The American system is really really screwed up if you are trying to escape poverty.
So free eduction may play a role in producing positive results for the whole society. Also maybe the poets are more important to this than a person from a country where no free education is available can understand.
Please also read about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome
In a certain sense you already are, by indirectly bearing the costs of widespread loan defaults. At least the government is in a position to effectively address the overabundance of worthless degrees being issued.
I do. Society needs poets.
What on earth makes you think the choice was not coerced? A student before the age of 18 is presented with an option. Here's one path - be in massive debt. Here's the other path - your hopes and dreams are shit. That's freedom? Hardly.
It's funny how all the moral hazard trolls come out of the woodwork as soon as something benefits poor people. Bank bailouts? No hazard. Corporate tax cuts? No hazard. Corporate subsidy? No hazard. Private prisons? No hazard. Help indentured slaves? HAZARD!
There might however be a lot more traction on one of the paths as compared to the other.
You're presenting this proposition as that the only way someone can make it, is by pursuing a higher education (with severe debt). I, again respectfully disagree. It is not that binary.
First of all, the path of not going into higher education is not as ridiculous as you make it sound.
Secondly, there are many variations of how to finance your higher education. You do not have to take out a loan. Especially not for the full duration of your studies.
And what do we end up with when these 18 year olds become 23 year olds with a load of debt and still no basic idea of economics or understanding what it means to go into debt? We end end up with an even bigger problem.
Also, government is not society.
But that empathy is short lived. We all have a free will. All these students could do the math prior to the commitment (I did!) and see the mountain of debt they'd be in. To say that it was someone else's fault is just yet another cop-out of a generation where it is socially acceptable to walk away from commitments and refuse to accept responsibility.
You call it a moral hazard to forgive the debt, but the students who took the loans are the least-bad actors in this scenario.
What I mean is this: a lender who cannot choose who to lend to wisely will be pushed out of a free market. If the people they are lending to cannot pay them back in large numbers, they have no one to blame but themselves.
I sympathize with these folks who have gotten themselves into this situation, but they did make the choice of their own free will. If they didn't do a proper analysis ahead of time, it doesn't seem fair to shift the cost of their decision onto others who did, or who are responsibly shouldering the burden that they took on.
There is a definite moral hazard in the current system (it encourages indebtedness and inflates the cost of education), but that doesn't make it right to create another moral hazard in trying to correct it.