Re:Why Science Needs Metaphysics
by TuringTest on Friday October 02, 2015 @11:03AM
(#10318976)
> it can eventually explain why something is the way it is.
Not exactly. It can explain "how" it is, but not "why" it is that way.
Unless you take "why" as a shortcut for "how it works in a more detailed framework", which is not how philosophers understand it when doing metaphysics.
I did a shortcut on my comment mixing religion with philosophy, not to start any kind of big discussion.
> Science hasn't yet discovered why something as it is => Metaphysical explanation
This is a bit of a myth. If you look at the metaphysical problems that, say, Aristotle was grappling with a few thousand years ago, pretty much all of them are still unsolved philosophical problems that have barely been touched by any developments in science. To pick an example at random: are statements about the future true or false?
(To say that these problems remain unsolved is not to say that there's been no progress. We understand the space of possible and plausible solutions a lot better than Aristotle did.)
1 - Science hasn't yet discovered why something as it is => Metaphysical explanation
2 - Mankind needs an explanation for things they cannot understand => feel better with the unknown
Scientific knowledge is the enemy of any religion as it can eventually explain why something is the way it is.