News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by ams6110 on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @10:56AM (#10339277)
So we need a new Australia where we send all our criminals?

How is "segregation, not punishment" materially different from what we do now with prisons.

Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by scarmig on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:15AM (#10339418)
One asks us to adopt a frame of criminal justice as a social harm reduction policy; the other encourages us to think of criminal justice as a way of doling out pain to monsters totally unlike us.

It's still not at all an easy problem to solve--a whole lot of what makes prisons so shitty is the other prisoners, but enforcing a total isolation on the criminal from anyone he may hurt or be hurt by is probably more harmful than a shiv, which is the deep tension that any solution will have to work around. But the bigger thing standing in the way of a solution is the belief of most people, which is rarely even thinly veiled, that most criminals deserve whatever they get.

Which is understandable: many times (most of the time?) the criminal has actually done something heinous, and I suspect we're programmed to depersonalize and even hate people who commit asocial crimes. But it does lead to barbaric results that a civilized society should reject.

ETA: Just to be explicit that there are ways to make the experience of prisons better: don't charge a prisoner $20 for a 15 minute phone call. Allow them internet access. And, more controversially, implement the panopticon--right now there's little to no accountability for the things that happen within prison walls.

Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by tormeh on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:24AM (#10339482)
In theory? Not much. In practice? No beatings, more rights and permissions etc.
Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by pessimizer on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:12AM (#10339398)
Sounds better. More therapeutic.
Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by tormeh on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:26AM (#10339500)
Many prisons are built to be awful places on purpose. That needs to stop.