News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:13PM (#10347810)
> One current dominant media narrative is that any sort of intolerant thought is intolerable, and that the emotional state of a listener is the responsibility of the speaker.

Speaking out against gay-marriage is intolerant. Threatening blacks or publicly shaming fat people is violent speech. Violent speech is not a problem because of the "emotional state of the listener". It is a problem because it creates an atmosphere of fear, and fear is a means of oppression. Sure, fear is an emotional state. But if I point a gun to your head, I think most would agree that society should place the blame on your emotional state in my gun-holding hand.

> which is why it is a narrative, not actual reporting

Except that this is actual reporting. I had never read anything (good or bad) about Reddit (wasn't interested) until I started visiting the site (which has lots of great stuff, too), and was amazed at what was going on there. Because most threats weren't aimed at me, I found it fascinating, but I could clearly see how it could really make others afraid.

> Shame and guilt don't really ever teach the lesson that is intended, but those are the only tools the media truly has.

Shaming those who create an atmosphere of fear is not a goal. The goal is to take that fear away. Besides, it seems like you're bemoaning the fact that some sort of speech is more effective than others. Maybe that's a lesson for those who call for free verbal-abuse-and-bullying to make better use of their speech? They should most certainly regard this as a lesson.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by brazzledazzle on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:58PM (#10349049)
>publicly shaming fat people is violent speech.

I don't dig generic jabs at fat people since it's in bad taste (calling out fat people that try to say being fat is healthy is another thing entirely) but I'm not sure how it's "violent".

To go off on a bit of a tangent: Don't get me wrong, I know the power words have since I was bullied for several years. I also understand how much of a struggle weight loss can be. But part of the reason that those words are so powerfully negative for a fat person is because of the shame they already feel for being obese, unhealthy and having no self control.

Besides the rare medical exception these people are in a bad place mentally and physically. Hiding external confirmation of what you already know about yourself doesn't do anything but reenforce the downward spiral of self destruction.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Nadya on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:08PM (#10348254)
>Speaking out against gay-marriage is intolerant.

Are you tolerant of other peoples' religious beliefs? If so to what extent?

I find people are quick to defend certain religious beliefs and people's right to believe in them; but start drawing lines where religious beliefs don't mingle well with their own personal beliefs.

For example - a Jew's right to avoid pork and shellfish is respected but the right for an evangelical Christian to avoid people they see as ultimate sinners who could soil them and send them to hell for eternity is completely disregarded and not tolerated at all.

>It is a problem because it creates an atmosphere of fear

If I were a hell-fearing Christian I would be very understanding of being afraid of going to Hell and being afraid of anyone who might increase my chances of doing so.

The issue is you do not have a concept of sin or that your interpretation of the Bible (and thus sin) differs from theirs. From their religious perspective, you're in the wrong. You're a sinner - and a good Christian doesn't listen to sinners. That's how you go to Hell. From their perspective it's very logical to not want to go to Hell and to condemn sinners.

The issue stems from you not being tolerant or understanding of their religious beliefs.

What's my point here? It's that arguing between right or wrong will depend entirely on beliefs. You believe you are right so they must be intolerant - they believe they are right so you must be intolerant.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:29AM (#10350900)
> people they see as ultimate sinners who could soil them and send them to hell for eternity is completely disregarded and not tolerated at all.

And if that were true, this could be an actual problem (don't think "soiling" is a thing in Christianity). In any case, no one who wants to tolerate anything means that it takes precedence over everything else. Some cultures allow murdering unfaithful women. Even the most tolerant of free societies would not tolerate that, yet that doesn't make it intolerant. Society doesn't operate according to boolean logic and values have relative importance.

> The issue stems from you not being tolerant or understanding of their religious beliefs.

But I am tolerant of their expressing their beliefs. I'm all for Reddit allowing intolerance. I'm against it allowing mobs of intimidation.

> It's that arguing between right or wrong will depend entirely on beliefs.

Except I'm not arguing about right or wrong. I'm arguing about building an effective community (or a society) that can function well, given the composition of its members.

If someone feels uncomfortable in a community where threats of rape are not acceptable and would rather spend time in a community that enjoys bullying and threats, it stands to reason that they should form a separate community and not spend time with the 99.9% of people who feel different.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by CocaKoala on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:57PM (#10348589)
>For example - a Jew's right to avoid pork and shellfish is respected but the right for an evangelical Christian to avoid people they see as ultimate sinners who could soil them and send them to hell for eternity is completely disregarded and not tolerated at all.

The right for evangelican Christians to avoid people they see as sinners is respected just as much as the right for Jews to avoid pork and shellfish is; nobody forces a Jewish person to eat pork, and nobody forces evangelical Christians to interact with sinners.

The right of evangelical Christians to enforce their beliefs on others, i.e. by making it illegal for homosexuals to get married, is a very different right, and you haven't made an argument for why that right should be respected at all; should Jews be allowed to shut down a restaurant just because that restaurant happens to serve pork or shellfish?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Nadya on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:12PM (#10348707)
>you haven't made an argument for why that right should be respected at all

That's because I don't think it should be. You're entirely missing the point of my argument and why arguing from morals and right/wrong is completely pointless. You're arguing about enforcing beliefs - I'm arguing about what is and isn't immoral and how people treat behaviors they deem to be moral or immoral. It's only immoral when you don't agree with it. If you thought homosexuality was a sin and marriage should be banned defending the cause is moral. Enforcing beliefs would be impossible because everyone has their own beliefs and there would be contradictions everywhere.

I'll use a different example, since people are missing my point entirely.

A despised terrorist to one group of people is a glorified hero to another. The only difference is which group you belong to.

It's all a matter of perspective and shouting down about how immoral or intolerant they are being will change nothing from their perspective because you are in the wrong. Not them.

Tolerating a homosexual in their presence goes against their beliefs. It's a sin to tolerate such a presence. You are asking them to sin and go to hell. I can easily understand why they might not so willing to sin and go to hell, no matter how politely you ask.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by CocaKoala on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:22PM (#10348806)
>Tolerating a homosexual in their presence goes against their beliefs.

But nobody has said that evangelical Christians have to tolerate the presence of homosexuals? Unless there's been a movement to ban homosexuals from doing things like being in public spaces; I'm not currently aware of any such movement, although I admit that I'm not really up on such things. If somebody doesn't want to be in the presence of a homosexual, then they can arrange their life in such a way that they never need to do that, and I don't think anybody is really going to force them to do something like travel to San Francisco to watch a pride parade.

edit: I guess I'm not sure what your argument is, because you say that you're not talking about enforcing beliefs and then you say that evangelical christians are forced to interact with homosexuals.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Nadya on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:37PM (#10348896)
Tolerance of everything is impossible. You have to be intolerant of certain beliefs or practices in order to tolerate others. What you choose to tolerate come down to little more then your personal beliefs. Saying something is intolerant is ultimately an empty statement.

>Speaking out against gay-marriage is [against my] beliefs

>Promoting gay marriage is intolerant [to Christian beliefs]

Allowing gays to marry - regardless if Christians have to be around these gays or not is against their beliefs. Not being respective of their beliefs is intolerant (this is a must, and intolerance is not necessarily a bad thing any more than tolerance is a good thing)

I tried to be as succinct as possible.

E:

I feel this is a necessary disclaimer after re-reading this response, lest I offend any Christians who are tolerant of homosexuals... Not all Christians...there are too many branches and sub-branches with different opinions, I use it as a blanket term for the specific (and known to exist) branches that are intolerant of homosexuals and hope it is taken as such for the sake of communication.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by com2kid on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:35PM (#10348877)
> But nobody has said that evangelical Christians have to tolerate the presence of homosexuals?

Laws exist saying that public businesses must serve all customers without discrimination, there has been a lot of controversy over, for example, a baker refusing to make a cake for a gay couples wedding.

This is an example where government enforced capitalism has been enshrined in law and it is a good thing. Discrimination distorts the market in horrible ways, American history has plenty of examples of stores discriminating meaning other stores pop up providing substandard non-competitive service to a population.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by jtuente on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:59PM (#10349423)
>a baker refusing to make a cake for a gay couples wedding.

>This is an example where government enforced capitalism has been enshrined in law and it is a good thing.

No, it's a government-enforced liability, it has nothing to do with capitalism (if anything, it's borderline anti-capitalistic). The fact that the second store serving the disenfranchised is substandard or non-competitive has nothing to do with the fact that the original store would not serve some population. A third store could also service those disenfranchised by the first and unsatisfied by the second. That's capitalism. Now if there's some kind of regulation limiting the number of stores, that's anti-capitalistic government action (a government-sanctioned oligopoly of sorts).

Let's say the baker decides to close their business rather than be forced to serve some group of people. Is that baker still obligated to make that cake? Why? What if the baker moves their business to a region that allows personal biases, is the baker obligated to bake that cake?

Your example is more akin to stores requiring patrons to wear shirt and shoes to receive service. Potential customers are being discriminated against here for an arbitrary reason based on some ideal of what is considered public decency. Do you think that a Muslim store requiring female customers to wear a burqa is discriminatory, or are they practicing freedom of religion? Does the government forcing the Muslim store to allow female customers without a burqa violate the first amendment?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by humanrebar on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @09:56PM (#10350425)
> there has been a lot of controversy over, for example, a baker refusing to make a cake for a gay couples wedding.

A better example is a wedding planner or a marriage counselor. At some point, the freedom of speech and freedom of association comes into play and cannot be disentangled from the services provided. Saying a marriage counselor has to help save marriages or close up shop is to ban people with certain beliefs from certain occupations.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by CocaKoala on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:26PM (#10349224)
Sure, but that's still a choice that evangelical christians are making; they choose to run a public business, which means they have to interact with the public. If they're not comfortable doing that, then they don't have to run a public business.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by humanrebar on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @09:53PM (#10350414)
> If they're not comfortable doing that, then they don't have to run a public business.

On the other hand, you're implicitly banning a certain class of people from owning a certain kind of business. I'm not sure why that's the most tolerant option.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by CocaKoala on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:47AM (#10353085)
A ban you choose to participate in (since it by definition only affects people who choose to be devout Christians to the extent that even interacting with homosexuals is forbidden, a philosophy which I'm not at all confident is in the bible, who also choose to own a business devoted to serving the public) seems more tolerant than a ban which is forced upon you (since nobody chooses their sexual orientation).

Do you disagree? I'm not arguing that it's completely tolerant, but unfortunately we have a case where one person completely refuses to tolerate the mere existence of another so I think it's clear that one hundred percent toleration is off the table. Since one person is choosing to be intolerant and the other isn't, it doesn't seem unreasonable at all to place restrictions on the person making the choice; if they feel that the inconveniences are too much, they're obviously welcome to rethink their choice. You can't really ask that of a gay person.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by honestcoyote on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:58PM (#10350685)
>but the right for an evangelical Christian to avoid people they see as ultimate sinners who could soil them and send them to hell for eternity is completely disregarded and not tolerated at all.

If there are any Christians who actually believe this, then they clearly have not read their gospels. Jesus, in word and deed, emphasized being around people who are sinners. The only people he ever pushed away were those who were abusing religion for their own gain.

And entrance to Hell is not gained by being around or talking to sinners. If this were true, Christianity would have died out because its members would not have been able to talk to anyone outside the group, and therefore would have had zero converts. The reasons for going to Hell vary based on what part of the Bible you read or what theologian you favor, but all the reasons can basically be summed up as the individual rejecting God in some way. People aren't sent to Hell just because they picked up cooties from some random sinner.

In short, your example is incredibly ridiculous and has no theological basis. Yes, some Christians separate themselves from the world. Some enjoy playing the "holier than thou" game. Even for people like that, none of them would think they were in danger of eternal damnation for spending time around a gay person.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tsotha on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:33AM (#10350908)
>In short, your example is incredibly ridiculous and has no theological basis.

That's really beside the point, isn't it? If they believe something, however wrong it is in your eyes, it's still what they believe. Of course there's no reason to accommodate people whose beliefs actively affect someone else, but people have a right to refuse associations for any reason.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by rhizome on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:26PM (#10347907)
Words are not guns, period.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:33PM (#10347954)
True, and pointing a gun isn't firing it, and some people feel even guns don't require regulation. But that doesn't mean verbal violence doesn't cause real harm and shouldn't be regulated, and in fact, it is regulated in virtually all free societies (and even non-free ones). The debate is on the degree to which it should be regulated, and this varies from one society to another.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech

In any case, the ideal of free speech originated in the desire to share novel ideas and speak truth to power. It's sad to see the same term used to justify tolerating bullying by angry mobs.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:25PM (#10348383)
The idea of "verbal violence", especially on the internet, is absurd on its face. On every social network that matters, permanently dismissing someone from your attention who's committing "verbal violence" against you is a mouse click or two away.

Call it what it is: People saying mean things on the internet.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by DanBC on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:24PM (#10348813)
Criado-Perez (and I'm going to say her name every time you repeat your lies)

https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/JCO/Document...

> She describes how the effects of the harassment she has received have been life-changing. Her personality has changed long-term. She describes panic and fear and horror. She feared the abusers would find her and carry out the threats. She felt hunted. She remembers feeling terror every time the doorbell rang. She has had to spend substantial time and money ensuring she is as untrackable as possible. She gives a detailed and personal account of the physical effects of the fear on her. The emails from Sorley and Nimmo (she says) are imprinted on her mind – “I don’t think I will ever be free of them”. It is a moving, detailed, and entirely understandable account of the effect of these crimes on her.

> These offences have caused serious and entirely predictable harm to her.

> The effect on Stella Creasy has also been substantial. She became concerned for her safety to the extent that she had to alter her behaviour. She had a panic button installed in her home. She describes the effect of the crimes on her public duties, on her staff, and on her family. Again the offences have caused serious and entirely predictable harm to her.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:46PM (#10348966)
Lies?

Most people on the receiving reading words on a screen do not react this way. I wonder why? Perhaps Criado-Perez is an exceptionally sensitive individual.

Hm, reading further:

The messages were posted on a number of different sites, and continued after being blocked and or warned.

This goes well beyond "saying mean things on the internet" at that point, and is also well beyond the level of what this conversation is about. The behavior described in your link is nothing short of stalking. Something which is rightly already against the law.

(And I think you know that, and I think your accusation of "lying" is especially troublesome in that regard)

We're not talking about stalking and actively attempting to make someone else afraid for their life.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tsotha on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:21AM (#10350878)
"she feared... she felt..."

What actually happened to her?

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:19AM (#10351197)
> What actually happened to her?

She was intimidated.

It is important to understand that those who have power rarely need to exert it over others physically. Intimidation is enough, and is common in nature, too. Any sort of physical struggle bears a lot of risk for both sides involved (even if it's leopard vs. gazelle), so animals try to avoid violence by communicating their strength both to rivals in their own group as well as to potential prey or predators. It is called signalling[1].

Obviously, being intimidated is not the same as being killed or wounded, but that doesn't mean that this form of signalling is not very real or not a very common form of exerting power over others, in humans as in other species.

Intimidation is very common in man and in nature, and its goal is to save the intimidator's the chance of injury and the intimidatee's life -- if they learn their place. If it weren't very real, animals wouldn't have spend so much energy on it[2].

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_theory

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handicap_principle

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tsotha on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:11AM (#10351442)
She was... intimidated? Seriously? You think it's reasonable to curtail free speech in other people to prevent intimidation?
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:57AM (#10351572)
What constitutes "reasonable" is a hard question. What I know is that all societies on this planet curtail speech to prevent intimidation. They only vary on the degree of intimidation they forbid. As a matter of fact, I am not aware of any single system of ethics where free speech is a higher value than preventing all forms of intimidation.

I also, again, must take issue with the use of "free speech" in this context. It is not at all clear that it even applies to every sequence of letters a person types or every utterance a person makes. At its very core -- or consensus -- free speech means the freedom to express all ideas and opinions without fear of arrest. It is not at all clear that "I would like to rape Ellen Pao" is either an idea or an opinion, and therefore I don't mind discussing whether we should allow such things to be said, but I do mind including them under the umbrella of "free speech" (my objection is not on principal grounds but on aesthetic grounds).

I do believe that every person should have the right to freely express his or her ideas in public without fear of arrest, and I think that this value is rather high in priority. But I agree with all other free societies (including the US[1]), which think that this freedom does not apply (and I'm not talking about various exceptions to that freedom based on offense) to certain combinations of words that constitute neither ideas nor opinions.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the...

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by woodman on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:20AM (#10351636)
> ...I am not aware of any single system of ethics where free speech is a higher value than preventing all forms of intimidation.

I'm not sure how you define "system of ethics", but systems that eschew relativity and focus on universal principles (as defined by the philosophy) are more likely to value freedom over prior restraint. I'd be surprised if you've never heard of anarcho-capitalism, that is the first such system that comes to mind.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:59AM (#10351739)
> but systems that eschew relativity and focus on universal principles (as defined by the philosophy) are more likely to value freedom over prior restraint.

Every system of ethics contains a relative ordering of values (the alternative is having a single value or none) to decide how to act when values conflict. "Freedom" is not such a well-defined (single) value -- i.e. it contains internal contradictions -- and therefore requires finer-grained prioritization at the very least, because all it implies is a lack of restraint, which is impossible in a system with more than one principal (two individuals can't both be completely unrestrained as it yields a logical contradiction: one is either allowed to restrain the other or not, either choice contradicts lack of restraint).

In short, anarcho-capitalism most certainly doesn't value speech over freedom from intimidation absolutely. It might have different relative priorities of different forms of speech vs. different forms or measures of intimidation. But this is just a difference in measure. An example that requires resolving the contradiction with prioritization is as follows: am I allowed to say, "if you deny evolution, I will stab you"? Prohibiting this speech is a restriction of speech, and allowing this speech is also a restriction of speech (and bear in mind that every kind of law requires intimidation for enforcement -- otherwise laws are not laws, but voluntary behavior -- so we have two options here, both involving intimidation, and both involving speech). This applies even in anarchic systems that don't have laws at all, up until the point that you get an anarchic system that has no values (other than individual values).

The latter, BTW, is my personal preference, but short of that I prefer a socialist liberal democracy. Any system that places the limit at physical violence (basically all American-style libertarian thought) seems to me to be both arbitrary and not truly anarchic (i.e. far from free). And if we can't have true anarchy, we might as well prioritize freedoms in a more principled way. Drawing a single line at physical violence to me seems not only arbitrary but ignorant of how social systems work (both human and animal), where freedoms are often restrained but only rarely through physical violence (and commonly through intimidation). This can be easily observed empirically.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by woodman on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:16PM (#10356312)
> Every system of ethics contains a relative ordering of values...

> ...anarcho-capitalism most certainly doesn't value speech over freedom from intimidation absolutely.

It has been several years since I last gave this a lot of thought, so correct me if I'm wrong, but I only remember one universal principle in anarcho-capitalism: aggression is immoral. From that single precept every other value is derived - property rights, self ownership, etc. As I said, it has been a while, but I do remember being impressed by the logical consistency. So do you have a contradiction that you can point to?

> ...am I allowed to say, "if you deny evolution, I will stab you"?

Yes. I don't understand how you view that as a restriction on free speech, maybe the point of confusion is around your use of the word "allowed" - because there is no central authority to grant permission in a state of anarchy.

> This applies even in anarchic systems that don't have laws at all, up until the point that you get an anarchic system that has no values (other than individual values).

An anarchic system that has laws is not an anarchic system... maybe this is another hint at the point of confusion. Anarcho-capitalism is not really a form of governance, it is a philosophy that informs thinking related to interaction between individuals. It leads to a highly distributed system of justice, where each individual relies upon their own system of ethics to mete out justice - you decide if you want to do business with murders or those who consort with murders.

I am very interested to hear about any logical inconsistencies you've found, because absent that your first two paragraphs are totally wrong.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Friday October 09, 2015 @02:37AM (#10358501)
> I do remember being impressed by the logical consistency

While I'm very fond of anarchism (not its libertarian interpretations), I've always find its libertarian forms completely inconsistent (and very, very restrictive and far from free) under a guise of consistency (and freedom). The key is that everything can look consistent if you ignore the facts. It's ethics for spherical cows, and it's not simple but simplistic. Every ethics begins that way, but then there are lots of complications that stem from how the world works. Libertarian anarchism stops there, at the logic stage. It describes a consistent model -- for spherical cows -- and chooses not to examine whether the model fits the real world.

The main issue is what constitutes aggression. A clever teenager could say, "let's draw the line at physical harm!" but an educated scientist knows that physical aggression is rare, and is only used in those circumstances where common aggression fails. Common aggression works by intimidation (as I've shown -- even in the animal kingdom) and emergent social forces (like economics). You can only draw those arbitrary lines if you choose not to study aggression. If you choose not to learn something, then everything seems simple and consistent because it remains a Platonic ideal. Once you study aggression and see how it really works you realize that preventing aggression requires a very intricate ethics.

Which is why I'm for anarchism without false and arbitrary restrictions on aggression (which only serve to increase it in its common forms), or an intricate system of ethics and law that serves to really reduce aggression, but is a far cry from anarchy.

Just to very quickly explain the difference, in a real anarchy, the threat of physical harm must always be present to offset other forms of aggression. If it isn't, there's no balance in the system. The rich can inflict economic aggression without fear of reprecussion. Once you add "no-agression" to anarchy, you've basically created a very lopsided, very non-free, and a very inconsistent system.

> Yes. I don't understand how you view that as a restriction on free speech, maybe the point of confusion is around your use of the word "allowed" - because there is no central authority to grant permission in a state of anarchy.

I used the word "allowed" loosely in this case, to mean a combination of ethics and a possible enforcement structure. The belief that only a central authority grants permission is a common mistake among libertarians, that, as I said, stop at the logical reasoning stage and don't examine the facts. Centralized government is a recent invention, at least in the Western world -- 400 years or so (that the Roman Empire appears to us like a central authority is an anachronism based on extrapolation from what we know). Yet enforcement has existed throughout human history in much more diffuse ways.

Now, back to the example. So you say it's OK to say, "if you deny evolution, I will stab you". Fine. Now what happens when I deny evolution? If I know you'll never stab me then there must be some enforcement at play. But that means that I know your threat to be empty to begin with, and so no intimidation took place. In the real world, that's not the case. The possibility that you will stab me is always on the table. If so, stabbing me for denying evolution is most certainly a restriction of my free speech. And if that option exists, intimidating me with the threat also restricts my free speech.

> It leads to a highly distributed system of justice, where each individual relies upon their own system of ethics to mete out justice

Because that's how human society existed until not too long ago, it isn't some thought exercise, and we know how that looks in practice. That is a form of governance, but without a central authority.

> your first two paragraphs are totally wrong

No, they are not. Your confusion stems from the anachronistic conflation of laws with a central state. Laws are rules based on ethics with some enforcement mechanism. That enforcement can be excommunication. In fact, that was the primary form of enforcement until not long ago. A highly distributed system of justice was the norm (again, at least in the West; I haven't studied the history of Asia).

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by woodman on Friday October 09, 2015 @04:57AM (#10358873)
> It describes a consistent model -- for spherical cows -- and chooses not to examine whether the model fits the real world.

Ok, so to be clear, you don't have a logical inconsistency to point to? Your complaint is purely utilitarian? Well, I don't really have much to say about that except that such a perspective only ever serves those presently in power.

> The main issue is what constitutes aggression.

The initiation of force, force strictly related to property rights (derived from universal preference, not state fiat). But before you equate my views to that of an adolescent again, let me first say that you've consistently redefined words. You've indicated that english isn't your native language, which could explain it - despite your command of the language otherwise, except for the fact that all your redefinitions shift the meaning to a very broad definition that supports your position. That is what kicked the whole thread off, your redefinition of violence to include spoken word - and you've done it several more times here: aggression has been redefined to include economics, laws are now derived from ethics and not simply government decree, one's own fears (rational or otherwise) and choices as a consequence constitute restriction by some other party.

If your political opinions are so informed by nature, I don't understand how you could possibly think any system could exist where individuals enjoy the total absence of any outside stimuli that may cause them discomfort or hinder them in living out their every fantasy. Especially when the terms are subject to redefinition, and all definitions are equally valid - because... feelings.

> ...in a real anarchy, the threat of physical harm must always be present to offset other forms of aggression.

Well, that is really no different than the way things are now. I believe you are pointing to a lack of monopoly on force, which does nothing to change the net amount of bad things that can happen to you - just the likelihood of total personal destruction as delivered by the state.

> ...you've basically created a very lopsided, very non-free, and a very inconsistent system.

Consider for a moment the sort of world that we'd live in if aggression was redefined to your liking. The internet would be a very quite place after a few hundred are arrested as word rapists. Economics would grind to a halt as VCs are shuttered for all the human rights violations perpetrated in not funding everybody who approaches them. Theological laws become the norm as the vocal insane grow in number. You'll find no freedom if you live at the mercy of somebody else's emotional interpretations, but you'll certainly find consistency and equality: constant misery for everybody.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:34AM (#10359004)
> Ok, so to be clear, you don't have a logical inconsistency to point to?

No, there is a logical inconsistency, but it can't be uncovered by looking at a statement in isolation. It's like saying that the statement A /\ B has no contradiction, but if you look at the definition of B and see that it's defined as ~A, then the contradiction is apparent. My example contains such a contradiction.

> aggression has been redefined to include economics

No. Aggression is defined (at least in the dictionary I have in front of me) as: "hostile or violent behavior or attitudes toward another; readiness to attack or confront". Nowhere does it say that aggression means a physical attack. I do not define aggression to include economics. I state that if you study the world (I studied history in graduate school) and learn how aggression works, you see that it often works through economics (sometimes through religion, sometimes through other social forces). If you say that your ethics include just a prohibition of physical aggression then I say that 1. it still leads to contradiction in my example, and 2. it is completely arbitrary. After all, you've chosen those values to achieve a purpose -- say freedom -- and you correctly note that aggression restricts freedom. But then you make the factual error -- that can only be confirmed through empirical observation, not logic -- that it is physical aggression that restricts freedom, and that's false.

If you actually want to learn about aggression rather than believe in some system that seems logical to you but is actually intended for spherical cows, you can start here: http://2012books.lardbucket.org/books/social-psychology-prin...

How do you know that it's a good place to learn? Well, because it was written by people who have actually studied the subject rather than people who speculate on it, and therefore, while it may be wrong, it is probably a better source than that of people who want to prescribe ideas without learning how the system really works beforehand (i.e. they prefer their own imagined explanation to how the system works, which they take great care not to accidentally verify in the real world).

> laws are now derived from ethics and not simply government decree

I'm sorry, but it is you who are unfamiliar with some definitions (I spent years of my life studying these things). My dictionary says: "Law: the system of rules that a particular country or community recognizes as regulating the actions of its members and may enforce by the imposition of penalties". You see government mentioned? Decree? A law is rule + enforcement accepted by a community. That's the only definition.

> Especially when the terms are subject to redefinition, and all definitions are equally valid - because... feelings.

You're making the same mistake. You want my statements to include redefinition of words (because you believe that that's what people of liberal or anarchic (as opposed to libertarian-anarchic) views or something do. But it's not really what I'm doing. If you want to argue with me you must first try to understand what it is that I'm saying, not misunderstand it based on what you'd want me to be saying.

> I believe you are pointing to a lack of monopoly on force, which does nothing to change the net amount of bad things that can happen to you

Ah, but if you want to limit the amount of "bad things" you must first study how "bad things" happen. As someone who has studied it, I can tell you that more bad things are caused by intimidation than by a release of violence. I'll gladly argue over facts with you, but we should at least be talking out of some knowledge and not a "feeling" that bad things happen because of physical violence.

Anarchy and the sanctity of private property can't go together. A system where the poor are not allowed to steal from the rich (because private property) but the rich are allowed to starve the poor as long as they don't do it through physical violence (i.e. they're allowed to do it the way this has actually been done in history) is not a free system. In a real anarchy, if the rich starve the poor, the poor will gang up and kill the rich. Only in such a system you can have true freedom. Otherwise, your "anarchic" society will quickly devolve into a system of masters and slaves (with no physical coercion!) We know that because that actually happened, and in quite a few distinct societies (including Europe).

> aggression was redefined to your liking

You mean that if aggression was defined the way you think it is

> The internet would be a very quite place after a few hundred are arrested as word rapists.

What? Arrested? I'm an anarchist! And short of that, a social-democrat! Neither anarchists nor social democrats advocate the arrest of people who threaten rape online. We just don't think communities should tolerate them.

> Theological laws become the norm as the vocal insane grow in number...

Look, study some history instead of making these Glen Beckian sci-fi fantasies. Pretty much every legal or political system you can think of has been tried somewhere more-or-less. I'm not saying we know how things will turn out -- far from it -- but we can at least make a few informed bets or knowledgeable comparisons. Your projections are similar to someone who'd try to create a model of the physical universe, but who's simply unaware of the electromagnetic force. There's a gap of information here, and without information you can't build a model.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by dang on Friday October 09, 2015 @02:43PM (#10362400)
You're crossing repeatedly into incivility. Please don't do that on HN, even when someone else seems ignorant to you.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mwcampbell on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:42AM (#10353478)
Why does fear not count as something happening to her? Her emotional state is just as real as her physical state.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tsotha on Monday October 12, 2015 @01:09AM (#10372670)
Getting the police involved based on someone's emotional state seems like a mistake. How could you possibly measure such a thing with any objectivity?
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @05:42AM (#10379349)
You don't need to. First, you hardly measure anything in the justice system objectively. That's why you have judges -- to use judgement. Second, you can measure the effects the distress has on one's life -- e.g. being unable to get out of the house, being startled by noises etc. -- and you get an expert opinion from a professional. There are harder things to measure in court cases.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by AndrewKemendo on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:44PM (#10348958)
Who is in charge of the emotions of an individual?
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:16PM (#10349166)
The same as who's in charge of their general (physical) well-being: it depends on the circumstances. Of course, it's all a matter of degree. Raping someone is obviously worse than threatening to rape them, but threatening with rape might be worse than, say, stepping on their foot or slapping them.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by woodman on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:01PM (#10348194)
> In any case, the ideal of free speech originated in the desire to share novel ideas and speak truth to power.

Did it? Or did it originate from the idea that it is immoral to react violently to noises coming out of somebody's face hole? By violence I mean real violence, not verbal violence, the kind of violence that a free society uses to control the activities of its members... hmm - that doesn't sound right at all.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mreiland on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:59PM (#10348181)
> verbal violence

Is not a thing, you mean verbal abuse. equating verbal abuse with physical abuse doesn't make your point genuine, what it does is cause those of us who employ critical thinking to disregard your opinions as those of an unreasonable person.

Words can be important, but you cannot try to manipulate language in order to alter reality without alienating a lot of people from your cause.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:16PM (#10348315)
> you mean verbal abuse

Right. Sorry, English is not my native language. In my native language, verbal abuse is called verbal violence.

> what it does is cause those of us who employ critical thinking to disregard your opinions as those of an unreasonable person.

It really doesn't.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mreiland on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:57PM (#10349042)
I'm curious which country you're from.

Googling the term pulls up a few the wiki article for verbal abuse, but even that article makes no mention of violence. The closes you can find are a few blog opinion pieces where people are doing exactly what you're doing, attempting to equate verbal abuse with physical violence.

I would be interested in learning more.

As for your response, you don't get to tell me how I react to people. Blunt, but true.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:33PM (#10349268)
> Googling the term pulls up a few the wiki article for verbal abuse, but even that article makes no mention of violence

Well, pull up Google translate and see which languages translate "verbal abuse" as "verbal violence". There are more than one, but I'm sure the process would be very educational.

> exactly what you're doing, attempting to equate verbal abuse with physical violence.

I never did such thing just as I don't equate murder with theft when I call them both crimes, or 53 with 75 if I call them both positive integers. Equating means putting things on the same level, not in the same category. I'm not even sure I did that. I may have only made an analogy, which is a rhetorical device using comparison to draw attention to specific properties with similar function in different categories in order to assist in understanding or viewing a subject from a certain perspective.

> As for your response, you don't get to tell me how I react to people. Blunt, but true.

I didn't. Blunt, but true.

----------------------

P.S.

Your reaction, however, perhaps ironically, raises a difference between physical and verbal abuse (although, just to make sure -- I've never said there wasn't any), which is people who are victims of physical abuse usually know it, but those who are victims of verbal abuse may not. This opens the door to some very interesting discussions no only on the nature of humiliation (e.g. most people would agree that humiliation causes harm even if the humiliated is not aware of the humiliation if there are spectators), but also on the very core of ethics (and in particular ethical naturalism vs. non-naturalism and phenomenology).

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mreiland on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:46PM (#10350175)
alright, well you had your chance, but if you can't do something as simple as describe the culture in which they translate as such, then I'm going with my initial reaction.

You're unreasonable and not to be trusted on this issue.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by RickHull on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:10PM (#10348272)
Verbal violence, heh. If you mean anything other than credible threats of physical violence, I'm flabbergasted.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:19PM (#10348337)
You are free to hold and express your opinion. Nevertheless, it is a fact that all societies on this planet have chosen to regulate speech even when it falls short of being a credible threat of physical violence, even though it makes some of their members flabbergasted.

If, however, you were referring to my use of the term "verbal violence" as opposed to "verbal abuse", it's nothing other than a linguistic mistake on my part. Verbal violence is how verbal abuse is called in my native language.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by RickHull on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:02PM (#10350002)
> If, however, you were referring to my use of the term "verbal violence" as opposed to "verbal abuse", it's nothing other than a linguistic mistake on my part. Verbal violence is how verbal abuse is called in my native language.

Ah, ok. Verbal abuse is a sensible term to me, whereas verbal violence is not.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:22AM (#10350884)
Just that you know, the term for "verbal abuse" is "verbal violence" in more than one language.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by RickHull on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:43AM (#10351100)
Sure, but in English, violence implies physical abuse. This distinction is captured by the old nursery rhyme:

"Sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me"

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:15AM (#10351189)
In French, where English got the word violence from, "violence verbale", is how you say verbal abuse. And it's not the only language where it is so.

And it is funny (and perhaps even ironic) you should bring up that nursery rhyme. One of the very first things you learn when you study history is that in order to know the state of certain societies, read what they legislated, wanted to legislate, or warned against. No one legislates or warns against things that don't happen. The reason that is a nursery rhyme, rather than, say, "Sticks and stones may break my bones but bubbles never hurt me", is precisely because words do hurt.

But a much more profound thing to understand is that those who have power rarely need to exert it physically over others. Intimidation is enough, and is common in nature, too. Any sort of physical struggle bears a lot of risk for both sides involved (even if it's leopard vs. gazelle), so animals try to avoid violence by communicating their strength both to rivals in their own team as well as to potential prey or predators. It is called signalling (you can read about it here [1] and here [2]). Signalling is a very real thing in most (advanced) animals.

Obviously, being intimidated is not the same as being killed, but that doesn't mean it's not very real.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_theory

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handicap_principle

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by RickHull on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:59AM (#10351579)
Here is the distinction, I think:

Anyone who endures verbal abuse chooses to do so.

In the case of physical abuse, the intuitive presumption is that coercion dominates any voluntary component.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pron on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:11AM (#10351614)
> Anyone who endures verbal abuse chooses to do so.

That is factually wrong. People are abused in school and in their workplace. Of course, they could choose to change schools or workplace, but the existence of the abuse is a severe, coercive, limitation of their freedom.

Most common form of coercions work in non-physically-violent ways, both in human and animal societies. Coercion is not binary, and bodily harm is not the only coercive force. Not recognizing that is simply ignorance of both human psychology and sociology as well as zoology. It's a little like saying, "in physics, the only force that matters is the electromagnetic force!"

I understand that you're making an assertion of value, but values should (I believe) at least be somewhat based on fact. If an experiment were to show that physical force coerced 100% of people to do something, and intimidation coerced 80% of people, you could not say that intimidation is not coercion. You could say that intimidation is a strong coercive force, but one that is weaker than physical violence, and with that I -- and everyone else -- would agree. My point is that the effect of intimidation on people is a matter of empirical observation -- not an assertion of value -- that yields clear results, even if the effect size is less than 100%.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by CountSessine on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:48PM (#10348526)
verbal violence

WTF please get over yourself.