News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I Teach Gerrymandering by LordKano on Monday October 12, 2015 @01:12PM (#10375812)
I don't see the composition of the Senate as a problem. I see it as balance. More populous states get greater representation in the House. The Senate serves to prevent more populous states from steamrolling less populous states.

It's a feature, not a bug.

Re:How I Teach Gerrymandering by TheCoelacanth on Monday October 12, 2015 @01:54PM (#10376040)
Since the passage of the 17th amendment, Senators don't represent states, they represent people. And some of those people have vastly disproportionate representation by Senators.
Re:How I Teach Gerrymandering by LordKano on Monday October 12, 2015 @07:37PM (#10377506)
The Constitution only provides for proportional representation in the House.

There were disparities in population during ratification. This was a necessary compromise to address the concerns of the smaller states.

The system is working as intended.

Re:How I Teach Gerrymandering by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday October 14, 2015 @04:26PM (#10389220)
I'm well aware of the reason it was created that way. I just don't think it makes sense in an era where 3/4 of the states are just arbitrarily chosen chunks of land rather than formerly sovereign entities.
Re:How I Teach Gerrymandering by gohrt on Monday October 12, 2015 @02:04PM (#10376078)
Senators represent the people of their state.
Re:How I Teach Gerrymandering by TheCoelacanth on Monday October 12, 2015 @03:29PM (#10376526)
Yes, and some of those people have a vastly disproportionate amount of representation.
Re:How I Teach Gerrymandering by Fishkins on Monday October 12, 2015 @04:09PM (#10376696)
In my view, talking about how much representation a state deserves doesn't even make sense. People should decide elections, not some semi-arbitrary geographical boundaries. In the house, people are fairly represented. In the senate, people in smaller states are unfairly over-represented.

It's a feature like an "install our app" popup on every random mobile site is a feature. Someone thought it was a good idea and did it intentionally, but I think it's awful and was done for bad reasons.

Re:How I Teach Gerrymandering by dragonwriter on Monday October 12, 2015 @05:18PM (#10377010)
> In the house, people are fairly represented.

Moreso than in the Senate, but beyond that, not actually fairly by most reasonable standards. Monatana's Congressional district has a little under a million people, each of Rhode Islands two districts has a little over a half-million. So the division into states creates an almost 2:1 advantage in representation for Rhode Islanders compared to Montanans in the House.

Now, that's not as lopsided as the 66:1 advantage Wyomingans have over Californians when it comes to representation in the Senate, but its not exactly equal representation, either.