Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by amelius on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:03AM
(#10352798)
Obviously, yes, this is the preferred long-term solution. This doesn't buy anything for the people suffering at this very instant. Also, if you are struggling to survive, how are you going to even think about getting education?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by jpadkins on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:49AM
(#10353099)
Give a man a fish, he becomes dependant on your fish. Yes, teaching him to fish takes longer, but it's better.
> how are you going to even think about getting education? You start with an education on how to survive better. You don't need to start with an advanced education.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by Matumio on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:06AM
(#10353211)
You can teach people how to pull yourself up by your bootstraps, but some of them have no boots, so it's not entirely fair.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by swasheck on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:21AM
(#10353319)
life's not fair ... but expecting someone to pull themselves up by their bootstraps when they have no boots is cruel and denies the advantage that "you" (the teacher) most likely started with a pair of boots, at least.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by Fargren on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:02PM
(#10354051)
Unless he starves while you are teaching him because you didn't give him the fish. Or he's so famished that he can't realisitically pay enough attention to learn.
Many people are already dependant in "the fish", whether or not you give it to them.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by swasheck on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:20AM
(#10353310)
the whole teach-a-man-to-fish thing is a nice saying that really helps with things outside of the jurisdiction of macroeconomics. at its core, it makes more sense to me to interpret it from the one lending aid than the one being aided. in other words, it's advice given to the teacher to seek systematic justice and fairness and not simply engage in simple, punctiliar acts of mercy.
however, neither of these should exist in a vacuum. act with mercy and work toward justice. the hard part about this is that there needs to be more of an emphasis on understanding and contextualizing justice within any given culture. "fishing" in guyana may look very different than "fishing" in guinea which may look very different than "fishing" in the philippines.
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by DasIch on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:06PM
(#10354696)
Unless of course that man is competing against heavily subsidized large scale fishing companies from industrialized countries, that export to his own country and can undercut his prices.
Free trade and free markets are truly amazing, aren't they?
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by pdeuchler on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:30PM
(#10355951)
If it's "heavily subsidized" then it's not free trade and free markets...
(unless you were going for sarcasm there)
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by DanBC on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:08PM
(#10354116)
"I live in drought ridden land locked Africa. Stop teaching me to fish; there are no fish here."
Re:'Extreme poverty' to fall below 10% of world population f...
by Shivetya on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:29PM
(#10354323)
this is both a long term and short term solution. The issue is that far too many of the poor are in countries with little or no respect of private property rights. These people stay poor because they and their property is not protected.
nothing you give them will mean anything when someone else can simply take it because of their position of power. we see this everyday, aid goes to the powerful except for a few select media staged events.
all comes back to the rule of law, not the rule of man.