Re:Why Lisp is Awesome
by abstractbill on Wednesday January 06, 2010 @04:07PM
(#1035762)
Right. Mainstream languages have been gradually evolving towards Lisp but until they adopt a simple uniform syntax they won't get real macros, which I think is the biggest difference between Lisp and other languages today.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I believe that appreciating Lisp's minimalistic, tree-like syntax requires a very mathematical way of thinking. Many (perhaps most) developers have a different way of thinking. There's nothing wrong with that, diversity is a good thing but because of that, I don't think that the S-Expression syntax will ever become "mainstream".
Re:Why Lisp is Awesome
by abstractbill on Wednesday January 06, 2010 @04:22PM
(#1035798)
I think I agree... I'm undecided though. I actually find JSON to be a positive development, and potentially a step in this direction (i.e. the fact that people now use javascript literal data syntax as a way of serializing general data, and the syntax has been written down somewhere quite carefully and is not too verbose or ugly - at least compared to something like xml). Who knows how far the mainstream will take this though...
It is already.
XML is full of prefix, nested syntax.
Re:Why Lisp is Awesome
by abstractbill on Wednesday January 06, 2010 @06:56PM
(#1036129)
Yes, but nobody would seriously write a programming language that used XML for its syntax.
So you say existing XML-based programming languages were 'written' by non-serious people?
'Water':
<defmethod test_true source=required="ek_string">
<try <if> source.<execute_string/>.<not/>
<concat "Busted: "source/>.<print/>
else “OK”
</if>
>
<concat "Errored: " source/>.<print/>
</try>
</defmethod>
See also XSLT, XL, RuleML, ...
Re:Why Lisp is Awesome
by abstractbill on Wednesday January 06, 2010 @08:17PM
(#1036233)
So you say existing XML-based programming languages were 'written' by non-serious people?
Whether or not the people who wrote (sorry, I guess "designed" is the more appropriate word) these languages were serious, I do believe they are a dead-end.