http://www.sfgate.com/crime/article/S-F-attorney-who-killed-...
/wears a helmet when cycling.
Maybe you haven't noticed, but at some point, a meaner nastier criminal justice system does little or no additional good at the expense of harming innocent people. That point's long been passed with DUI laws, and people still do it.
If a person can't be trusted to put either the bottle or the keys down, then they need to be restrained. I'd rather find a cheaper way than prison, but it's insanity that you can drive drunk and receive a punishment that serves as almost no disincentive to continue to do it.
Oh sure, they MIGHT have killed someone because they were a little bit over an arbitrary and always decreasing blood alcohol limit, but they didn't, so I'm not sure what a 10 year prison sentence would accomplish.
I suppose at some point you can create such massive penalties for every possible misdeed that people become too terrified to leave their homes, but I don't want to live in that world.
I don't even know where to begin...
Everyone drinks and drives. That's not even illegal. But it's not that hard to take one sip too many and break the law. Seriously, get off your high horse. There are over a million DUI arrests per year in the US. That's just the tiny percentage they catch!
There's a death every 51 minutes from it. 31% of traffic-related deaths.
17% of children under 14 who die in a car crash involving an alcohol-impaired driver. Over half of those are in the vehicle driven by the drunk driver. That's utter insanity, and I wonder how many of those people were close to the limit and something you'd deem just fine.
I'm not naive enough to think everyone at the restaurant took Uber or have a designated driver, but I trust you're also not naive enough to think that it's not a serious problem, and it's one that, more often as not, kills innocents.
The problem is that people can get away with it, and largely do. (As you allude to.)
Please don't pretend it's a small problem, and that discussing whether longer/harsher/different sentences would motivate more people to take Uber or get a designated driver is the problem. That's as counterproductive as adopting a smug tone when discussing policy.
Edit:
> I suppose at some point you can create such massive penalties for every possible misdeed that people become too terrified to leave their homes, but I don't want to live in that world.
Enough with the straw man, BTW. I'm pretty Libertarian. But the moment you demonstrate that you can't safely manage the responsibility of driving, then I'm all in favor of strongly limiting your ability to do others harm. It's the height of American selfishness to think that the current system is sufficient relative to the problem that exists.
Agree, and I think a similar approach should be followed regarding civil penalties for not riding your bike with a helmet. $5 fine – okay, I'll take it. $100? That's a quarter or half of what my bike costs.
Yes, at the time of manufacture. How about maintenance? If your car has severe mechanical problems, you are endangering everyone around you (and of course yourself as well).
> I don't think many people die in cars today in 10 mph wrecks
Not that many cars go 10mph. Why should it be some kind of benchmark for car safety? Freeway speed limits are usually between 55 and 70mph, and are violated with a level of casualness that varies by state.
If you kill somebody when you're behind the wheel, and you were sober?
You'll usually get dinged with "failure to yield", which basically means "there was an accident and it was your fault because your car was where it was when it had no right to be". Like turning when the intersection isn't clear or something.
That comes with a $500 fine. A $500 for taking a life by negligence.
Yeah, besides airbags and seat-belts, we collectively don't give a crap about vehicular safety.
One thing that is interesting is that compulsory wearing of helmets has not decreased fatalities to any great extent. But if I ever have an accident I am sure glad that I wear one.
Yes, this sounds pretty good. I think the situation on car safety is much better in the EU and other countries compared to the US.
> But if I ever have an accident I am sure glad that I wear one.
As will I. I do wear a bike helmet a lot. What pisses me off is that I can be fined $100+ for not wearing it when the guy next to me with a car that seems to be running on coal and two tires with questionable pressure goes scot free.
I don't think that's the point: I don't think most bike fatalities are from the kinds of injuries that helmets mitigate. I think the point of helmets is reducing the incidence and severity of a certain class of non-fatal injuries that are experienced without them.
- Having a five-point harness for every car is compulsory (alright, I'll admit this is somewhat overkill and rhetorical)
- Cars are certified yearly as being road safe (not the case in all states in the US, but I think this is the case in the EU)
- Drunk driving has extremely severe penalties (10+ years in prison) beginning with the first offence.
The motorist is driving a much more dangerous vehicle capable of causing serious injuries to themselves and other parties. Let us all behave in a responsible manner.