Re:Basic Cryptography Concepts for Developers
by jeff_marshall on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @09:58PM
(#10343751)
I think we're in violent agreement. I'm a fan of the high-level approach taken by the common criteria[1], which emphasizes cataloging threats, security objectives, environmental concerns & vulnerability mitigations when designing secure systems. This seems to overlap more than a bit with your thought process based on your blog post.
The challenge is to get people with good critical thinking skills (like the kind you advocate, and embodied in proceses like the CC) and domain knowledge involved in building things. For example, I think I have a good ability to reason (I started my career in formal methods) but at present I know very little about how a browser actually treats it's inputs. So, it's quite difficult for me to reason about the application operating environment presented by a web browser running some javascript. I wouldn't trust myself to start coding a secure web site today. Hopefully the industry will foster both of these skills (a critical mindset & good domain knowledge) and put them to good use.
Some what conversely, I've proposed a model for classifying various forms of security vulnerabilities that might be easier for developers to conceptualize:
https://paragonie.com/blog/2015/08/gentle-introduction-appli...
The idea is treat it like a taxonomic model: You have general security mistakes (data-instruction confusion), which can be drilled down into vulnerability classes and then specific bugs that, either stand-alone or chained together, result in specific vulnerabilities in specific implementations.
Or maybe I'm way off base here. The feedback I've gotten has largely been positive, though.