News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by tormeh on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @09:48AM (#10338826)
This. Segregation, not punishment. I believe as neuroscience advances way fewer things will be ascribed to amoral choices. Explaining crime with free will is often like explaining natural disasters with God's will - mere supersition.
Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by zo1 on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @02:39PM (#10341279)
Remember, we have to think about rehabilitation, otherwise segregation is just another form of punishment.

So, it seems that segregation implies: There is something wrong with the individual, therefore we have to keep them from being within harm's reach of the general populace.

This is a binary, on-off mechanism. That is why society, I guess, opted for unpleasant segregation, as a means of doling out a variable "fix" to the problem (mild for petty crimes, heavy for serious ones). Otherwise, you'd have to segregate each individual that ever does any sort of wrong, or breaks any violent law, etc.

Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by ams6110 on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @10:56AM (#10339277)
So we need a new Australia where we send all our criminals?

How is "segregation, not punishment" materially different from what we do now with prisons.

Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by scarmig on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:15AM (#10339418)
One asks us to adopt a frame of criminal justice as a social harm reduction policy; the other encourages us to think of criminal justice as a way of doling out pain to monsters totally unlike us.

It's still not at all an easy problem to solve--a whole lot of what makes prisons so shitty is the other prisoners, but enforcing a total isolation on the criminal from anyone he may hurt or be hurt by is probably more harmful than a shiv, which is the deep tension that any solution will have to work around. But the bigger thing standing in the way of a solution is the belief of most people, which is rarely even thinly veiled, that most criminals deserve whatever they get.

Which is understandable: many times (most of the time?) the criminal has actually done something heinous, and I suspect we're programmed to depersonalize and even hate people who commit asocial crimes. But it does lead to barbaric results that a civilized society should reject.

ETA: Just to be explicit that there are ways to make the experience of prisons better: don't charge a prisoner $20 for a 15 minute phone call. Allow them internet access. And, more controversially, implement the panopticon--right now there's little to no accountability for the things that happen within prison walls.

Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by tormeh on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:24AM (#10339482)
In theory? Not much. In practice? No beatings, more rights and permissions etc.
Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by pessimizer on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:12AM (#10339398)
Sounds better. More therapeutic.
Re:A Criminal Mind – Why did a respected psychiatrist became... by tormeh on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:26AM (#10339500)
Many prisons are built to be awful places on purpose. That needs to stop.