News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics by coldtea on Sunday October 11, 2015 @10:10AM (#10369290)
>Ok, you are pretty explicitly appealing to the Copenhagen theory of ethics. Good to have that out in the open.

I don't appeal to any such BS. The so called "Copenhagen theory of ethics" is an ill-thought neologism of the writer of the blog post, and lacks several metric tons of nuances and considerations.

The basic premise -- that a third-party has the same "moral obligation" to pay her maternity leave as the person who employeed her, made money of her (the total balanace was positive on THEIR side, not hers) and fired her when she become pregnant, is absurd.

Not only that, but protections against firing an employee that became pregnant are an accepted part of the legal and moral obligations of an employee, enforced by law in most developed countries.

If anything the burden of proof is on the author of TFA to counter the thinking of all those legislators.

I would also like to know how a deal like "I'll give you food everyday for having sex with you" to a poor woman who hates the idea, but is starving and thus accepts it, is any different than the situations lauded by the author of TFA article.

After all the woman is better off, right? She would be starving or even dead from hunger. And she accepted the deal by her own volition.

Re:The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics by yummyfajitas on Sunday October 11, 2015 @10:48AM (#10369437)
Because I'm not making money off of her.

"The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics says that when you observe or interact with a problem in any way, you can be blamed for it. At the very least, you are to blame for not doing more."

To summarize your post: I subscribe to the Copenhagen interpretation of ethics, but don't call it that!

I have no moral objection to prostitution. I also have no moral objection to "I'll give you money everyday for cleaning my house" to a poor person who hates cleaning.

Re:The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics by coldtea on Sunday October 11, 2015 @04:43PM (#10370899)
>I have no moral objection to prostitution. I also have no moral objection to "I'll give you money everyday for cleaning my house" to a poor person who hates cleaning.

Do you have moral objections to anything, then, or do you think that as the necessary money have been exchanged everything is OK?

Also do you think that "voluntary agreement" means the same for everybody in every financial situation?

Re:The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics by shasta on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:00AM (#10369493)
Your attitudes are common and somewhat align with the way things work today, but I think everyone would be better off if society viewed the market as just an efficient medium for exchange and took more direct responsibility for the welfare of the poor rather than foisting those responsibilities on arbitrary economic transactions. The market already has a mechanism in place to determine price by balancing supply and demand. Markets have problems, like big players and lack of information, but this basic price determination mechanism is great when it works.

Also, I think it's best to pick a different example than prostitution because of the importance of cultural factors there. Instead, what if I offer $20 to a poor person to let me slap them hard in the face? That might be a good deal for them, but I'm still a jerk for doing it. The problem though isn't that the transaction is exploitative. It's that it's wasteful. Why did the poor person need to endure the slap? What was the point?

Re:The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics by pron on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:03AM (#10369508)
> rather than foisting those responsibilities on arbitrary economic transactions

Transactions are never arbitrary. They're an action taken by individuals based on their interests, and their interests are determined by their values, and their values are often shaped -- at least to some degree -- by communal values.

> but this basic price determination mechanism is great when it works

How do you know when it works? Obviously, there is difference of opinion in determining what "works" means.

> Instead, what if I offer $20 to a poor person to let me slap them hard in the face? That might be a good deal for them, but I'm still a jerk for doing it. The problem though isn't that the transaction is exploitative. It's that it's wasteful.

OK, that's a classic.

Re:The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics by philh on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:28AM (#10369630)
> the total balanace was positive on THEIR side, not hers

It was positive on both of their sides. They made money from the fruits of her labor, and she made money from the money that they gave her in exchange.

Employment is positive sum. Just because one party benefits from a transaction, doesn't mean someone else lost out.