News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mcv on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:10AM (#10360529)
Did Myriad really claim to own the gene itself as their invention? If so, there are a lot of people who'd probably like to sue them for infecting them with that invention.

It seems to me that all Myriad could possibly patent, is a unique detection method for that gene. But that wouldn't stop anyone from using a different detection method.

But what interests me more about this case is that the article expects an Australian court decision to be taken as global jurisprudence. What's the logic behind that? And is that really where we're headed?

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by dbbolton on Friday October 09, 2015 @02:07PM (#10362146)
SCOTUS struck down patents on naturally occurring gene sequences themselves and decided that the "mere isolation" thereof cannot be patented:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ass%27n_for_Molecular_Patholog...

However, "artificial" sequences can be. I'm not aware of any test cases that establish boundaries on the difference though. It would be logical to assume you'd have to alter the nucleotide sequence to the extent that the resulting peptide or protein is not naturally occurring (e.g. changing a TTT codon to TTC wouldn't suffice, since both will ultimately be translated into phenylalanine).

Contrary to this reasoning, complementary DNA is patentable in the US on the grounds that it's "not naturally occurring". So, if you take the mRNA corresponding to an un-patentable DNA sequence and mix it with a few enzymes and nucleotides that react in a deterministic fashion, you can then patent the sequence of the final product:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complementary_DNA

In a gross oversimplification, it's almost as if the court said: "you can't patent natural English words, but you can patent the ROT13 versions of them".

But regarding methods, the majority opinion clearly said they're fair game (just as you can't patent gold, but you could patent a novel approach to mining or extracting it) and there are several valid examples in the US today:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_patents_in_the_Unit...

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by AnimalMuppet on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:38AM (#10360737)
> But what interests me more about this case is that the article expects an Australian court decision to be taken as global jurisprudence. What's the logic behind that?

I wondered that, too. But in a parallel comment, ihodes pointed out that this was already ruled unpatentable by the US court system. Courts do keep an eye on decisions from other nations; if they find the logic convincing, they're likely to adopt it. So if the US and Australia are following the same logic, it's likely to be adopted pretty much universally.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by legohead on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:02PM (#10361531)
The article mentions that the US Supreme Court already denied them a patent. The fact another well-developed country has denied them solidifies the ruling.