News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by toomuchtodo on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @04:37PM (#10342185)
Would I use them to sell? Maybe. Would I use them to buy? Most definitely. As mentioned further down in this thread, buyer's agents have every incentive for the buyer to pay as high a price as possible (due to RE commission structure). I want someone earning a fee on my transaction because they got me the best price (as either buyer or seller).

Price of a service can be a form of signaling, but paying more for something does in no way mean you're getting better served.

Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by brudgers on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @05:49PM (#10342661)
Real-estate commissions don't incentivize squeezing out a maximum sale price. They incentivize closing the sale over everything else. For example:

  Assume 7% commission.
  Assume 50/50 buyer/seller agent split.
  Assume 40/60 broker agent split.
  Assume sale price of $190,000
  Buyer agent commission = $3990
  Assume market value of $200,000
  Difference from market value is $10,000
  Total commission $700 on $10000 sale price
  Net difference to seller $9300
  Net difference to buyer's agent $210
The $210 needs to be discounted for the risk that the higher price will cause the sale not to close or create some other form of opportunity cost.
Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by toomuchtodo on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @05:58PM (#10342703)
I agree with you. I edited my comment to make that clear.
Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by rconti on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @05:17PM (#10342471)
Depends on the market. In a competitive market, I want my agent to be as dedicated as possible, not one taking a smaller cut. We won a 13-offer bidding war on a financed deal with only a SLIGHTLY higher price than the 2nd place, all-cash offer. anything could have made the difference in the deal, and I'm more than happy to throw another 10k at the agent to have it locked down.

You're right that traditional agents have incentives to get the highest price, but so does a Redfin agent.

Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by rgbrgb on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:05PM (#10347253)
>> SLIGHTLY higher price than the 2nd place

It's cool that you liked your agent but in our experience submitting hundreds of offers in SF and LA, 100% of the time we've come in with the highest price at comparable terms (waived inspections in SF) our buyer has won. In our case, we take a smaller cut because we do less upfront shopping/client prospecting work, not because we provide less service in the offer/close process. But at the end of the day, it's really your money doing most of the work, not the dude presenting it.

Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by aggieben on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @05:34PM (#10342574)
> but so does a Redfin agent

I don't see how - and anyway, a buyer's agent can be a big waste of money in a lot of markets. Traditional single-family housing transactions aren't that complicated, and a great many buyers could handle one on their own just fine. I applaud _any_ effort to undermine the NAR.

Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by cowsandmilk on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @10:45PM (#10343922)
> I don't see how

redfin gets more money with a higher price. And there are some homes redfin will not show you at all because the price is too low (and a middle range where they use "partner agents" rather than their own). And I'm not talking your 5-figure houses in suburbia, I'm talking condos in the city of boston. I have a rooftop pool, fitness center, and concierge in my building, but the price I bought my condo in 2014 was too low for redfin. Meanwhile, my buyer's agent from century 21 got 10% knocked off the list price for me, despite list being 75% of what I was willing to spend.

Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by aggieben on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:02AM (#10345454)
That's an interesting data point, for sure. I've never had a Redfin agent turn down a showing because of price, but there are too many variables involved to read too much into it.
Re:What Zillow doesn't want you to know about its listing gap by drewmeyers24 on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @06:16PM (#10342798)
Buyers agency doesn't exist in many other countries