News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by gambiting on Monday October 05, 2015 @06:49AM (#10330942)
Meh. I've already decided my next car won't be a diesel. I bought a 1.6dCi Nissan Qashqai in 2013 and that engine has only one advantage - ridiculously low fuel consumption. Seriously, my usage is usually around 5L/100km or less(56 UK MPG/47 US MPG). But - the engine is very noisy and rumbly, plus it takes forever to warm up in winter. Seriously, I drive on the motorway on my way to work and it's still a solid 10 minutes before any warm air starts to enter the cabin. For the temperature indicator to get to the middle, operational position, it's 20 minutes of driving. It's unacceptable. My partner has a small petrol powered car, and she is warm within a minute of starting it. The emissions scandal has only cemented my decision to not buy a diesel in the future.
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by svalorzen on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:06AM (#10331011)
I'm not a car expert, but wouldn't the fact that the engine takes time to heat up mean that it is more efficient?
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by ptaipale on Monday October 05, 2015 @08:16AM (#10331276)
Precisely that. Over here (Finland), modern diesels have heaters to compensate for that (so, because the engine does not produce excess heat, the heater burns some fuel to generate heat).

The UK models may be stripping off the heaters for cost. I hear people don't even use winter tyres in Britain...

Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by ju-st on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:32AM (#10331103)
You're right. In my experience the gas guzzlers always heat up faster.
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by tdkl on Monday October 05, 2015 @06:58AM (#10330973)
Isn't the low fuel consumption + low diesel price the biggest point to buy a diesel fueled car?
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by gambiting on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:14AM (#10331036)
In UK diesel was always more expensive. Not long ago I was paying £1.30/litre when Petrol was £1.10/litre(£1.30/litre is $7.5/US gallon for US readers). It's only very recently that the two fuels are nearly at the same price everywhere.
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by Theodores on Monday October 05, 2015 @03:08PM (#10334047)
Ye of short memory! In the 1980's and the early 90's diesel was definitely cheaper. Also in the late 1970's although back then you had to fill up standing in the rain at some special pump used by lorries.

We also had lead in petrol back then - nice!

I can only recall this anecdotally, a friend's mum ran a diesel car and my mum explained why they had such a noisy thing. You could suffer from tinnitus for hours after getting out of what I believe was an early square shaped Golf (with diesel engine). Diesels back then had no clever electronics or fancy injection so it was a dirty fuel.

Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by gambiting on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @03:22AM (#10337207)
>> Diesels back then had no clever electronics or fancy injection so it was a dirty fuel

You will find plenty of people who will say they were the best diesels, because they would burn literally anything, you could put used oil from your frying pan in it and it would happily burn it without any problem. They were uncomplicated chunks of metal, so it's quite common for them to do a million miles without any significant problems. Of course they were dirty as hell, so it's a good thing we don't use cars like that anymore. The only legitimate use I can think of is people who go in off roaders to Africa or deep parts of siberia, where the fuel quality is absolutely horrible, so you can't have a modern diesel with a high pressure direct injection system - one spec of dirt in your fuel and your injectors get clogged.

Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by DanBC on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:24AM (#10331069)
We have pretty good numbers for costs of diesel vs petrol.

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-sets/oil-and-...

Diesel has always been more expensive, but there have been a few times (2007) where the prices got close.

And that's just the cost of the fuel from the pump - it doesn't take into account MPG of the car or duty benefits for diesel car ownership.

Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by redcalx on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:45AM (#10331140)
> MPG of the car

Also not that diesel is more energy dense per unit volume. (And a US gallon is different to an imperial/British one)

Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by mseidl on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:27AM (#10331080)
In Germany near me, it's roughly 20 cents a liter cheaper.(euro cents)
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by pvaldes on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:17PM (#10335680)
When was the last time that you changed the heaters of your car?
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by gambiting on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @03:35AM (#10337252)
The car is two years old, I don't think I need to change anything to be warm in winter :P And in any case, what do you mean by heaters? The only source of heat is the engine coolant, which circulates through a radiator in front of a fan in the cabin - until the engine heated up the coolant, there's no warm air coming out.
Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by pvaldes on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @07:08AM (#10338046)
> it takes forever to warm up in winter

> there's no warm air coming out

Ok, is a different problem then that I thought. Never say this in any of my cars, but it seems that other qashqai owners have the same problem. Not easy solution for a feature that your car just do not implement. If the air is in closed circuit (inner) will warm a couple of minutes before, but do not expect miracles with your model. In this case, is just a problem of poor design.

> what do you mean by heaters?

I don't know the name of the piece in english, they are needed for warming up the engine before starting the car. When some of them eventually break and is cold outside you can't start the car after several minutes. (Just need to replace the broken pieces, but is a new car and this is not the problem here).

Re:VW Scandal Will Speed Up Diesel's Demise by ptaipale on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @08:26AM (#10338343)
So, with heaters you mean glow plugs [0]. However, they are not the problem if the engine starts.

If your problem is that the engine starts, but it takes a very long time to get warm air from the heating system, in modern cars it's most likely just that the engine is extremely efficient in converting energy of fuel to kinetic energy, so there is no excess heat that could be used for heating the cabin and keeping windows clear from mist.

(Heating is also slow or off if your engine is out of coolant, but if you keep running it without coolant, you'll soon break it so that you really do notice.)

Just think what this heating problem will be in electric cars...

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glowplug