.
Re:Why ‘Mom’ and ‘Dad’ Sound So Similar in So Many Languages
by Steko on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:32AM
(#10378840)
It really depends what you mean by 'traditionally'. My reading of [1] is that the 'ka' reading is one of many although it's become more prevelant in modern usage. [2] says that 'papa' was most common in Old Japanese.