News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by elevenfist on Sunday September 27, 2015 @12:41PM (#10287059)
I was never even taught this "trick." The language used is shitty.

The way I was taught, dividing a fraction by a fraction is equivalent to multiplying the first fraction by the second fraction's reciprocal. It's easy to check this yourself. "Just cross multiply!" is ridiculous...

Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by xtreme on Sunday September 27, 2015 @12:51PM (#10287086)
You are definitely judging the book by its cover. If you follow the link, the full book has a lot more "tricks" and "solutions". The cross-multiply one is just an example. Of course many of them are culture/location dependent, but I'm sure you will find ones that you are familiar with.
Re:Nix the Tricks: Math tricks defeat understanding by eterm on Sunday September 27, 2015 @12:52PM (#10287091)
I guess it is saying that people are going straight to the "trick" (multiply the reciprocal) instead of understanding that they are applying the fact that:

a / (b/c) = a * (c / b) (a in Q, b,c in N and b <> 0)

And that they therefore have a less rich understanding of when the rule is applicable and when it isn't appropriate. (Such as a situation where b is actually zero, perhaps if it's "hidden" in another form like x-y.