News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Qualcomm enters server CPU market with 24-core ARM chip by userbinator on Saturday October 10, 2015 @12:14PM (#10365940)
the problem is that all of them are kinda crap, and most importantly don't have a well established ecosystem

I'd say performance was the more important factor, as most of the early non-Intel x86 were physically compatible (drop-in replacements) - and many were actually faster than Intel's CPUs, but Intel (and to some extent AMD) quickly caught up and passed them. The P6 (Pentium Pro/II/III) is when Intel really started pulling away from the rest.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_former_IA-32_compatibl...

Note: MediaTek is Taiwanese and also fabless. Their phone SoCs are nowhere near as performant as Qualcomm's or Samsung's, and largely viewed as the low-cost "value" option.

Re:Qualcomm enters server CPU market with 24-core ARM chip by dogma1138 on Saturday October 10, 2015 @12:27PM (#10365979)
As far as the x86 goes if you count the original 486/386 family then yeah, but ever since the Pentium only AMD could some what compete with Intel the performance arena.

I remember having to get a non-Intel 486 CPU that would plug into a daughter board that would sit in the original socket and it was some what faster than the 486DX that it replaced.

And yes I am very well that MediaTek is fabless and they cannot compete with QC as far as it comes to performance but they aren't dirt cheap either, and some of their newer SOC's are actually quite decent. They are however pretty much the only example of an established "Chinese" (Lets not get political here because people don't really differentiate between Taiwan and China when it comes to manufacturing, and most Taiwanese companies these days will actually manufacture in China because it's cheaper) ARM manufacturer I haven't seen any other one that can design their own SOC's that would actually work well and be commercially viable even for global products.

Re:Qualcomm enters server CPU market with 24-core ARM chip by solnyshok on Saturday October 10, 2015 @07:14PM (#10367371)
do you think Samsung can enter this market? they have Exynos for mobiles already.
Re:Qualcomm enters server CPU market with 24-core ARM chip by dogma1138 on Sunday October 11, 2015 @01:45PM (#10370189)
The question if they want too, they'll not only have to design a CPU but an entire eco-system around it.

I personally see ARM becoming a potential player through another vector.

We already have various "open-cloud" alliances that design their own reference servers, network equipment and storage.

As ARM being a relatively easy ISA to license it wouldn't surprise me if the likes of Google and Facebook would license it them selves and then come out with their open server architecture which will include an ARM based CPU.

Facebook has released their ethernet switches and server reference designs a while ago, HP has only recently released OpenSwitch which is opensource OS for networking devices, Intel is also getting into the game with their own echo system "Intel Open Network Platform".

To me this form of market penetration seems to be much likely than a slow attempt to creep into the market and in one form or another is pretty much mandatory current datacenter users to switch to ARM en masse. Especially considering just how fragmented the ARM market is, there are allot of different ARM ISA's and even more implementations of those ISA's which aren't necessarily directly compatible.

If we take Exynos as an example then the custom ARM cores that Samsung developed caused quite a bit of software compatibility issue which is one of the reasons why Exynos devices aren't that popular in the Android development community. Heck it was even an issue for 1st party Samsung software anything that didn't run in a VM had to be compiled/redeveloped for Exynos which meant that even software like Samsung GearVR didn't work on Exynos devices initially.

Which is precisely why i think that a uniform compatible ISA and design from an investment consortium is required for ARM to work out it's kinks and take on the server market. Anything that was compiled for x86 for the past what 30 years will work on Intel's current CPU lines. Yes newer CPU's with additional features, extended instruction sets and their respective supported compilers will enable you to run you software more efficiently if you want to invest additional development resources, but if we talk about low level programming the same cannot be said for ARM in all cases which is a big issue at least as I see it.

Re:Qualcomm enters server CPU market with 24-core ARM chip by maaku on Saturday October 10, 2015 @01:03PM (#10366110)
Technically it is Intel that competes for the AMD64 market ;)