News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ctdonath on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:10AM (#10353243)
For all the discussion (i.e.: heated biased arguing) about poverty, seems nobody has addressed an objective definition of what constitutes "poor". Why is the world poverty line at $1.25/day, but the US poverty line is 20x that? We need a quantitative analysis, starting with basic caloric/nutritional/BTU/water/power/data/etc needs (independent of arbitrary numbers imputed by fiat/floating currencies) for cost of bare sustenance, then work from there recognizing that varying geography, demographics, et al adjusts that cost, then admitting that different cultures further adjust those basic costs.

Without such objective analysis of basic sustenance, fudging numbers is trivial.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by maxerickson on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:25AM (#10353345)
That's more or less what the World Bank is doing. The dollars per day are PPP adjusted, which attempts to account for all of those things you are talking about.

http://blogs.worldbank.org/developmenttalk/international-pov...

I guess there is lots of room to quibble over how objective it is, but it is at least starting from the idea of doing an objective quantative analysis of the issue.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by devinhelton on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:21AM (#10353314)
Yes, exactly. The numbers I would like to see measured would be:

- percent of people who can afford 2,500 calories of food and 60 grams of animal protein a day (where afford has some standard definition, such as can pay for the consumption using less than half of their income).

- percent of people who have access to clean water

- percent of people with indoor plumbing

- percent of people with access to electricity in the home.

- percent of people who can access and afford 500MB of internet data a month

It is impossible to know what "$2 a day" actually means. The number gets adjusted for purchasing power, but there is an infinite amount of room in that calculation for governments to fudge the data. Many people in the third world can afford a cell phone, but not afford enough protein in their diet, does that mean they are richer or poorer than someone one hundred years ago without a cell phone but who can afford meat? There is no objective way to answer that question. Since I do not know all the subjective decisions made in doing the purchasing power adjustment, the ultimate number tells me nothing.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by sanxiyn on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:04PM (#10354076)
> percent of people who have access to clean water

This number is actually measured, because it is target 7.C of MDG(Millennium Development Goals). Lots of data at http://mdgs.un.org/.

Summary is that we are doing very well on this number. In 1990 it was 76%, now it is 91%. In the absolute number, 2.6 billion people gained access to clean water in the period.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by GordonS on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:25AM (#10353339)
Why specifically animal protein and not just protein?

(I'm not a vegetarian or anything like that, it's a serious question)

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by devinhelton on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:43AM (#10353486)
Well, ideally we could measure and track the stats for both. Animal protein is generally a more complete protein. If we tracked just "protein" do we count incomplete proteins? Do we count textured vegetable protein?
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by sliverstorm on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:35AM (#10353423)
Animal protein is generally both more desirable and more expensive. Generally animal protein is a complete protein source, whereas most plants are not.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by GordonS on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:27AM (#10353355)
> percent of people who can access and afford 500MB of internet data a month

I don't think I'd include Internet access in any definition of 'extreme poverty'.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by CoryG89 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:57PM (#10354006)
You're right here. I don't think I'd use it for extreme poverty. I might use it as a way to measure 'the poor' though. Although, the relative adjusted cost of 500MB of internet data is going to vary greatly depending on the networking infrastructure of their country. It may not accurately describe the wealth of the people.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by swampthinker on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:27AM (#10353372)
Honestly, I would take out the internet requirement. All the others can significantly improve quality of life in a home, but I can't truely say the same about internet access.

I'd love to hear the counterpoints, but I just can't imagine a farmer needing internet access to live a comfortable lifestyle, as opposed to clean water and electricity, which is necessary.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ctdonath on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:52AM (#10353532)
It's not so much about internet access, but information access (to wit: why public libraries were invented). Using his example of 500MB/month, that could easily cover a box set of the Foxfire books (extensive details on how to live off the land) one month, canonical classic literature in one's language the next, etc. Part of being "not poor" is qualitatively having the means to improve one's living condition, which very much includes means to learn how to improve.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:18PM (#10354217)
A farmer who strives for self-sustainability will not need Internet access for comfortable life. But a poor person living in a city - trying to escape poverty by getting closer with society, not further from it - might find it pretty useful. Such people often spend big amounts of time dealing with government institutions, trying to enroll and stay enrolled in the local welfare and jobs programmes - in some countries having Internet access can significantly speed up/streamline this process.

In general, a lot of extremely poor people in urban areas suffer more from the lack of predictable time slots than lack of money. When doing multiple temporary jobs with flexible hours, adjusted at a moment's notice, you can't really plan anything ahead. You barely have enough time to do groceries, let alone pick a shop that has a given item cheaper, and forget about any service that requires an appointment. Internet access solves a lot of these issues by allowing you to do things a) at random hours, and b) without having to physicly go somewhere.

Also on-line ordering usually gives you cheaper everything; hell, even groceries may be worth getting delivered if it frees up a time slot during the day that could be better spent taking care of something else, or even playing with one's kid.

Then there are things like Craigslist and other benefits of instant, pretty much free long-distance communication. One could list on and on. But the main point is - in all but the few least developed countries, Internet access can give huge quality of life improvements to the poor.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by GordonS on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:30AM (#10353388)
Internet access could certainly help, for example, a farmer, as it could give access to information on better farming techniques, where to source better value fertilisers, where to get the best price for produce etc.

But I certainly agree that it doesn't play any part in the definition of 'extreme poverty'.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by phil21 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:09PM (#10357028)
I was going to make a similar comment, but this boils down to information asymmetry. For how cheap it is to deliver reasonable Internet access to everyone, I put it up there with the same importance as most utilities. If you're building out electricity to a farmer, you can certainly add Internet infrastructure onto that for very little relative cost.

Why should giant corporations buying the farmers products have access to nearly limitless amounts of information, while the farmer is relegated to maybe an industry periodical and the local cafe gossip. That worked before the 1900's, but these days information moves too quickly.

So yes, I think Internet is probably not quite yet essentially a basic need to participate in the economy and society - but it's pretty damn close. And it's only going to continue to get more important as "old world" services are turned off in favor of those on-line. In my lifetime I will see the DMV close it's last in-person renewal desk. And the private world is already there in requiring online-only transactions to do certain forms of business.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by devinhelton on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:47AM (#10353505)
I was going beyond measuring just "extreme poverty" to measuring general economic development. In the modern world, internet is really important because you can need it to do business, order products, look up information, get reading material, get educated, etc, etc. Many developing countries never had public libraries, or homes filled with books, so the internet is way of granting access to essential information in a digital form.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by xacaxulu on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:50AM (#10353514)
Mostly agree, but I would argue that requiring animal protein could be optional, especially with the follow-on climactic effects that raising so much animal meat causes. There are a number of cultures and sub-groups that are perfectly healthy without animal protein.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by Wintamute on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:40AM (#10353460)
Where are your references that this, or some similar methodology, isn't how the World Bank arrived at its figures? Don't you think they would have thought pretty seriously about what an objective measure for "extremely poor" is? Perhaps $1.90/day is a statistically valid proxy when thinking globally based on their methodology, perhaps it isn't ~ I don't know and I'm none the wiser from your comment. And where's your evidence that the numbers were "fudged"?
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ctdonath on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:57AM (#10353575)
You're asking me to prove a negative in response to me asking for establishment of positive standards. Sure, the WB probably has some well thought out criteria - and I don't know where to find them, and have reason to believe most everyone else pontificating on the subject aren't sharing those criteria. I've not seen evidence ANYONE has worked out basic human needs to the point that anyone being given such satisfying resources can, and is, declared "not poor".

Of course you're none the wiser from my comment. It was a question (admittedly not bluntly phrased as such): what objectively constitutes "poor"?

Many in this thread decry the fudging of numbers in the discussion; I'd like something objective which can't really be fudged.

ETA: following another posters' suggested link, seems the WB admittedly arrived at that $1.90/day number by averaging the declared poverty lines of low-GDP/capita countries. That's not the quantitative objective analysis I'm looking for.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by maxerickson on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:25PM (#10353783)
Most of the low GDP poverty lines were established using a cost of basic needs methodology. This looks like the same pdf that World Bank paywalls:

http://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/6645038.pdf

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by mc32 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:47AM (#10353500)
You make some great points that measuring could be improved. Never the less so long as their method remains consistent, it shows the world getting richer or poorer relatively speaking.

For all the antiglobalization sentiment, I can't imagine this happening without globalization. If the workers of the developed world had put an economic moat around themselves and preserved their trend in rising purchasing power and had wages increase undeterred by labor competition from both shipping jobs overseas and allowing mass immigration of unskilled labor, we'd not have seen these improvements and those places, given the pop growth they experience over the last sixty years, would have been severely more impoverished.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by keithwhor on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:51AM (#10353523)
Sure, the poverty line is somewhat arbitrary. Poverty and general well-being are multi-dimensional concepts that are hard to reduce to a single number.

I think you're being a bit pedantic, though. The absolute number of those living in poverty can change with the stroke of a pen according to an arbitrary definition, sure. My interpretation is that the point of the article, and the thing that should be celebrated, is that life is on average getting better for the world community (even if only according to one metric).

I'm sure the data scientist in all of us wants to see "well-being" broken down by vertical. For one, I'm sure the data you're looking for exists, is likely accessible, and it would be intellectually satisfying to our curiosity (who wants to do the legwork? :)). Two, I'd be skeptical of the assumption that they'd show anything but a trend in the same direction (though maybe not all at the same rate).

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by AlisdairO on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:19AM (#10353305)
Note that this is discussing 'extreme poverty', which is distinct from 'poverty'.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ctdonath on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:07PM (#10353652)
Indeed, my next question would involve objectively differentiating the two. I'm starting with the presumption that being above the bottom line at least constitutes a sustainable[1] existence, if not a comfortable one.

[1] "sustainable" as in one can live indefinitely unto a normal lifespan, assorted diseases & incidents aside; don't confuse with "green" energy & resources.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by AlisdairO on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:38PM (#10353870)
Just guessing here, but it would seem reasonable to define extreme poverty as deprivation that substantially impedes one's ability to maintain a decent life expectancy. I might also include very poor access to (say) basic education.

'Poverty' is a rather broader definition, including issues like housing affordability, decent food variety, access to secondary/higher education, perhaps life stability (for example, no access to permanent employment).

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ultramancool on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:28AM (#10353378)
Very good point, still, what does this include. I would think of extreme poverty as those who have extremely limited access to food, water and shelter. Fortunately that is legitimately becoming a smaller and smaller portion of the world I believe so this is a useful stat to track. Still, I have no idea if that's what's being represented here.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by maxerickson on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:39AM (#10353458)
It's a well defined term:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extreme_poverty

(of course, they are redefining it, but there is lots of information available about how the number is set)

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by lhorie on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:25AM (#10353343)
In south american countries, there's a concept called a "basic basket" ( https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canasta_b%C3%A1sica_de_aliment... ) ( https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cesta_b%C3%A1sica ), which, while not standardized, can at least give you a ballpark cost of the basic food needs of an average household for a month.

One could conceivably figure out a reasonably not-out-of-thin-air number for each country by cross referencing the items in an arbitrary basic basket package and supermarket food prices in each country.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by dredmorbius on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:13PM (#10357521)
"Market basket" is in fact how inflation is typically measured universally.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by cuchoi on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:35AM (#10353421)
There has been lots of discussion on this topic. Many countries have a multidimensional measure of poverty, and there is also an international measure for it (http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/multidimensional-poverty-inde...).

The biggest problem is measuring it, so one standard income-based extreme poverty line makes sense in order to compare across countries.

Also, like I said in another comment, this measure of poverty is power purchase parity adjusted, so currency changes should not affect.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ctdonath on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:21PM (#10353742)
Aside: I wish HN had sparklines alongside the "points" for one's posts. The up/down-voting on this thread has been pretty impressive.