Doesn't affect (1) at all. As Sam mentioned, this is formalizing the de facto structure that's been in place a long time, so that announcement doesn't come with any changes to how HN works.
(2) Absolutely. Users can vouch for anything that's dead, including [flagged] and [dupe]. I see the notational confusion there; will ask Sam to update the post.
(3) Probably, but I'm not sure I agree with the line you're drawing from vouching to banning. Today's release massively lowers the cost an account of being banned. Instead of having your comments always stay [dead], they're now up for review by your fellow HNers; the community can decide what's good and bad. I'm not sure 'banned' is even the right word for it now— 'under moderation' would be closer.
The reason I say 'probably' above and not simply 'yes' is that there are a ton of issues to consider about it.
>Users can vouch for anything that's dead, including [flagged] and [duped]. I see the notational confusion there; will ask Sam to update the post.
If you were to rename the "duped" label, may I suggest "nuked"?
Whoops, I meant of course [dupe], not [duped] (fixed now). The traditional pg shorthand for duplicate. Not likely to change!
Re:Two HN Announcements
by KeepTalking on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @03:09PM
(#10298720)
Additionally, how is this going to affect startup school ?
Startup school picks attendees from hacker news.
It has zero effect on Startup School. We'd never do anything to impede that!
Re:Two HN Announcements
by KeepTalking on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @07:11PM
(#10300497)
Follow up question: I am assuming this change has not effect on Startup school radio that is hosted by AHarris.
1) How does spinning out YC as its own service affect a) the job posting system and b) the YC class qualifiers in submission titles? / What does "editorial independence" mean in the context of his announcement? YC submissions had a lot of points, true, but I had thought that was attributed to the high YC user base.
2) Will users be able to vouch for [flagged] submissions in addition to [dead] submissions?
3) Due to the vouch system, will the use of banning in general be readdressed, since there is now a way to address false positives/negatives? Shadowbanning was implemented at Reddit as a last resort (that the new CEO wants to remove), and it isn't respectful to the user to not know if they are banned.
EDIT: Reordered to match dang's responses.