News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kuschku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:56PM (#10355655)
The issue is, this is how profitable it is effectively – any driver following the law will have to pay this much.

And this is why uber can only currently provide their high margins because they provide no insurance between rides (only during rides), because they don’t follow laws, etc.

It’s unfair competition, and sadly, people expect Lyft to offer the same.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by SilasX on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:12PM (#10355815)
IMHO, this is a misconception. Most of the benefit of Lyft/Uber comes from app convenience, being cashless, mutual rating to weed out the jerks, carpooling efficiency, transparency (easy to get estimates and know if you overpaid), good customer support, and reliability in getting a ride, all of which are legal and which cab companies could have done.

They have a lot of room to raise prices before it outweighs those advantages. Remember, people were using UberBlack (as "UberCab" way back then), which simply took existing, fully-insured car service drivers, which had no regulatory advantage, long before UberX/Lyft.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by ssmoot on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:23PM (#10355899)
Room to raise prices in very dense areas maybe. Uber is only viable in a lot of places (like DFW) because their rates are much much lower than the per-mile Yellow Cab rates that came before. Here you had to decide wether the (not all that convenient) convenience of a taxi to the movies on date-night was actually worth $40 each way and a half hour's wait to you. Where at maybe $15 each way and a 5 minute wait with Uber it's a no-brainer.

At least that's my experience.

Never been to San Francisco. But in Chicago or NYC I generally use Uber just because most taxi drivers seem to only drive at 99% of their limits and it's stressful. The Uber drivers are much more sedate generally. IME.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by lsc on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:54PM (#10356134)
>Most of the benefit of Lyft/Uber comes from app convenience, being cashless, mutual rating to weed out the jerks, carpooling efficiency, transparency (easy to get estimates and know if you overpaid), good customer support, and reliability in getting a ride, all of which are legal and which cab companies could have done.

You are ignoring the speed of getting a ride. I mean, all those things would help a lot for cabs, but if I had to wait half an hour, even if I knew it would only be half an hour, while that would be better than my previous cab experience, it still wouldn't be very useful.

If you want me to use the cab regularly, your average wait time needs to be 5 minutes or less. This means you need a lot of cabs on the road... a lot more than were in my area before this.

I'll put up with a lot of other bullshit, but if you make me wait, I'm not going to use your service, full stop.

I'm not sure that would be possible under the previous regulations. Improving dispatch only takes you so far; at some point you need more cabs on the road.

>They have a lot of room to raise prices before it outweighs those advantages. Remember, people were using UberBlack (as "UberCab" way back then), which simply took existing, fully-insured car service drivers, which had no regulatory advantage, long before UberX/Lyft.

Now, here's where we need to stop and remember that the average HN user makes a lot more money than the average person. Yes, for you and me? it's about convenience.

That's the thing, I'd be fine paying uber black rates; but waiting is not a luxury experience. At the same price, I'd much rather ride in a ratty honda that shows up in four minutes than take a limo that takes twenty minutes.

But there are a lot of people for whom the price matters a whole lot. There are more of them than there are of us, by a lot. If Uber only wants to keep me as a customer, yes, they can double prices for me. but their customer base is massively larger if they are cheaper than cabs, and the larger their customer base, the more cars they will have wandering around, and the less time I need to wait for a car.

I suspect that if uber doubled their prices, their ridership (and thus drivers on the road) would fall to the point where my wait times would increase to the point where I would no longer find the service interesting.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by on_ on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:34PM (#10355976)
100% agree. That is why it has been successful. The magnitude would certainly be less if the cost was more because demand is elastic, but head to head with cabs they would dominate at the same price. It is an efficient way to manage resources and just a great thing.

"Breaking Laws" is maybe a bit strong, as regulation is extremely bulky and a monolithic unequippted government isn't in the position to adapt. The laws vary on every level but what I think it comes down to, in a society that teies to be democratic, is whether people are comfortable with this existing. It seems they are.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kuschku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:18PM (#10356749)
In my country, the laws for driving a taxi-like service (but without being allowed to use taxi spots, etc) are:

* Have commercial insurance

* Have a "people-driving drivers license", which allows you to drive commercially taxis, busses, trams, etc. Costs 55€.

Uber is even refusing to follow the insurance part – they only insure during rides, but not when the person commercially drives with their car to the start of a ride.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by bsder on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:57PM (#10356169)
As much as I hate the serfitude economy companies, the fact that the cab companies have not adopted the app approach boggles my mind.

I would have zero problem calling a cab, even with the regulated cab prices, if they had a Lyft/Uber-like app. Hit the button, accepted in 60 seconds, tracked to your door. The fact that the cab companies simply won't do this grinds my gears.

This is also why Lyft/Uber grind my gears. JUST BE A COMPETENT CAB COMPANY and people would love you. Uber/Lyft doesn't have to flout the existing laws while lobbying to get them changed.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by SilasX on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:02PM (#10356210)
Curb and Flywheel don't meet your criteria?
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kuschku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:02PM (#10356645)
But the cab company did adopt this approach! Already in 2008!

I literally have like 5 different taxi apps here offering me paying via app, rating, calling a taxi per button press, etc.

And they existed before uber did.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kuschku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:04PM (#10356654)
So, if I have here:

Taxi service, provides rating, has app, can pay and rate via app, fully insured, hired and trained drivers, transparent rate (rate set by law and shown in app), guaranteed arrival, etc.

And it costs 5€ less than uber.

And it existed since 2008.

What I am wondering is why this only caught on in some european cities, but never worldwide?

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by SilasX on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:55PM (#10356955)
Good question, I'd have to know more about the specific service. It sounds like it started in Europe, where there wasn't a big enough improvement over what cabs already provided.
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kuschku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:07PM (#10357015)
Well, it’s just a service of the taxi companies themselves – they decided to offer it to be better than competing taxi companies.

And they never really expanded over Europe and South America.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by SilasX on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:24PM (#10357100)
What is the name of the specific app you have in mind that is 5 Euros less than Uber and has ratings and driver tracking.
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kuschku on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:29PM (#10357126)
There are many existing, one that is supported by the local taxi drivers in my city would be http://www.taxi.eu/en/
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by SilasX on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:17PM (#10361659)
Well, now I have to admit confusion. I downloaded it and poked around, and it seems to be put together pretty well and has all the features from Uber. My best guess is that they started in a place where taxis were generally "good enough" already and didn't market it as hard, but it definitely competes well along the dimensions I gave before.
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kuschku on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:52PM (#10362011)
Well, they didn’t care about expansion.

But you have to know: My region had a dozen of these apps, all competing with each other.

So, the only reason why people used uber was that sometimes it was cheaper. But that only because they ignored the laws.

German Taxi market is a seriously free market, and uber can’t compete fairly.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by SilasX on Friday October 09, 2015 @02:58PM (#10362514)
Interesting, that definitely gives some perspective on why Uber has taken so much more flak in Europe than the US, where the taxi market is uncompetitive and routinely tries to take advantage of passengers.
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kuschku on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:08PM (#10363290)
But keep in mind: This is only Germany.

Italy, France, etc still have insanely overprotective markets.

Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by kazinator on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:59PM (#10355688)
Speaking of insurance, I was going over the terms of the car rental insurance coverage in one of my credit cards. It explicitly states that if you rent a car in order to provide a transportation service for hire, you are not covered. Oops!
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by tswartz on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:01PM (#10355707)
Yes, I saw a similar stipulation in regular car insurance. Unfortunately, I don't think a lot of drivers read the fine print.
Re:New Initiatives for Lyft Drivers by shostack on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:41PM (#10356039)
Another reason Uber can do this is because they have large amounts of money riding on doing away with human-driven vehicles entirely. Once they get there, they will fire their entire driver-base so quickly it will make heads spin. They just need to make it that far.