News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rayiner on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:50AM (#10359977)
The question is: what kind of valuable things would still be produced? You'll still get iPhones, but will you get ARM cores or Snapdragon chipsets or LTE or MPEG4 or pills that cure Hep-C?

The bigger picture is that almost all hard R&D takes place under the umbrella of some sort of protection from copying. Intel spends billions a year on semiconductor R&D, and protects it with trade secrets. Pharma companies spend billions on drug R&D and protect them with patents. Even internet companies like Google and Facebook depend on being able to hide a lot of their "secret sauce" (either algorithms or compilations of user information) on the server-side where it can't be easily copied.

Hard R&D that isn't protected from copying is usually subsidized. The core internet protocols were subsidized by the Government. Advances in core browser protocols are subsidized by Internet companies that rely heavily on ad revenue. Going back further in history, Bell Labs was subsidized by AT&T's telephone monopoly and PARC was subsidized by Xerox's copier monopoly. That model can work too, but has its own problems.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by icanhackit on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:12AM (#10360122)
You make some compelling points but I'm still not convinced that this form of protectionism is the only avenue to innovation. The strength of a company is often in its organization, processes, location, and systems which are difficult to copy in a cohesive way without being gifted with similar circumstances. Why can't a company's strength and success in the marketplace be defined by these characteristics as opposed to legislative shields? Winner-takes-all systems often shape organizational behavior to be more defensive than creative.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by kbenson on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:48AM (#10360350)
Let's not reduce this argument to innovation for companies. Individuals innovate and patent as well.

There is a tendency to focus purely on the negative effects of a system that seems to be failing it's purpose. It's important to understand the system as a whole, and it's history. Has the patent system ever functioned for the purpose it was designed for? If it isn't functioning correctly now, is that in part or in whole? Is it not functioning because it has been changed, because the world has changed, or both.

Finally, is there a way to alter the system, whether that be to curtail it, expand it, or just change how it operates, that might yield a better functioning system?

Personally, I'm not for abolishing patents. They had a very clearly defined purpose (innovation encouragement) when they were first created. I think they've been mostly perverted into another purpose (wealth protection), more-so in some industries than others. They've been expanded from court rulings to cover things which were not originally thought patentable. What we need here is a well reasoned legislative overhaul. What we'll get if we're extremely lucky is a hole-ridden clusterfuck of revisions, but if we're lucky, it will somewhat address the current problems. The new problems will be something we discover and address tomorrow.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by sdenton4 on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:47PM (#10361969)
Individual patents are a corner case that's hardly worth sneezing about. They typically come up in these sorts of conversations in the same way that, say, Monsanto will cry about protecting small farmers while proposing rule changes that let it get away with whole new classes of abuse...
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JoeAltmaier on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:50AM (#10360371)
I don't think you can disentangle those two purposes. Innovation is encouraged precisely because you can profit from your invention.

I believe the cost and delay of patent litigation is the real problem. It's important to identify the critical issue before effective change can happen.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by kbenson on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:59AM (#10360435)
My point was when wealth protection is a tool to bolster innovation, then the incentives are aligned correctly. When people, or more importantly legislators, forget that and think the purpose of patents is to reward for innovation, we get some perverse incentives. In a perfect world, protection would be inversely proportional to the amount of innovation the sector is experiencing, and would also be scaled to the amount the innovation helps. But those are both hard to measure realistically.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by novaleaf on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:44AM (#10360307)
> I'm still not convinced that this form of protectionism is the only avenue to innovation.

Protections of inventions (as loose as the term "invention" might be) isn't the only avenue to innovation, but it is an avenue.

There is always going to be a pull between free/open and paid/private. It's a good thing that multiple avenues exist, because some public-good innovations may happen under one regime but not the other.

Also, I take issue with the terms of the "it should be free" conversation here. The patent isn't for the gene: the company does not hold the rights to your DNA. The patent is for the discovery of it's link to cancer.

In this exact circumstance, I question how long it would take for this gene to be identified as a causal-link to breast cancer if there was not the bait of a financial windfall. Is there a smoking gun that shows this company beat out a public institution to this discovery?

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JoshTriplett on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:39AM (#10360745)
We could ask, though, which R&D gets protected by patents but not by copyright or trade secrets? Which R&D would not produce a return on investment if patents didn't exist?

Drug research, perhaps, though we might be able to find other solutions there, or produce a much more limited form of patent for that industry alone. What else currently depends fundamentally on patents for its business model?

Looking at the many groups working on FOSS media codecs past and present (VP8, VP9, AoM, Opus, Vorbis), I'd say the media situation would actually get better in the absence of patents.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rancur on Saturday October 10, 2015 @02:47AM (#10364745)
media requires algorithm which isn't supposed to be patentable but because software is sOoOo complex it got shoehorned into patentability. I think we just need to loosen up the ties a little
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JoeAltmaier on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:55AM (#10360008)
Marketing is at least as important as technology. Intel sells chips, not because there are no alternatives, but because they're Intel.

There will be little or no impact on innovation by this patent change.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by toomuchtodo on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:48PM (#10361396)
I want to point out that SpaceX doesn't patent any of their tech, as their competitors are sovereign states that would have no problem copying the technology.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rayiner on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:21PM (#10361704)
SpaceX is a great example of the Google/Facebook situation. When you sell a service, and not a product people can take apart and reverse-engineer, you've got built-in protection from copying.

Pervasive Internet and the move to putting logic on the server definitely outmodes many uses for patents, though. Take Siri. SRI invented the technology, spun off a company with the IP, which was purchased by Apple. I don't think that transaction would've happened without patent protection. But today you have an alternative model. Instead of licensing voice recognition technology for integration into products, you can provide the algorithm as a service. Now, the source code stays safely on the server side where nobody can decompile it to figure out how it works.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by toomuchtodo on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:26PM (#10361741)
This is very true. At the same time though, through the commidification of computing resources, as well as tooling continuing to advance, open source alternatives are reaching parity.

Humor me. When Gmail first came out, it was revolutionary. Now, you could host your own clone for $10-20/month using containerized Elastic Search indexing all of your email, with a small virtual machine ingesting your email from the internet, and providing it to you over JSON to your local mail client or through a web interface.

Voice recognition could follow the same trajectory. Computing power will increase, storage costs will continue to plummet (I've mentioned this multiple times on HN, but Samsung is predicting 128TB SSD drives in 3 years).

You don't need patents anymore, as you mentioned, because you can provide the service, not the underlying source code. But you still need to monetize quickly (if that's your goal), because the rising tide of technology can quickly supplant your lead with other competitors or open source options.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rayiner on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:32PM (#10361805)
Maybe or maybe not. Open source still lags far behind when it comes to "hard" algorithms that require domain expertise to design: OCR, handwriting recognition, voice recognition, etc.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by dragonwriter on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:00PM (#10361519)
Boeing is a sovereign state?
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by toomuchtodo on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:03PM (#10361550)
Oh come now. Boeing and the ULA are not SpaceX competitors. They're a last gasp attempt to keep the existing pork/gravy train of cost plus contracting and congressional district graft in place.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by dragonwriter on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:12PM (#10361619)
> Boeing and the ULA are not SpaceX competitors. They're a last gasp attempt to keep the existing pork/gravy train of cost plus contracting and congressional district graft in place.

No, Boeing and the other ULA members (both as ULA and separately) are SpaceX competitors for (particularly) government contract work, what you call "congressional district graft" is part of the game they play to maximize the value and duration of those contracts (to make them politically hard to curtail), but aren't what they exist to support -- you've got what is being served and what is serving reversed.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by toomuchtodo on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:17PM (#10361657)
We'll agree to disagree (I don't mean any offense). SpaceX exists to drive the cost of launch services down. Boeing and the ULA exist to profit. My opinion, of course.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by dragonwriter on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:28PM (#10361758)
SpaceX isn't a charity. It exists to profit, even if it is funded by investors who are willing to accept not profiting in the short term to build the business to the point where it can operate profitably.

Now, in order to profit, it has to differentiate itself from incumbents somehow, and the opportunity it is built around to do that is regarding efficiencies that allow it to offer launch services at lower costs. But, it is competing directly with ULA for business, as a simple matter of concrete fact.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by scotty79 on Saturday October 10, 2015 @11:41AM (#10365840)
Only 10% of important inventions are patented: http://infojustice.org/archives/31509
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by DannyBee on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:46AM (#10360330)
"The bigger picture is that almost all hard R&D takes place under the umbrella of some sort of protection from copying."

There is a huge difference between protection from copying, and protection from building similar things that achieve the same goal. Patents are not simply "protection from copying".

Drug patents often cover things like "using the same body mechanism to achieve a desired result".

(Now, you can argue this is necessary to protect them, but let's be clear - it's not straight copying if i make a pill with a completely different chemical composition that ends up triggering the same mechanisms. However, it likely runs afoul of their carefully drafted patents.

I'm also aware there are chemical compound patents that would not cover me doing this, but usually, when the drug companies can, they get both)

"Intel spends billions a year on semiconductor R&D, and protects it with trade secrets"

and design mask protection (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_circuit_layout_desi...)

"Pharma companies spend billions on drug R&D and protect them with patents. "

They are also heavily subsidized, unlike your intel example. Tax payers, for example, pay about 50% of pharma's R&D costs (and pharma includes a lot more than actual R&D in R&D cost). http://www.healthnewsreview.org/2012/02/the-costly-myths-abo...

and http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/Columns/2012/02/16/What-Those-...

"Hard R&D that isn't protected from copying is usually subsidized. "

Pharma, one of your examples, is both heavily protected and heavily subsidized. Heck, Intel gets huge R&D tax breaks too.

In truth, most of the heavily protected stuff is subsidized by tax payers in various forms anyway.

The idea that these companies are out there, doing it on their own, without essentially getting most of the R&D cost subsidized through tax breaks/etc, is a huge myth.

We don't have the model you propose. We have a model where it is both heavily protected and heavily subsidized.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rayiner on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:14AM (#10360555)
I'm not saying that protections or subsidies are two exclusive options. I'm saying that one or the other is a necessary condition for many kinds of hard R&D. I agree that in practice we have a mix of both.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by thescriptkiddie on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:58AM (#10360905)
> protects it with trade secrets

Trade secrets, unlike patents and copyrights, are not a legal construct. They're just things you aren't telling anyone.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by adebtlawyer on Saturday October 10, 2015 @01:18PM (#10366156)
They could exist without protection from the legal system, but to the extent that they are protected by courts, they are a legal construct. In the US, there is more to them than 'things you aren't telling anyone' and you are not necessarily without legal remedy if someone finds out your trade secret.