I'm not going to claim we execute it correctly every time but the general approach seems fair to me: have a distinct thread on each distinct major story.
It's true that merging threads sometimes eliminates some context (hopefully not too much) but duplicate or near-duplicate threads on the front page are arguably worse. If there were a way of pleasing everybody we would jump at it. Unfortunately, people disagree about this.
So be it if Microsoft/Apple/Google/Android/Amazon/Uber is on the front page multiple times...