News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by cjbenedikt on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:11AM (#10352848)
"More and more analysts, though, are pointing out that this claim is little more than an accounting trick: UN officials have massaged the numbers to make it seem as though poverty has been reduced, when in fact it has increased." http://ssir.org/articles/entry/using_design_thinking_to_erad...
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ef4 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:30PM (#10354331)
That article is highlighting deeply misleading facts. For example: "between 1990 and 2010 there was an increase of 371 million people living on less than $5 a day". But during the same time period, the world added 1.6 billion people, and even using your source's own data, that implies that the fraction of people living on less than $5 a day dropped from 75% to 60%.

In short, the claim that poverty is getting worse is utter bullshit. It requires either climate-change-denialist levels of willful ignorance, or a xenophobic definition of "poverty" that only counts people living in your own much-richer-than-global-average country.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by webXL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:59PM (#10355694)
Good catch, but what does climate-change denial have to do with this? No, really, your "science is settled" attitude detracts from your case.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by mbostleman on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:00PM (#10355198)
"...or a xenophobic definition of "poverty" that only counts people living in your own much-richer-than-global-average country."

In which case you are no longer measuring poverty. You are measuring inequality.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by collyw on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:28PM (#10355942)
Agan it probably depends how you define poverty. If you live somewhere where the land provides enough food for your needs every day, you probably don't need $2 per day.

If you define poverty as never knowing if you will have enough for the next meal then the $2 cutoff is again probably fairly irrelevant.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by squids on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:02PM (#10361536)
Did you factor in inflation into your calculation? By 2010 that 1990 $5 is worth $8.80. So you'd have to look at how many people were living on below that number to get your equivalent.

If i remember correctly, a 1981 $1 is now worth $2.50 if you factor in inflation so the fact they've chose to lower the bar at $1.90 reeks of politics.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by jsprogrammer on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:40PM (#10356502)
You are looking at it in relative terms (total_in_poverty / total).

However, according to your own analysis of the poster's source, the absolute number of people in poverty has increased a lot.

>In short, the claim that poverty is getting worse is utter bullshit.

371 million more people in poverty is not "getting worse"?

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ef4 on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:54PM (#10362040)
Worse vs which baseline scenario?

You're implying that your baseline scenario is a constant absolute number of poor people in the world.

But that scenario is not really constant. If things are getting neither better nor worse, the children of the poor are as poor as their parents, and the absolute number of poor people keeps climbing.

If nothing got better, the number of additional poor people would have been at least 611 million, and that is an under-estimate because poorer people have higher fertility rates.

So yes, "only" 371 million more people in poverty necessarily means things are getting better, when sheer demographics without economic growth would have pushed the number 2x higher.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by mbostleman on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:52AM (#10353537)
When it comes to policy that drives the funding of social programs and wealth redistribution, everything is an accounting trick.

One example is that the US Census Bureau's reporting of poverty statistics based on income has changed to NOT include the income of many benefits including food stamps and the Earned Income Tax Credit. If you include these benefits prior to counting the poor, the poverty rate falls to nearly zero.

This is why the director of the Census Bureau's report now answers to the White House instead of the Director of Commerce. Bending the numbers is essential to maintaining and expanding institutions.

The switch was made when Obama nominated Rebuplican senator Judd Gregg as Commerce Secretary. Given that Gregg had previously voted to abolish the Commerce department, it is likely that his influence would have brought the numbers in line with the facts. But, had Gregg accepted the nomination, it would have opened up a senate seat that would have been filled by the Democratric governor of his state. So to have his cake and eat it too, Obama took control of the number reporting. Gregg did not accept the nomination.

Talk about accounting tricks.

Another example is the disparity between counting income vs. consumption. Again in the US, when the money spent by poorer classes that are studied is counted it is far greater than what is calculated as their income (which is what policy is based on) This indicates that in-kind gifts and other non-reported income is substantial, but not counted.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by vidarh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:19PM (#10353730)
Source? Because the Census Bureau also releases the Supplemental Poverty Measure [1], which amongst other breakdowns includes numbers that adjusts for taxes (if you're going to count for tax credits, you also need to account for taxes paid if the numbers are to make sense), housing benefits, and various in-kind benefits. It also includes various other costs. Table 4a on page 9 gives a breakdown on how different aspects of the Supplemental Poverty Measure affects the total number.

The lowest version you can get from that table is 11.8% - if you remove medical out of pocket expenses from the income subtractions before calculating the rate (in other words: if you assume people are perfectly healthy, directly contradicted by evidence, you get a more favourable number of how many people can afford to put food on the table).

I'm curious what elements you'd add/remove to the SPM to get to "nearly zero".

[1] http://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publication...

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:38PM (#10356016)
Unfortunately the supplemental poverty measure doesn't actually measure poverty, just inequality. The definition is:

The 33rd percentile of expenditures on food, clothing, shelter, and utilities (FCSU) of consumer units with exactly two children multiplied by 1.2

http://www.census.gov/hhes/povmeas/methodology/supplemental/...

So if you were to reduce the income of everyone from the 34th percentile downward to exactly $1.24/day you'd actually reduce supplemental poverty.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by mbostleman on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:14PM (#10354779)
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by vidarh on Sunday October 11, 2015 @05:06AM (#10368634)
That does not at all support your claim "that the US Census Bureau's reporting of poverty statistics based on income has changed to NOT include the income of many benefits including food stamps and the Earned Income Tax Credit".

In fact, it specifically says that the definition has not changed.

It does claim as you do that the rate should be near zero, but it does not address the Supplemental Poverty Measure, that does provide a number of scenarios accounting for benefits in kind, and does not end up with numbers near zero when that is taken into account.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by sbov on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:26PM (#10354299)
I can see reasons behind doing this either way.

A good example is in medications. Lots of people go off medication because they feel better. But they feel better because of the medication. So they no longer feel better after they go off it.

Similarly, if all poverty reports in the US included benefits, many conservatives would say: see, we have no more poverty. We can get rid of these programs. But these programs were why we had no-one under the poverty line. We now have poverty again.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by mbostleman on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:38PM (#10354999)
I hear what you're saying and with accurate numbers and transparent assumptions there can be a good debate about that.

But I don't think the census should be a political tool. If a person did not, in fact, spend a decade living in poverty thanks to the resources she had (either earned or given to her), why should the census report show that she lived in poverty?

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by Retric on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:16PM (#10355329)
Your basic assumption is that a housing subsidy from HUD is equivalent to cash on hand. Which would imply the US government is as efficient as individuals when it comes to allocating resources which I find highly suspect.

In the end a lot of 'government assistance' really lines other peoples pockets and only indirectly assists the poor.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by lkbm on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:09AM (#10358103)
The US government is a massive bureaucracy, which is bad for efficiency, but they also control the bureaucracy, which gives them an advantage in cutting through red tape, and they can get an economy of scale that an individual can't.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by tn13 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:29PM (#10354322)
P.S. : This sort of argument would not go well on HN.

But you are right. Poverty is an accounting trick for everyone depending on how it suites those who are calculating it. In reality it is a hard thing to measure. But even the back of the envelope calculations would show that Poverty is substantially lower in India, China and many other countries which are known to be very poor.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by gohrt on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:46PM (#10354473)
You are saying that welfare systems successfully alleviate poverty, to insinuate that welfare systems not needed to alleviate poverty?
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by ptaipale on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:50PM (#10356931)
No, I read it says that welfare systems successfully alleviate poverty, which is why quoting numbers prior to the application of those welfare systems is not giving a realistic assessment of poverty.

I.e. if a worker gets $5 in salary and $5 in welfare subsidies, it is somewhat dishonest to argue that because his income is only $5, the welfare subsidies are insufficient.

It's the net income after taxes and transfers that should be looked at when considering poverty, not pre-tax pre-transfer income (which quite astonishingly seems to be used fairly often).

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by mbostleman on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:07PM (#10354704)
I am saying that to the extent that poverty gets better, it puts at risk the funding (or at least the growth of it) for the social institutions and economic policy that exist for that purpose. Since social programs make up half of US government spending, I am pretty sure that makes them collectively the largest institution in the world. And they're going to defend their jobs and their turf proportionately.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by vidarh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:37AM (#10353019)
This one (linked from yours) is even more directly addressing the trickery involved:

http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2014/08/exposing-gr...

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by yk on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:26AM (#10353352)
Unfortunately I fail to replicate the assertions of the article, using the World Bank's povcal tool. [0] ( Linked in the article.) As far as my clicking around goes, it seems that a strong reduction in poverty is independent of the precise poverty line used. In particular, if I use a poverty line of $2.5/day (2005 PPP), the data shows a reduction from 75% of global population to 46%, contrary to the claim of the article.

So just a bit playing with the data seems to imply that the claim of a strong reduction in global extreme poverty seems to be warranted. (This is certainly not a sciency study...)

[0] http://iresearch.worldbank.org/PovcalNet/index.htm?1#

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by vidarh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:54AM (#10353557)
You need to switch to 2005 PPP [1] in order to replicate the number from the article.

The numbers then does show increasing absolute numbers of poor until 1999, and then a decline getting to slightly below 1981 levels in 2011. As percentage of the worlds population it looks a bit better.

[1] This version uses 205 PPP: http://iresearch.worldbank.org/PovcalNetPPP2005/index.htm?0

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by yk on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:46PM (#10353925)
Yes, however the numbers are still amazing.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by DannoHung on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:35AM (#10353425)
Doesn't this basically just show that there has been inflation?

Why not use some stuff like infant mortality or literacy or deaths from starvation or deaths from communicable disease? You know, stuff that actually indicates whether someone is impoverished or not.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by cperciva on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:53AM (#10353546)
Doesn't this basically just show that there has been inflation?

No, because the poverty lines are all expressed in inflation-adjusted dollars.

Why not use some stuff like infant mortality or literacy or deaths from starvation or deaths from communicable disease? You know, stuff that actually indicates whether someone is impoverished or not.

Those measures are all improving dramatically too.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by Isamu on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:15AM (#10353276)
> the Bank shifted the IPL from the original $1.02 (at 1985 PPP) to $1.08 (at 1993 PPP), which, given inflation, was lower in real terms.

I don't understand this, and they don't explain. What is PPP, if not "real terms"? Plus I hate it when somebody makes a claim like this without actually showing the numbers, or creating a graph - it makes the claim less plausible than what they are complaining about.

Otherwise the article has valid points, mostly about watering down goals, and the lack of real progress in poverty reduction.

Note also that the OP is about the poverty rate, not about poverty being in decline, which is in fact increasing all too quickly.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by vidarh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:39AM (#10353455)
I believe what he's saying is that 1.02 1985-dollars (PPP adjusted) is greater than 1.08 1993-dollars (PPP adjusted).

Clicking the first two inflation calculators I found on Google and assuming their numbers are right (they both gave the same result), it does seem that if they had inflation adjusted the number using US rates, the original USD 1.02 should have been USD 1.37 by 1993.

EDIT: It's of course important to keep in mind that inflation rates are different across the world, and presumably the world bank at least will insist that they accounted for real term price changes for the relevant goods, so I still don't know how relevant this point in the article actually is.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by crazydoggers on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:09AM (#10353229)
Hmm... seems like if you move a large number of people out of "extreme poverty" which was originally defined by the UN, and set at $1.90 a day by the World Bank, they're still going to end up under the "poverty line" of $5.00 a day as defined by your article.

So I'm not sure how this constitutes a "trick". You'd have to move those people directly out of extreme poverty over the $5.00 a day in your article in order to drop the number of people in poverty.

It's still frankly an improvement to move such a large number of people up the poverty scale. I'm sure i'd rather be living on $4 a day rather than $2.

Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f... by tn13 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:27PM (#10354309)
Does not make sense. As someone who grew up in poverty in India which is also home to 17% of world population the poverty has reduced substantially over last 20 years post economic reforms.

There is no possible way I could think of how poverty could have increased. If we just look at China an India which is home to 33% of world population extreme poverty is down by 50% in whatever way you measure it.