Re:Why the Internet Needs IPFS
by skybrian on Sunday October 04, 2015 @10:36PM
(#10329684)
I think it's less about who owns the hash and more about who refers to it. Think about how git works. If more than one place refers to it then it's like it was copied. If you remove a hash from a directory, it's gone from that directory. If no other directory has it then it can be garbage collected.
The key would be to convince publishers that removing the hash from their directory tree counts as deletion. Maybe the hashes shouldn't be that prominent?
I don't see how the Internet Archive policy is naive. Yes, they're assuming whoever owns the domain owns the files and maybe sometimes that means someone deletes some files when they didn't have the right. But taking a stand against domain owners who want the files gone would probably land them in court.
The key would be to convince publishers that removing the hash from their directory tree counts as deletion. Maybe the hashes shouldn't be that prominent?
I don't see how the Internet Archive policy is naive. Yes, they're assuming whoever owns the domain owns the files and maybe sometimes that means someone deletes some files when they didn't have the right. But taking a stand against domain owners who want the files gone would probably land them in court.