News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by trhway on Sunday October 11, 2015 @02:35AM (#10368316)
> in 1985, no government of a major state appeared to be as firmly in power, its policies as clearly set in their course, as that of the USSR.

the ship was rotting and falling apart from inside. Andropov, before Gorbachev, was trying to treat the situation the way that was natural to him - previously head of KGB - by enforcing the workplace discipline and implementing strict restrictions on alcohol. Talking about the way Russian government can lose the last trust and support of the people! (i say Russian because the rest of USSR had significant other reasons to leave the empire) Current regime in Russia has learned the lesson - https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2015/02/02...

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by txru on Sunday October 11, 2015 @05:25AM (#10368680)
I think the point that this article somewhat strenuously tries to make is, if the ship was rotting and falling apart on the inside, why didn't it do it in the Brezhnev years, during the stagnation and attempted economic reforms, especially when oil prices dropped to an all-time low?

To say that simply "the system was bad, and 1985-90 was just when the bottom fell out" smacks of hindsight bias.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by dsfyu404ed on Monday October 12, 2015 @09:33AM (#10374340)
People often forget that a typical existence in the USSR is on par with being poor white trash in the semi-rural northern US, just swap the trailer park for the apartment complex. They weren't starving but they had been close for decades. They were working as hard as anyone else who's trying to make ends meet but getting nowhere fast. For example, if a light-bulb burnt out in their home the only way to replace it was to switch it with a working one at work. Walking a miles in negative double digit temperatures to get to work, or to go to the grocery store because you can't afford to buy gas until payday wears on you. Taking scraps of insulation from a dumpster to keep the wind from coming in around your windows isn't fun. Having to park your car on a hill so you can roll start it in the morning because you can't afford a battery that can start your car in the cold doesn't make you feel good about your life. When you're living poor like that you've got so little invested in the system that you just don't give a damn. You wouldn't care if society collapses because you know in the back of your mind that there's a chance that in the following chaos you might come out ahead. These are the kind of people that made up the working class of the USSR. Some were better off, some worse but very, very few were comfortable where they were.

Meanwhile the upper middle class and above are comfortable but insecure. Sure the nation looks good on paper but even the people who are doing ok aren't going to be comfortable in a corrupt system because even if they put in the time and effort to do good work there's that chance that the next bunch of guys in charge will have someone else they'd rather give your job to or worse, by doing good work you've put yourself at odds with them and might be promoted to digging a ditch in Siberia.

IMO the statistics may have looked good there were a lot of unhappy people in the Soviet Union and in retrospect the place looks like a house of cards.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by DominikR on Sunday October 11, 2015 @08:25AM (#10369034)
> Current regime in Russia has learned the lesson

Why is it a "regime"? Putin was democratically elected and even Western opinion research institutes unequivocally attest that he is supported by 85 to 90 percent of the Russian population.

In US media this is always attributed to "propaganda" while economic successes that might have an influence on Russian votes is completely ignored. For example: Russian GDP rose during Putins years tenfold. Russia reduced its foreign debt down to 23% of GDP and a flat tax of 13% for everyone was introduced. (I live in the EU and I am basically robbed by my government - I pay a hefty 50% tax on top of being forced to charge 20% VAT from my customers)

If these aren't good reasons to vote for someone then I don't know what is. I would vote for ANY party (except radicals), be it left or right that would stimulate GDP growth while reducing my taxes down to 13%.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by mojuba on Sunday October 11, 2015 @09:41AM (#10369201)
In the years preceding the collapse of the USSR, circa 1987, 98% of the population supported the Communist Party. When there is no freedom of speech votes aren't predictive or indicative of anything at all other than the amount of propaganda.

There is no freedom of speech in Russia today, in fact it's been deteriorating year by year. So no, the pro-Putin votes you have today will evaporate in a (historical) instant just like they did then, in the 1980s.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by DominikR on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:34AM (#10369660)
I see Russians everywhere on the Internet speaking their mind freely and hosting political Youtube channels. The government has nowhere near the grip on information it had during the USSR.

Additionally Russians can access all Western media whenever they like and they do so often, especially the urbanized population. (where the majority of them create pro-Putin comments defending the actions of the Russian government)

That pro-Putin votes will evaporate is just your personal opinion and hope, but it isn't based on anything real. After the Yeltsin years it will take many decades for liberalism to recover in Russia.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by nine_k on Sunday October 11, 2015 @12:13PM (#10369826)
Russian government does censor the internet. There is a blacklist maintained by Roskomnadzor; it, for instance, blacklists certain Wikipedia pages, along with certain opposition and other "extremist" web sites. Russia lacks a China-style single-choke-point firewall; ISPs have to enforce it.

If you have a chance to watch any Russian TV, you can't avoid noticing how propaganda-heavy it is, and how all the propaganda is in favor of the government (in the US, at least, the latter is not the case).

Also, being a businessman of any importance and not following the party line does not work. Not all cases are as dramatic as Khodorkovsky's, who happened to own one of the largest oils and gas companies, but legal harassment of business for political non-conformance continues, or continued while such non-conformance lasted, or, at least, was publicly visible.

This is milder than China, and way milder and more sane than than the Soviet regime was; there's no doubt about it. Also, the sharp rise in living standards of 2000s, fueled by oil prices, is still remembered and has not completely deteriorated. So Putin does enjoy some genuine citizens' support. It's still not something that citizens, acting freely and with consideration, have chosen, kind of like the Swiss do in their referenda.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by DominikR on Sunday October 11, 2015 @12:30PM (#10369897)
Yes. Although I disagree with censorship where ever it happens, you can hardly argue that the blocked pages are political in nature.

Wikipedia was blocked for drug and suicide related content and was since then unblocked. (after Wikipedia removed these articles in its Russian version)

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by guard-of-terra on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:22PM (#10372345)
I can argue. Why were grani.ru blocked?
Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by Const-me on Monday October 12, 2015 @08:50PM (#10377815)
I'm a Russian freely speaking my mind on the Internet. I’ve only started doing that after I've took my one-way flight from there, with no intention to return ever.

Are you sure those Russians you're talking about aren't emigrants like me?

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by DominikR on Wednesday October 14, 2015 @07:16PM (#10390207)
Who or what prevented speaking your mind on the Internet while in Russia. I'd really like to know.

It's not like they have a great firewall there where every foreign service is blocked.

And yes, based on the sheer number of Russian comments found on the Internet you would have to be insane to honestly propose that these are only coming from emigrants

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by aethant on Sunday October 11, 2015 @08:13PM (#10371768)
There is rampant blocking of religious freedom in Russia - online and in real life, enforced by government and England's by the Orthodox Church. It is a regime and it is a tyranny.
Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by DominikR on Wednesday October 14, 2015 @07:23PM (#10390234)
What is "blocking of religious freedom" even supposed to mean? Do you mean the freedom to be a Sunni Jihadist or following some other school of extremist indoctrination?
Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by TazeTSchnitzel on Sunday October 11, 2015 @02:08PM (#10370266)
> Additionally Russians can access all Western media whenever they like and they do so often, especially the urbanized population.

East Germans could get West German television.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by tptacek on Sunday October 11, 2015 @01:56PM (#10370227)
It's pretty easy to consolidate reported public support when your government has nationalized the bulk of the media, and exerts economic and coercive violent pressure on the opposition press.
Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by DominikR on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:06AM (#10391603)
Media is in Russia overwhelmingly owned by private shareholders, so please get your facts straight.
Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by hackerboos on Sunday October 11, 2015 @04:41PM (#10370890)
Same could be said for Singapore substituting violent pressure for legal pressure.
Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by guard-of-terra on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:21PM (#10372339)
Singapore is successful, Russia is crumbling. That's the main difference.

Of course it always depends on perspective. There are some people who would claim relative success of Singapore not compensating restrictions, and yet some other people would claim even North Korea is doing okay so stop insulting them.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by guard-of-terra on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:08AM (#10369536)
"Democratically elected" for some value of. Take voting in North Caucasus, for example, where official turnover is 99% but tens of percents say in polls that they never go to elections.

But. Putin stole elections to Duma. Those were totally baked, and to make matters more humiliating, they did it in Moscow, they outright rewrote results, they let same people to vote dozens of times, they threw batches of fake votes into bins. This is widely documented.

Do you think this will be forgotten? Do you think this will never shoot back?

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by DominikR on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:47AM (#10369710)
> Take voting in North Caucasus, for example, where official turnover is 99% but tens of percents say in polls that they never go to elections.

You know Chechens are the most fervent Russian nationalists today? They experienced the joys of living under an extremist Islamic caliphate for a few years between the first and the second Chechen war. Today they'll vote for any strongman that will ensure stability and security in the region. And that my friend is currently Putin.

> But. Putin stole elections to Duma. Those were totally baked

Yes sure. When Western opinion research reaches the conclusion that 85-90% of Russians support Putins policies it obviously makes a lot of sense to "steal" elections.

> This is widely documented.

Where? In the CIA fact sheet?

> Do you think this will be forgotten? Do you think this will never shoot back?

Please spare us all of this childish rhetoric.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by powera on Sunday October 11, 2015 @02:00PM (#10370241)
I think he's claiming that the official election results are blatantly not true, since they claim "99% of voters voted", but over 10% of the population claims to be voters that did not vote in the election.
Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by guard-of-terra on Sunday October 11, 2015 @11:18PM (#10372333)
It's irrelevant how fervent you are when you are presumed voting when you actually don't.

I don't know how much sense does it make to steal elections; nontheless it has been done.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by guard-of-terra on Sunday October 11, 2015 @03:58AM (#10368489)
Weren't strict restrictions on alcohol a Gorbachev thing?

Anyway, this is not the lesson, it's just one lesson.

Re:Moral causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union (2011) by pandaman on Sunday October 11, 2015 @04:21AM (#10368530)
>Weren't strict restrictions on alcohol a Gorbachev thing?

Indeed, Andropov did the opposite by lowering vodka's price, hence "andropovka" name for the "Moskovskaya" vodka.