Have a large number of tests, let the law of large numbers rule (eg let 1000 random people borrow each type of car). Have a think about whether there's some bias between the manufacturers built in and adjust your sampling accordingly. Make the data available to scrutiny.
That doesn't sound expensive
Re:The Internet of Criminal Things
by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 04, 2015 @04:03PM
(#10328612)
I agree. Paying people to do comprehensive tests in a few locations will probably cost less than a single brand new car, of which they're making thousands to millions. Even a thousand test drives is not that much; 20 cars borrowed for a month is more than enough to do those.
Re:The Internet of Criminal Things
by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 04, 2015 @04:00PM
(#10328600)
>How will you handle all of the "its not fair" complaints
You look at them with disbelief and ask why they designed it to skirt the edge of illegal levels of pollution and be so likely to fail.
The essence of tightening emissions and CAFE standards (as currently implemented) is that they are hard to meet and even passing manufacturers are generally "just barely" passing.
For CAFE, makers sell some high mpg models at cost/slight loss to allow them to sell high-margin luxury and sports models.
And also, how will you ensure that certain manufacturers aren't actually given better conditions?