News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by axx on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @09:20AM (#10303683)
I think we all should agree that this is the same for every car manufacturer (except electric). Sure, european manufacturers are the target now, but i expect same results from all other manufacturers (including asian and american).

Lab results never represent real street results. How could they? People drive differently and the outcome is based on many aspects that you can't reproduce in lab conditions.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by eterm on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @09:25AM (#10303720)
You are obfuscating the issue here.

The issue isn't that we can't "represent real street results", the issue is that manufacturers took deliberate steps to alter car behaviour with the intention of obtaining better test results than would be present outside the tests.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by knowaveragejoe on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @09:41AM (#10303839)
But the results they're aiming for are ostensibly based on some measure that represents "real street" results. Otherwise, why the hell do we have these measures in the first place?
Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by axx on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @09:44AM (#10303868)
And that's a surprise to whom?

It's the same with smartphone and notebook batteries. Tell me, when was the last time, you actually got 9 hours of battery live (in case of a MBP)?

Don't get me wrong, i see it the same way as you are, but this is an issue that you can find everywhere not just in car manufacturing.

For example, a lot of power supply companies try all kinds of tricks to game the efficiency test systems.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by simias on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:23AM (#10304157)
The consequences are different however, increased pollution has far reaching consequences, first of all human health. If my neighbour's smartphone has a shorter battery life it doesn't concern me, however if their car (and the cars of million of people around me) pollute more it's definitely my problem.
Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by cujo on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:38AM (#10304270)
All these little things add up though. Every device that gets less battery life than expected is taking more power to run. That power likely comes from a non-clean source. Given, it's not on the scale of the automobiles, but dismissing it outright may be a mistake.
Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by takeda on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @03:38PM (#10306535)
Perhaps you did not read the article and responding to the title.

The article points out that 1/3 of improvement in past 3 years to meet regulation requirements was real improvement and 2/3 was just manipulation.

It doesn't matter that people drive cars differently than they are tested in cars, to illustrate it they highlighted that due to those manipulations that difference now can be as high as 50% which is beyond claims that people drive cars differently than when they are tested in labs.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by quesera on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:10AM (#10304056)
In fairness, Apple typically understates battery life in marketing materials. Most new-model reviews show that clearly.

And, if you got a bad battery that doesn't live up, they'll replace it at no charge.

Battery life declines with age, however.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by pcr0 on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:41AM (#10304282)
MBP battery issue is a bit complicated, especially when discrete graphics is present due to switching issues with their in-house solution (no Nvidia Optimus for OS X). MBAs on the hand, I've seen them go past 13 hours easily (~1 year old, WiFi off, low-med brightness, editing documents).
Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by cLeEOGPw on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:08AM (#10304044)
> except electric

Why? You have just been shown corporate cheat on tests. Why you would ever assume this has something to do with fuel type? I expect Tesla cheat as much as MB or BMW in their "range" test. And if you believe otherwise you are just someone who doesn't learn from his experience.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by mikeash on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @12:59PM (#10305345)
Tesla's range numbers for the Model S assume about 300Wh/mile average consumption. My average consumption so far over not quite 8,000 miles is 315Wh/mile.

It's hard to cheat in an electric car. Few people care about efficiency directly, but most electric car drivers care deeply about range, and range is just battery capacity multiplied by efficiency. If Tesla were cheating so they could lie about efficiency, Tesla owners would notice pretty much right away that they're not achieving the range they should.

The only practical way for Tesla to cheat would be to ship a larger battery than they say they do, and then fudge the numbers from there. Given the current cost of batteries, this would be an incredibly expensive cheat, and it would be tough to hide from the tinkerers who tear down battery packs to see how they're built.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by briantrice on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @05:58PM (#10307687)
I have definitely found that electric vehicle companies advertise very sound and realistic figures for their mileage.

My personal case is a Zero motorcycle, but I've heard confirmation from owners of other kinds; the range it gets is more or less exactly what they state for the test conditions (straight level ground, no winds, etc etc). Mine did in fact improve when I adjusted the aerodynamics, but that's another topic.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:15AM (#10304097)
Tesla have, on a couple of occasions, experienced the opposite: a journalist does a range test and falsifies the result downwards by unrealistic driving conditions. On one occasion they used the car's telemetry to disprove the review.

Top Gear got complaints for doing the same thing to (I think) a Leaf.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by ams6110 on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @11:19AM (#10304600)
Top Gear did it with a Tesla Roadster.

But really, Tesla develop cars with high performance characteristics, and then people complain about "unrealistic driving conditions" when people drive them as they are designed?

Tesla could easily program the cars to accelerate moderately and with maximum energy efficiency, but they would't be able to command $80,000 price tags if they did that.

People who spend Tesla, Mercedes, or BMW money on a car, by and large, don't give a shit about economy.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by michaelt on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @11:25AM (#10304631)

  I expect Tesla cheat as much as MB or 
  BMW in their "range" test.
Many lithium-ion batteries lose capacity with more charge cycles - 20% after 500 charge-discharge cycles would be typical [1] although there are longer-life batteries - so manufacturers who value their reputations design in enough overhead that the battery will still have enough capacity after a few years / when the product reaches the end of its design life.

Personally I'd expect a tesla that had just rolled off the production line to exceed the specified range easily.

[1] http://industrial.panasonic.com/lecs/www-data/pdf2/ACA4000/A...

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by Bud on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:26AM (#10304182)
You "expect"?

Could you perhaps cite any data, any at all? It's not like we don't have a LOT of Tesla owners out there who are obsessively testing this, every day. Do you think they're just all part of the conspiracy?

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by yoz-y on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @12:45PM (#10305233)
It is kind of weird that this is surfacing just now. There are magnitudes more VW owners than Tesla. Why have not the consumer studies revealed this a long time ago?
Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by mikeash on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @01:02PM (#10305381)
You have to put in a fair amount of effort to monitor the fuel efficiency of a gas (or diesel) car. It's not hard, but you have to keep manual records and do some math.

If an electric car is much less efficient than claimed, you'll notice as soon as you try to drive to the limit of your car's range, because it won't get there.

Re:Study: Some car models consuming around 50% more fuel tha... by yoz-y on Thursday October 01, 2015 @03:50AM (#10309806)
Hm, I see. However I imagine entreprises with large car parks should have quite a lot of information (taxi services, car rentals, ...)