News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by draaglom on Friday October 02, 2015 @09:45AM (#10318460)
It's a shame that philosophy has gained such a poor reputation in certain circles.

I mean, it's understandable: the extent of most people's interaction with philosophy is with cartesian-style "but can we even know we exist??" navel-gazing -- or worse, with the intentionally obscure bits of continental philosophy.

Because of this reputation, many (the majority of?) scientifically-minded people view it as a binary choice: you're either a good empiricist or you're one of those damn poststructuralist lit-crit people from the humanities department.

IMHO: people who hold this mindset risk missing out on a powerful tool for their mental toolbox.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by MichaelGG on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:43AM (#10318863)
I tried to see what it offered. For instance, those "A very short introduction" series of books. Tried out Philosophy of Science. I see things like "what does 'alive' really mean" as something that is what Philosophy of Biology would deal with. That seems... rather useless? Arguing over definitions and going round in circles without contributing, today, to anything? (Everyone used to be called a philosopher, so in years past I'm sure "philosophy" has done plenty.)

Looked at Philosophy of CompSci on the Stanford Plato site. Read a lot of ... words... that were just fascinated they could work "duality" into computer programs. Cause a program is source right? But it can also be object code. Ooooh. And what about interpreted scripts, what does all this really mean? ... This would appear to have no redeeming quality. Perhaps I'm wrong I've just yet to see how this could be useful or even really intriguing.

Then there's even top scientists like Feynman making mocking comments about philsci. So given even top scientists are unconvinced there's value, I start to think OK maybe I'm not missing out on much.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by astazangasta on Friday October 02, 2015 @12:04PM (#10319374)
We could easily pull up dozens of examples of spurious, dull or absurd results and claims from science. There are interesting things to be learned from philosophy even if some of it is dumb.

It's especially important to address the claims of science to be a perfect method of knowledge; in the absence of religious justifications for human activity science has been set up as a valid replacement and its important to examine its right to the throne. We have a long history of attempts at scientific decision making that claims an objectivity it ought not to have (see: forced sterilizations, eugenics, mass medication and medicalization of human behavior) and tremendous consequence resulting from this sort of claim (environmental catastrophe, for example).

If science is going to intrude on the domain of politics, of deciding what is human and who should be considered human, we seriously need to challenge the assumption of objective knowledge and think about science's fundamental dependence on metaphysical constructs. Easy to ignore if you are Feynman at the top of this pyramid, but scientific authority is just authority; it has to be accountable to something or it is going to produce monsters.

As the article states, this exploration can only occur from outside science; we can't answer claims about its validity or access to truth from within science.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by MichaelGG on Friday October 02, 2015 @09:01PM (#10322171)
I didn't go to look up bad examples. I tried, honestly, to see what PhilSci was about, how it could help. Hence reading the Very Short Intro book. Stanford's Plato is often held up on HN as this awesome site. And since I understand CompSci a bit, I figured PhilCompSci should be something I can understand (whereas I might not be equipped to judge other areas so well). In every case, I've not found any good arguments, just pontificating.

The closest I've heard similar to what you're saying is stepping outside of Science-the-process to determine what things are true using Bayesian probability. For instance, Einstein stating that his theory was correct, even if the first test didn't agree. I thought this was pretty well accepted. Other than that, what kind of outside-science thought systems are we talking about?

And more usefully, where is a short intro that doesn't come with spurious, dull, or absurd statements?

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by Retric on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:09AM (#10318616)
Step 1: Name a single piece of information* gained from philosophy that is not currently debated.

This is why people look down on philosophy. While people might pretend to disagree with this, I would take the complete lack of counter examples as agreement.

PS: And because debate about word choice is so popular, information: facts provided or learned about something or someone.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by jevgeni on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:16AM (#10318662)
You mean, like the fact of Earth-centric solar system models everybody used to believe in?

This is not why people look down on philosophy. This is why STEM people fail to learn anything about it. Other people look down on philosophy, because it's close to impossible to make a living out of philosophy.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by tdb7893 on Friday October 02, 2015 @01:11PM (#10319818)
The fact that science changes and people used to disagree is a testament to the difference between the two fields. Testability is where science gets it's credibility so it's not surprising that it doesn't have much credibility among scientists. How many times has philosophy made a prediction about how things worked that was observable? I'm not saying it should have the reputation it does but it doesn't surprise me at all.
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by jevgeni on Sunday October 04, 2015 @03:39AM (#10326809)
Philosophy is not predictive. Why do people think that? Is set theory predictive? The very principle that you describe, the principle of falsifiability of a scientific theory, is a philosophical construct (developed and described by Karl Popper) on which today's scientific approach is based.
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by Lawtonfogle on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:47AM (#10318879)
There are lots of facts gained from philosophy. The issue is that any subset of philosophy that produces useful results gets developed into its own field of knowledge. Thus, what is classified only under philosophy is a dead sea effect of sorts, resulting in the low opinion of philosophy.
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by foldr on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:15AM (#10318660)
One neat result in metaphysics is the discovery that there can't be a property for every predicate, since this gives rise to analogs of Russel's paradox. (Does the property of being a non-self-exemplifying property exemplify itself?)
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by dkural on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:18AM (#10318680)
This is a result in logic, a branch of mathematics. Logic, as practiced inside mathematics, is far more advanced than what's practiced inside philosophy departments. Something like more than 95% logic professors inside philosophy departments cannot competently explain anything in logic after Godel & Tarski.
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by drdeca on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:40AM (#10318842)
It seems to me that there is no clear break between logic and philosophy?

Nor between logic and mathematics.

There is also the idea that part of why philosophy is dismissed is because people tend to take results and say that the result isn't really part of philosophy.

Could this be because their idea of philosophy is that it has no results, so any results they are shown are concluded to be not part of philosophy?

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by foldr on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:33AM (#10318789)
It's not a result in logic. The question of which properties (if any) exist is not a logical question but a metaphysical one.

Of course, philosophers often make use of results in mathematics. If you arbitrarily decide that any philosophical work that does this in some sense "doesn't count", then of course you will find that the remaining work concerns results that are less than certain! It's in the nature of questions that can't be answered through mathematical methods to have less than certain answers. You might notice that many of the most important questions in life fall into this category, though.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by Retric on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:22AM (#10318712)
Contractions don't prove philosophical arguments. They only demonstrate something is inconsistent, but nothing requires reality or systems of thought to be consistent.

This is what separates philosophy from math or logic.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by foldr on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:34AM (#10318805)
I'm not sure what you mean. If a statement entails a contradiction, then it must be false. So if you can show that the statement "every predicate has a corresponding property" entails a contradiction, then it must not be the case that every predicate has a corresponding property.
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by Retric on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:58AM (#10318952)
In math people are used to A = B has very specific meaning such that B = A. In some systems of thought A=B does not exclude B != A or even A != B.

This might seem ridiculous, how could such a system be useful? Well what about time, just because at one point A=B does not mean A still = B. [Yay, programming ;0]

Now, time is just one specific case, but Philosophy encompasses all systems of thought not just the tiny subset that is western philosophy. Some religions for example actively promote contradictory ideas.

As such, showing contradictions mean more in math suggests something is false, where in philosophy showing a contradiction only demonstrates something is false in a subset of systems of thought.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by tdb7893 on Friday October 02, 2015 @12:58PM (#10319707)
I haven't really had any philosophy so can you briefly explain what implications this has outside of philosophy? I don't really understand what this means practically
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by draaglom on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:38AM (#10318832)
If you want an example of genuinely valuable philosophy, I found "Kinds of Minds" by Daniel Dennett to be a compelling discussion of the origins of consciousness.

It's not "fact" but it does provide interesting ways to think about the issue; ways that could drive experiment or further enquiry. So under a "pragmatic" theory of knowledge I would say that there is information there.

But of course that's a philosophical stance that you should not feel compelled to debate me on ;)

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by glomph on Friday October 02, 2015 @11:09AM (#10319018)
I mean all of physics is open to revision as well right? Should we look down on physics?
Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by vinceguidry on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:04AM (#10318579)
People tend to forget how utterly limited the capacity we have for scientific inquiry is, and how those limits shaped history and science. Before there was ever science there was philosophy, and that philosophy was shaped by religion, and the same people did all three of those things throughout history.

If you took a king from the 1200s and had him look at our scientific establishment, he'd have called them monks. From this perspective, philosophy is religion without deity, and science is just philosophy of the empirical.

Disciplines of the mind do not have to have this hard separation, its a shame cynicism and scorn have been allowed to take over the public discourse. Not everyone who looks at the philosophy of science is a quack.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by coliveira on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:30AM (#10318773)
> Not everyone who looks at the philosophy of science is a quack

True, but the problem with philosophy is that it is the study of how humans embrace reality, not the study of reality itself. For the simple reason that philosophy has no tools (other than science) to establish what is true or false in the world outside our own minds. If you understand philosophy as the ways we make sense of the world, instead of a tool of finding what is true, then we would have a better time dealing with it.

Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics by GFK_of_xmaspast on Friday October 02, 2015 @10:27AM (#10318745)
I feel that this reflects an ignorance about (a) the lives and work of scientists in the modern day and (b) the lives and work of monks in the 13th century.