News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by cperciva on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @04:43AM (#10295195)
Radioactive waste from spent nuclear fuel has a shelf life of hundreds of thousands of years. Maybe even more than a million, it’s not possible to precisely predict.

The fact that a journalist can write such a thing demonstrates the level to which public discourse about the sciences has sunk. We have very accurate measurements of the half-lives and decay pathways of all the isotopes found in non-trivial quantities in spent nuclear fuel, and it is indeed very possible to predict the level of radioactivity at a given time in the future.

Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by scriptman on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @05:39AM (#10295300)
I find it frustrating that so much journalism these days exaggerates environmental issues, with any factual errors seemingly brushed off as just showing an excess of virtue.
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by andyjohnson0 on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @05:04AM (#10295229)
The only circumstances I can think of in which the decay of radioactive waste might be unknown is in the case of mixed waste where the content or origin is unknown or ambiguous. Some old waste material might fall into that category, but I don't think that recent spent reactor fuel would.
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by arethuza on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @07:25AM (#10295572)
My understanding is that radioactive emissions are readily measurable so what elements/isotopes are involved should be identifiable and therefore the rate at which these will decay will be predictable - this could well be wrong!

One potential other risk is chemical instability of nuclear waste materials - that has caused lots of problems e.g. the Kyshtym disaster:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyshtym_disaster

Edit: Modified the first part to make it clear that I should have been asking a question rather than making a statement!

Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by andyjohnson0 on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @07:29AM (#10295583)
Is it possible to precisely identify the composition of a body of mixed waste solely from its emissions? Wouldn't chemical analysis of a sample be necessary?
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by VLM on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @08:57AM (#10295863)
1) Yes its extremely trivial, aside from shielding and non-homogenous and screwing up issues.

2) Yes because for example glass is stable in acid and unstable in some alkali so neutralizing the "stuff" before mixing it into glass bricks for all eternity would be Highly advisable if you want the glass brick to be unchanged for 100K years or 1M years or whatever. Aside from acid/base reactions with the glass itself there are solubility situations where a simple reaction might convert some radioactive salt that is highly soluble in water to something that's essentially waterproof. Note that the glass for vitrification is not exactly mere window glass, its some weird stuff, and adjusting its mix might help depending on what you're trying to dissolve into it.

(edited to extend answer #2, most of the waste you put into a vitreous block is not radioactive, you can't use the gear from answer #1 to tell what most of it is made out of)

On a high level this overall discussion has gone off the rails because the 100K and 1M numerological numbers come from glass vitrification and stainless steel corrosion theoretical studies; it has little to nothing to do with radioactivity; you could vitrify coal ash or industrial waste or Atari 2600 game cartridges the same way for 1M years if you felt like it. Or at least people think that storage tech will last 100Kyrs Of course radioactive waste is harmless once it finished decaying whereas arsenic is forever so its kinda pointless to try and stockpile industrial waste for 1Myrs whereas nuclear waste is the only kind of waste that actually goes away with time.

No human has ever made an industrial artifact that's lasted 1M years so things are kind of fuzzy at that kind of extrapolation.

Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by DennisP on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @09:19AM (#10296009)
1) Is this because the emitted particles have different energies when they come from different isotopes?
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by VLM on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @09:50AM (#10296247)
Yes. The resolution and dynamic range you can get with modern gear is pretty impressive. Check out images.google.com with terms like "gamma spectrum". Also different kinds of particles. Also you can zap things with neutrons (and other things) and the reactions tend to be rather unique.

Given a large enough amount of money to outfit a lab, its very fast and easy to tell whats inside an unshielded box. If its a thick enough shielded box, exact minimal design probably classified, then you'll have to crack the box open or stick a sensor in a hole.

Its trickling down to consumer level. Junkyards can now afford an x-ray zapper than analyzes the exact metal alloy of scrap that comes in. Its interesting that when I was a kid things like FLIRs and xray analyzers were very star trek, but within my lifetime they're going to be nearly consumer goods. If you thought police visual cameras and airport xray scanners were controversial, wait until every podunk police dept has 500 FLIR cameras on lampposts and every car that drives by is remotely analyzed for drug or gun or explosive signatures all for your "safety".

Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by kijin on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @08:20AM (#10295730)
Two substances might emit the same kind of particles, but their rate of decay will be different.

Measuring the emissions of a container over a period of several years will probably yield enough data points to solve for all of the unknowns.

Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by hga on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @09:04AM (#10295918)
Also the energies, specifically of the more penetrating gamma rays (very energetic photons). And the more dangerous stuff has shorter half-lives, so it wouldn't take all that long to get the full picture.

WRT to nuclear weapons, we can determine what the fissionables were, where they were mined, and some details of design all from sniffing the air downwind.

Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by thomasrossi on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @07:49AM (#10295643)
Contaminated lumber, clothes, plastics, that mixed material can be difficult to valuate indeed and uses a lot of space too, so it gets incinerated.
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by Altay- on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @05:11AM (#10295246)
The writing quality was a lacking overall. I actually found that uplifting, I'm not a great writer but if VICE is willing to publish this story, I shouldn't be as self conscious about my own work!
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by TeMPOraL on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @07:12AM (#10295534)
In other words, not only the article sucks, it also teaches others not to care about quality. :(.
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by amelius on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @05:02AM (#10295225)
Not if we invent methods to reduce the shelf life. Difficult to predict indeed :)
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by MertsA on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @05:09AM (#10295239)
Not too difficult, with a high neutron flux, the waste can be "burned" and that half life can be dropped to something manageable on a human timescale.
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by achamayou on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @06:26AM (#10295411)
That involves either creating more waste, or a sizable particle accelerator though. It's not too difficult, but it's quite expensive on a large scale to say the least.
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by adrianN on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @07:05AM (#10295515)
Breeder reactors burn up >90% of what we call "waste" now, leaving behind only relatively short-lived isotopes. They're not more expensive than normal nuclear power plants, but because they can be used to breed weapons grade plutonium we don't build them.
Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by ckozlowski on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @09:50AM (#10296250)
We don't, and that's a shame. They /can/ be used to breed plutonium, or they can me used to transmute into non-proliferation concerned materials. (Plutonium may be an interm step still; you'll need to read further on the Nuclear Fuel Cycle)

France does this still actually, but we do not. Too toxic an issue. (no pun intended.)

I've always been perplexed though at the 10,000 year requirement of the repository, as if envisioning all progress stopped for that period of time. Would this not be considered an interim step if, one hundred years from now, we found an economically sound alternative not available earlier?

I am not suggesting for a moment that this become a "kick the can" solution, but rather, the issue of nuclear waste is an ongoing project of management, not simply "stick in the ground for 10,000 years." If it turns out that in 200 years, we still do not have a better way of dealing with it, then take it out of the vault and put it in a better one.

Re:Built for Eternity: The Hoover Dam by elektromekatron on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @07:28AM (#10295577)
Might be a good job for CERN.