News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by JdeBP on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:35PM (#10357816)
This is nothing new, of course. NeXTStep introduced things like ~/Apps, /LocalLibrary, and /LocalApps back in the early 1990s.

Daniel J. Bernstein, around the turn of the century, proposed a /package hierarchy (for package management without the need for conflict resolution) and a /command directory. (http://cr.yp.to/slashpackage.html) Their major problem was the idea that one had to register things with what was to most of the world just some bloke on another continent. But they had concepts like a hierarchical package naming scheme ("admin/", "mail/", &c.), self-contained build trees with versioned names, and an "index" directory full of symbolic links.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by gcb0 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:54PM (#10358059)
the problem is exactly that. some group in an ivory tower refuses to (or can't?) move. most of posix is like that. Linux "standard" for gui stuff is still some definition from IBM to normalize DOS apps (reason why F10 open menus, copy paste with ctrl+ins, shift+ins, etc).

then people that can't work together with others (eg Jobs) does retarded things like /localLibrary which benefit nobody, not even themselves. just throw everything up. then if those folks succeed despite that, it becomes the new immutable thing to follow, like gnome is doing with following blindly apple ui specs.

edit: i never tried to contribute to any larger standard. i did develop against most of them, cursed at their anachronistic ways and coded around it praising consistency. so i am pretty sure i am part of the problem described above. I'm not saying the fine people in those ivory towers are the problem. I'm glad we have that little help for world consistency. it's just not enough.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by JdeBP on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:19AM (#10359508)
You're taking received wisdom from Wikipedia, and it's wrong. Common User Access was for normalizing IBM applications, across its then hardware platforms: the PC, System/3x, and System/370. Indeed, it's most promiment PC success was 32-bit IBM OS/2, which implemented the later CUA 91 and which most definitely wasn't DOS.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by gcb0 on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:38PM (#10362764)
well, whatever the actual reason, i actually (used to) consult it when writing CURSE applications only because it is the closest we have for a curses application usability standard.

where it came from originally is not much of concern. but the fact that it is the best we have, is.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by spacemanmatt on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:43PM (#10364143)
It wasn't bad. I appreciate the attempt to reduce my cognitive load.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by smegger001 on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:13AM (#10358302)
I do not seem to understand, so forgive my ignorance if you will but; Why do we need a /Apps directory isn't that what /bin /sbin and /usr/bin are for? And as for /LocalApps is that not what /home/$user/bin is for? this seems fairly redundant, or needless wheel reinventing?
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by wtallis on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:36AM (#10358634)
On NeXTSTEP and OS X, the /Apps (/Applications) directory is for self-contained application bundles that hold a GUI application and all of its dependencies that aren't part of the base OS, and they can be installed and removed by dragging and dropping that one bundle (which is a directory, but appears in the graphical file manager as a single object). There was also a distinction between locally-installed stuff and network resources which made things a little more complex but more manageable if you were actually working in an office full of NeXT boxes. OS X still has /usr and it still has pretty much the same meaning, but GUI apps live in a separate and more user-friendly domain.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by pjmlp on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:46AM (#10358663)
Known on Windows world as xcopy install, due to the similar way MS-DOS software used to be bundled and everyone used xcopy instead of the pretty basic copy that didn't do recursive copies.

But sadly it doesn't present the nice object concept NeXTSTEP and OS X have.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by nailer on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:07AM (#10358568)
Not advocating for one of the other, but they're not the same. /Apps is based on the application that supplied the files, /usr vs / is based on whether necessary to boot the OS, /bin vs /lib vs /share based on the file type.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by BinaryIdiot on Friday October 09, 2015 @02:38AM (#10358505)
Probably just more intuitive more than anything else. Someone without prior knowledge to the operating system (or even computers in general) and things like /Apps is really obvious where as /bin and /sbin understanding is really going to depending on how much someone knows about computers.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by lottin on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:27AM (#10358617)
As far as I know, /Apps is for packages that ship with their own versions of shared libraries and everything else the program needs to run; all files are installed in one directory under /Apps, instead of where they actually belong in the Unix directory structure.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by rakoo on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:46AM (#10359630)
/bin and friends are for binaries only. For a full package you also want libraries, man pages, configuration files etc... Those are usually bundled as a .tar.gz which would ideally be the best way to bundle and distribute a program.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by brbsix on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:55AM (#10359064)
This sounds somewhat similar to /opt (albeit more complicated), wherein programs are located in /opt/package or /opt/provider. For example, the entirety of Sublime Text is stored in /opt/sublime_text and Google programs are stored in subdirs of /opt/google.