News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by jordanb on Sunday January 03, 2010 @06:15PM (#1029317)
The thing about ABS is that it operates on the principle of least surprise: It takes what the user expect brakes to do (slow the car down) and makes it work even when traditional brakes would fail to perform that task.

So it took a technology that the user expected to work in a certain way, and made it work better in that way.

It made brake behavior less surprising to the user.

This technology seems to do the opposite (at least, the way Scoble described it). It massively changes the behavior of the car based on some sensors, and then expects the user of the car to deal with the different behavior of the systems, all in a high-stress situation with alarms going off.

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by ugh on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:00PM (#1029358)
Driving cars is very dangerous. The earlier we radically change how we use cars the earlier we can avoid deaths on the streets.

I want an autopilot for cars as soon as possible.

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by houseabsolute on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:11PM (#1029373)
Absolutely. The moment we develop an autopilot that is safer than average human drivers by a statistically significant margin, it should be mandatory in all cars. I am hopeful that we will see this during our lifetimes.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by ugh on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:11PM (#1029470)
The introduction of such systems (probably expensive at first) would also be a great opportunity to switch from car ownership to widespread car rental (ala zipcar).
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by rdtsc on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:50PM (#1029522)
The technology might get there soon but not the legal framework. I can't even imagine the legal implication of cars on autopilot killing pedestrians and drivers.

That is also probably one of the reasons we don't have flying cars yet.

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by rms on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:17PM (#1029380)
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by houseabsolute on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:20PM (#1029382)
Sure, but that's not the same thing as saying they will be proven statistically safer, which will be the bar you have to pass before you can mandate them for everyone. I figure that's another few years off. But I agree that it won't be long now.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by mike_organon on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:29PM (#1029395)
Scoble's text is different from what the Ford guy says. Ford doesn't automatically hit the brakes, only preps them and when you hit the brakes, it automatically applies them 100%. Prius automatically applies the brakes and Scoble says he no longer instinctively hits them himself. I wonder if that loss of instinct is worth the benefit.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by mschy on Sunday January 03, 2010 @06:36PM (#1029335)
In practice what it means is that if you're about to crash into something, and you hit the brakes, that it hits them 100% right off the bat, instead of the 50% or 80% that most people would go for.

I've not used the system in the Prius, but I've used a competing system and it's not at all surprising.

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by ams6110 on Sunday January 03, 2010 @07:39PM (#1029418)
In many cases you're better off trying to steer around the collision than (or in addition to) stopping short of it. I've seen a few crashes where people could have just steered onto the shoulder or median to avoid the crash but it seems that they just applied the brakes and hoped for the best.

I don't think driver's education in the USA teaches emergency maneuvering much. How is it elsewhere?

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by enjo on Monday January 04, 2010 @12:38AM (#1029844)
I believe these systems don't have the effect until the point at which steering is no longer the option. The idea isn't so much to avoid the accident, but rather to try to bleed as much of the force of the accident out through braking as possible.

If you can get the brakes fully engaged you can reduce the severity of an accident pretty substantially, even if you can't fully avoid it.

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by vlad on Sunday January 03, 2010 @11:22PM (#1029755)
My drivers education course (in the US) emphasized steering to avoid a collision first, and then braking afterwards. We were taught that colliding with a pole at 35 mph is better than doing so with oncoming traffic for a total effect of 70 mph. It also reduces the chances of injury.

After reading that pilots are the safest drivers, I've made sure to always look around my car as I drive.

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by daveungerer on Monday January 04, 2010 @08:08AM (#1030254)
Remember that F = ma.

Hitting another car of the same size coming from the opposite side when each car is doing 35 mph is pretty similar to hitting a concrete wall at 35 mph. There is no 70 mph effect. The reason the pole would be safer is that it has some give. Lower acceleration = lower force.

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by daveungerer on Monday January 04, 2010 @01:33PM (#1030851)
If someone could explain why I was voted down, that would be great. Thanks.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by sailormoon on Wednesday January 06, 2010 @12:32AM (#1034238)
I didn't vote you down, but you cannot assume the cars are of identical size and mass, or indeed that it's a car at all. Hit a truck at 35, while he is also doing 35, and you'll feel a 70mph effect all right. For a few milliseconds.

Unfortunately, poles, especially old ones, do not have as much give as one would like, and large trees have basically none. Plus, their narrow aspect is a very bad thing to hit; cars are designed to collide with large, flat, wide objects and to crumple accordingly to wash off energy. Hitting an immoveable narrow object is outside this design consideration and cars have a nasty tendency to wrap around it.

Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by daveungerer on Wednesday January 06, 2010 @06:16AM (#1034535)
I was just making the point that justifying swerving out due to some undefined 70 mph effect is incorrect if you don't know what you're dealing with. And that whoever came up this 70 vs. 35 mph effect justification should realise that it mostly applies to e.g. the truck example you gave and somewhat to cars of significantly different mass / size. Therefore it's confusing advice and obscures other possible good reasons for swerving out.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by evgen on Monday January 04, 2010 @12:01AM (#1029797)
Ditto. The thing that seemed to trip up most people in the simulators was remembering to correct for the swerve. Most would turn hard right/left to avoid the obstacle and then forget to make a fast counter-turn to avoid running off the road.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by TeHCrAzY on Sunday January 03, 2010 @08:54PM (#1029528)
Nothing taught in Australia, at least conventionally. My driving instructor was a retired police driver trainer, I benefited greatly from his experience and understanding of vehicles. Never had an accident, but avoided several via quick thinking + knowledge of how the car will react and what options I have when driving.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by MartinCron on Sunday January 03, 2010 @09:58PM (#1029641)
For what it's worth, that's the main focus of the Motorcycle Safety Foundation course. If I remember correctly, 35 mph is the speed at which is easier/faster/safer to swerve than to try to stop a two-wheeled vehicle.
Re:The most under-hyped, but most important, technology sinc... by jrgnsd on Monday January 04, 2010 @01:58AM (#1029930)
It's not taught in South Africa, although we have a number of Advanced Driving Courses which teaches you anything from skid control to collision avoidance.