News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:28AM (#10331645)
I am ambivalent about the TPP. I am ambivalent about free trade agreements. I am ambivalent about globalization. I generally believe, from the perspective of the US market, that every job that can cost-effectively be exported to Asia already has been. I don't think job exports are a good thing but also don't think TPP has much to do with it.

So having said all that: I'm not arguing in favor of the TPP. I'm simply pointing out that the most common criticism of the TPP --- that it's a "secret" deal --- is both inaccurate and not particularly significant.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by mcv on Monday October 05, 2015 @10:07AM (#10331880)
> the most common criticism of the TPP --- that it's a "secret" deal --- is both inaccurate and not particularly significant.

I disagree. The scope of this deal, particularly the ISDS (which seems to have been amended due to widespread criticism), is incredibly broad. Undermining the basis of justice and democracy in secret negotiations without any feedback from the public is a terrible idea. If it was just about tariffs, sure, go ahead. But if business can get awarded massive damages in private courts because a democratic system decides not to tolerate their harmful practices anymore, well, that's unbelievably harmful to any semblance of justice and democracy. Stuff like that should never be negotiated in secret, but be subject to democratic checks and balances. The status of ISDS is to me still the primary factor in whether this deal will be acceptable or not. And as long as it's an inseparable part of the treaty, the treaty as a whole should fall if this part of it is considered unacceptable.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:46AM (#10332569)
Businesses can obtain damages from governments, if those governments are found to have enabled trade policy that contravenes the treaty. Businesses cannot go to ISDS for damages from citizens or companies in those countries.

I don't know what one thing you don't like in the TPP has to do with the level of transparency involved in its ratification. If the ISDS process is a grievous flaw, rather than a mechanism that is similar to those used in many/most other trade treaties, surely it won't be ratified.

Either way, you'll soon have the full text of the treaty, months before it comes to a vote.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by mcv on Monday October 05, 2015 @06:37PM (#10335520)
"Surely"? Only when there's sufficient protest against it.

The reason why the secrecy makes ISDS even worse is that it undermines democratic means of the people to improve their country. They might vote for a good law, but doing so might lead to steep damages paid to the companies whose behaviour made the new law necessary in the first place. It seriously undermines the country's sovereignty, and that's not something that should be bartered away in secret.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by techdragon on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:20PM (#10336213)
Unfortunately the government gets its money for those damages from its citizens.
Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by ckozlowski on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:50AM (#10331765)
>I'm simply pointing out that the most common criticism of the TPP --- that it's a "secret" deal --- is both inaccurate and not particularly significant.

This is an important point. And furthermore, I'd even argue that it was necessary. The lack of transparency in the negotiations was to allow country's negotiators to be able to put their cards on their table without being immediately skewered out of context. For example, if Japan's negotiator proposed eliminating tarries on rice imports into her country as a carrot, the uproar back home would be enormous. But if it resulted in say, a removal on tariffs for exported Japanese cars, then the country could see it as a net win when the final agreement was put forth.

The secrecy was only there to let them barter freely before arriving at a conclusion. Otherwise, the negotiations would have gotten nowhere, and free trade would be nowhere.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by digikata on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:59AM (#10332659)
I understand why it's kept secret during negotiation, but the terms of the secrecy kept representatives from copying out portions of the text for analysis during the negotiations. This is significant because the 90 day time line is insufficient to read and analyse such a large reaching trade agreement.

Then under the short time frame, the argument becomes 'we worked for years on this deal' don't vote no on any one point you disagree with because it's tied up in a big Gordian knot with a hundred other points. If software were written the way we negotiate trade deals, we'd fire the programmers.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @12:02PM (#10332681)
All due respect but I call bullshit on the idea that months of time is insufficient for hundreds of Congresspeople to work with their million dollar staffs and the armies of lobbyists for business, labor, the environment, and tech policy that will also analyze the bill gratis.

I know they won't review the enabling bill carefully. But it's not because the bill isn't transparent. It's because reviewing the bill is work, and none of them are excited about spending their precious cycles on work rather than political status games.

If this bill had been public 9 months ago and voted on 9 months from now, the amount of scrutiny legislators would give it would be roughly equivalent.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by digikata on Monday October 05, 2015 @12:17PM (#10332811)
So if I suggested that say there is a 100k line update scattered amid a 20M line in-production codebase and you have 90 days before that code goes live and cannot be changed and cannot be revoked. Would you feel that 90 days is sufficient? I wouldn't.

It's not just staff to read the text, it would be identifying and lining up experts with context in each area to weigh in. So far corporate lawyers have been embedded into the process but few representatives of the people. So I think we should approach this with deep caution.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @12:45PM (#10333021)
Yes, I think a team as large as the one assembled to deal with the TPP could easily handle a 100kloc patchset for a 20MM line project. Teams much smaller than that handle gigantic patchsets all the time.
Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by digikata on Monday October 05, 2015 @01:47PM (#10333459)
When code is irrevocable, the team sizes and/or time to handle the code should go way up. I suspect most of us have internalized a gut feel for estimates along the lines of the Linux kernel process or other equivalent commercial low-reliability software process, when with long lived legislation, we should take more cues along the lines of the Space Shuttle code development process (or perhaps I should liken it more towards approving and implementing a new crypto algorithm...) as more reasonable approaches.
Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by ZenoArrow on Monday October 05, 2015 @05:42PM (#10335191)
You make it sound like the TPP is the only bill these congresspeople will have to digest in the next 2 to 3 months, but I suspect they'll have plenty of other policies vying for their attention.

Even if it was the only policy they need to get their head round, what's the rush? Is the world going to fall apart if it takes a year to debate? Isn't our understanding of the intricacies of the bill likely to improve over a longer debate?

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by drdeca on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:26PM (#10336235)
Who cares if the congress people have enough time to read it all?

If I wouldn't have time to read it all, if it were all I did other than eat or sleep in the allotted time, then there is not enough time for it to be sufficiently considered, and should not be passed.

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by PantaloonFlames on Monday October 05, 2015 @01:41PM (#10333419)
> I generally believe, from the perspective of the US market, that every job that can cost-effectively be exported to Asia already has been.

Do you mean "every TYPE of job" or every instance of job? Plenty of jobs have been exported, and plenty more will be, until the world is basically flat. As one example, right now, US doctors are still commonly reading and interpreting X-rays and CAT scans. This is being automated and also outsourced. In other words, this TYPE of job is already being done by doctors in China. But large portions of work remain here in the US. The export and automation of jobs will continue.

Maybe you're right by qualifying your comment with "cost effectively". Surely that's the case in an efficient market. But "cost effective" will change as technology and culture develops. As hospital administrators become less tech-phobic, more xray-techs will work from Shanghai.

> I don't think job exports are a good thing

Why not? It's the most efficient way of providing economic well-being to less developed countries, which means better food security for their people, better education, better healthcare, and more stable politics. You might say exporting jobs is the #1 best way the USA can deliver aid to foreign countries.

> also don't think TPP has much to do with it.

For a counterpoint, see this link previously posted here: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/06/26/417851577/episo...

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by rory096 on Monday October 05, 2015 @10:58AM (#10332200)
> I don't think job exports are a good thing

Why not? Do you think automating jobs with technology is also a bad thing?

Re:Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal Is Reached by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:47AM (#10332574)
I definitely don't think it's automatically a good thing.