This'll most likely start as CDN endpoints (that no longer need an origin), and move on from there.
Also, it is impossible to know who owns a file. Since it is identified only by a hash, everybody possessing the same file at any point could claim that file is theirs and prove it by producing the hash. In this way, downloading a file is owning it.
Also, the Internet Archive policy seems too naïve. So anyone who just bought a domain can exclude everything saved at that domain in the IA up to that day?
The key would be to convince publishers that removing the hash from their directory tree counts as deletion. Maybe the hashes shouldn't be that prominent?
I don't see how the Internet Archive policy is naive. Yes, they're assuming whoever owns the domain owns the files and maybe sometimes that means someone deletes some files when they didn't have the right. But taking a stand against domain owners who want the files gone would probably land them in court.
But I don't think it's going to take off until there's a way to take down files you don't want published anymore. Even with the Internet Archive, if you add them to robots.txt, they will take it down. [1]
Removing things from the Internet is always going to be imperfect since there will always be people who archive old copies of files (and that's a good thing). But the official software should honor retractions or mainstream publishers won't be interested.
[1] https://archive.org/about/exclude.php