News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by no_gravity on Sunday September 27, 2015 @04:48AM (#10285896)
The difference between web and app is trust.

A website has write access to my screen, my speakers and my internet connection. Plus limited read access. To keyboard, mouse, device orientation etc. Other rights can be granted (location, cookies etc). It can do all this only as long as it's "open".

An app usually has read/write access to large parts of my device. The whole sd-card, raw internet access, the camera, the microphone, ask me for money etc. And it can keep doing so even when it's "closed".

We will see the two converge. Websites will have more rights they can ask for. Apps will be better to tame.

But trust will keep being the differentiator and they will keep co-existing. There is friendship and there is marriage. Both have their use case.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by p4bl0 on Sunday September 27, 2015 @08:53AM (#10286338)
I think you are right. And I'll add that on smartphones that are in the low- and mid-range segment, mobile version of websites are often way better than mobile apps.

For example on my smartphone (a Wiko Cink Slim), I uninstalled the Twitter and Facebook apps because mobile.twitter.com and m.facebook.com are much quicker and responsive than the Android applications. They also do not request as many permissions, and are more featureful (e.g., Facebook chat works on m.facebook.com while it isn't included in Facebook's app, and rather requires an additional very intrusive shitty app).

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by tdkl on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:22AM (#10286070)
> An app usually has read/write access to large parts of my device. The whole sd-card, raw internet access, the camera, the microphone, ask me for money etc.

On Android.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by aviraldg on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:59AM (#10286142)
Not anymore.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by dombili on Sunday September 27, 2015 @07:19AM (#10286176)
I wouldn't so firmly say "not anymore" when only 15% of Android users[1] are on the latest version of Android almost a year after its release. That number probably won't go any higher over time either because Android's update cycle is a mess.

[1] https://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by marcosdumay on Sunday September 27, 2015 @09:04AM (#10286358)
> That number probably won't go any higher over time either because Android's update cycle is a mess.

What? People don't upgrade to an older phone. That number has nowhere to go but highter.

The upgrade cycle being a mess just make this take more time.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by dombili on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:01AM (#10286728)
By "that number" I meant the percentage of users who're using the latest version of Android. Lollipop's numbers will eventually get higher, but by that time there'll be 2 or 3 newer versions of Android.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by coldtea on Sunday September 27, 2015 @10:07AM (#10286531)
>What? People don't upgrade to an older phone.

No, but new phones come out all the time that are STILL using older Android versions. I think it will take around 2-3 years for all new Android phones to come with the latest Android.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by dogma1138 on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:51PM (#10287710)
It's more likely that sites became better at supporting mobile browsers and mobile browsers just became better in general. This all leads to a better mobile browsing experience, javascript runs better on mobiles now, and site developers have learned what works and what doesn't, sites aren't Flash sponges anymore (which was the case even for sites with Mobile support 5 years ago), HTML5 and other W3C standards have taken off, the mobile screens even on low-end devices are usually similar to desktop/laptop screens in resolution. People rarely care about their privacy, they auto accept pretty much anything that an app requests, Apple's lockdown of the permissions might help that case a bit, but again not because of privacy but because of the hassle of having to go into the settings and enable individual access for apps, this doesn't make people care for their privacy just annoyed and can't be bothered.

Content distribution and companion apps made sense when you needed to go mobile 5 years ago, when redoing your entire site to support mobile was too expensive and even then it wouldn't be a good experience due to how poor mobile browsers performed back then. Now it makes absolutely no sense, it's another thing you need to support and worry about which costs money, it's much harder to make people download an app than press a link, and in the current "link-content-sharing" (e.g. outbrain) eco systems most sites operate in it makes very little sense since allot of the traffic is generated by those click-baity "25 reasons why Node is now considered harmful" links you have at the bottom of each TechCrunch article. And on top of that even a low-end phone will usually have a 1080p(or close enough) screen, 2GB of RAM (unless it's an Iphone ;)) and a quad/hex core CPU which is more than capable of running pretty much any browser served content today mobile or not.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by davemel37 on Sunday September 27, 2015 @04:05PM (#10287753)
This is true at the layer of "why mobile browsers are capable of competing and beating app usage today"... the ante to get in the game...

But, the reason people are using browsers more than apps is simply because search is becoming the main use case of a smartphone.

I never look for an app on my phone beyond my home screen anymore, I just search or voice search my phone and expect it to either direct me to an app on my phone, or a search results page in Google.

I dont care where the solution to my need lives, I just want the quickest, easiest access to that solution.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by dogma1138 on Sunday September 27, 2015 @05:14PM (#10287956)
Could also be the case, tho it's a bit hard to tell since you don't know how they've accessed the content, however if mobile browser would blow like they did only a handful of years ago that wouldn't be a viable approach. Content access apps like TapTalk are pretty much dead, the only big community i know that still cares about their app is XDA-Developers which well is a very niche community to begin with.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by arrrg on Sunday September 27, 2015 @08:35AM (#10286304)
That is such a nerdy perspective, totally stuck in the filter bubble.

I don’t think that explains the difference at all. I think it’s about convenience. People don’t want to use apps for the diverse things they do on the web all the time. Apps may be convenient if you use them frequently (and then only marginally, especially with improving speeds and more people paying attention to making websites usable on phones), but if you use something not so often?

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by 49531 on Sunday September 27, 2015 @09:56AM (#10286492)
I don't think it's a totally unique perspective, but perhaps the average smart phone user would use different terms. If you look at apps as always having new updates, and always using up precious phone storage space you begin to feel like these apps are cumbersome. It might not be what they call trust, but it is a negative experience regardless.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by johnhkg on Sunday September 27, 2015 @08:38AM (#10286310)
I have observed that non-tech people find the App Icons sitting on their home screens to be very convenient to access a service they use, kinda like bookmarks.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by arrrg on Sunday September 27, 2015 @09:58AM (#10286502)
Sure, I don't think there is one variable that explains everything. There are a multitude of reasons that lead people to decide to use or not to use apps.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by tempestn on Sunday September 27, 2015 @02:18PM (#10287355)
I agree with your point. Do you think it could have been phrased differently though, since some people might take offense at their perspective (and by implication, them) being called nerdy? (Obviously not the most dire of insults, and not an insult at all to many people - yourself included, probably - but still probably unpleasant to some.)
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by catshirt on Sunday September 27, 2015 @02:24PM (#10287375)
if someone here is offended by this use of the word nerdy, they are completely unaware of themselves.

it's 2015 man, we took the word back. nerdy is cool.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by reitanqild on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:44PM (#10287689)
I'm one of the people who could have been insulyed and I say please STOP. Stop this nonsense where we cannot even describe anything.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by davemel37 on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:58PM (#10287734)
You are partially right. It is about convenience, but it is really about the convenience of search and the proliferation of voice search.

I don't even know anymore what apps I have on my phone.

I simply search and let Google search my phone and the internet at the same time and I click on the most convenient result.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by catshirt on Sunday September 27, 2015 @02:22PM (#10287368)
thank you.

it is definitely a difference, but to act like this is the reason for these numbers is so misguided.

"I use mobile web because apps have too much control" - no normal person ever

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by LoSboccacc on Sunday September 27, 2015 @09:29AM (#10286420)
poeple especially don't need apps of 150mb+ each, and premium phones come with limited storage forcing costly upgrades on top of an hefty price.

the only competitive advantage for apps is push notifications, and the sooner browsers and phones can build that into a standard the better (including opening the right page when clicking on a specific service notification)

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by davnicwil on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:21PM (#10287594)
> the only competitive advantage for apps is push notifications

Don't know about that. What about UX? It's pretty well accepted now that the native controls in apps provide a much less frustrating UX than all but the most meticulously designed web apps, which is a very low percentage right at the top. That's just talking about controls, that's not even to mention the clunkiness of the browser itself (address bar popping up over content, popups offering to remember passwords, all that kind of stuff that detracts from your tailored experience) and to an extent the navigation model (typing in a url rather than tapping an icon for instantaneous checking of a service). Simple stuff like this really matters to the majority of people.

For technically-minded people, we're not as distracted or put off by this 'minor' stuff because we understand the trade offs, reasons for it, depth of it and even how to work around it. Most people don't, they just (probably rightly based on evidence) trust apps to deliver a better and more tailored UX and that's it, that's what they like and want more of.

Don't get me wrong, I love the web, for probably much the same reasons you do. One advantage it definitely has is the ability to avoid downloading apps in the first place. But its competitive disadvantages vs native apps go way beyond push notifications. There's are a lot of things so deeply baked in to the web and browsers that apps do so much better that it will take (software) generations to 'fix', if at all.

Unfortunately for the web, as seen in the last five years or so, these are disadvantages that really, really matter to the majority of people who actually use services. Much more so than the higher level, arguably 'more important' things like security, privacy, storage space, etc that us techies tend to prioritise.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by LoSboccacc on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:03PM (#10288097)
address bar popping up over content [true] popups offering to remember passwords [solved] typing in a url rather than tapping an icon [solved]

we're not that far from a good user experience. even the bar problem is only ios specific, android browsers have a better support for full screen apps

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by jzzskijj on Sunday September 27, 2015 @09:49AM (#10286466)
The other thing is privacy. I don't want to give every service a "full access" into my phone. At least I have a feeling, that my privacy is in better hands, if I access services using up-to-date mobile browser (or Tinfoil for Facebook) instead of a native app running on my phone.

Looking at the ridiculous number of permissions different apps would require to run on my (Android) phone, using mobile site of the most of the services seems safer choice. Android 6.0 may change this with switchable permissions, tho.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by LoSboccacc on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:07PM (#10288107)
you are right about privacy, but if you follow the thread the parent already makes a good point of user already having been desensitized about app security permission by them being confusing and only really understood by few

I agree that the current browsers represent an exceptionally good model to run remote applications securely, far better than the app store / play store 'sandbox' and 'vetting processes' model, since has been used since forever and tested again loads of different attack vectors.

but I don't know if this is the reason for non nerds not to use native apps

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by andrepd on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:10AM (#10286762)
I remember having switchable permissions since 4.3. Did something change in the meantime?
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by tdkl on Sunday September 27, 2015 @01:48PM (#10287260)
AppOps got canned since 4.4 in AOSP and are coming back in 6.0.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by andrepd on Sunday September 27, 2015 @05:56PM (#10288073)
It went away in 4.4 but I have it again on 5.0. I had to use Xposed to get it to work on 4.4 but now it's on again by default. I see people complaining it's not present in 5.0, though. Strange...
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by jeromenerf on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:01PM (#10287514)
Offline storage is a great competitive advantage for apps.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by LoSboccacc on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:18PM (#10288134)
uhm while WebSQL and IndexDB aren't mature enough, wrapping libraries that grant some cross platform offline storage do exist and are only getting better
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by tambourine_man on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:34AM (#10286838)
A website has write access to my screen, my speakers and my internet connection.

And on iOS, even speakers and high bandwidth content are loaded only on a per user request basis.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by superuser2 on Sunday September 27, 2015 @01:52PM (#10287272)
You're referring, of course, to Android's broken and user-hostile permission model. This is not true of iOS.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by samcheng on Sunday September 27, 2015 @01:57PM (#10287286)
iOS allows apps to be pretty user-hostile, too. A bunch of apps require location tracking 'always' or 'never' but without an option for 'while using.' Why would I want the Yelp app to know my location when I am not using it?
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by shawn-butler on Sunday September 27, 2015 @04:29PM (#10287846)
This comment makes no sense to me. The "While Using" is a user setting / choice in the Privacy options.

It corresponds to kCLAuthorizationStatusAuthorizedWhenInUse authorization status in the SDK.

If an app tries to use any of the background location API without the user having previously authorized kCLAuthorizationStatusAuthorizedAlways (and I believe the user is prompted again in a few days after the initial authorization by iOS8+) the app API calls are denied access with an error code representing unauthorized.

It has been my experience that adding the "Location updates" background mode capability indicating to Apple that your app requires background location sets off closer review during the app store acceptance process.

I have had apps rejected that a reviewer felt did not have a good enough text "reason" for requiring location tracking displayed to the user in the message box.

There are many reasons for a Yelp-type app legitimately to know about your location while not in use. It could make better recommendations, limit searches to "local" sites, etc.

None of this of course stops iOS itself from "spying" on you. The CLVisit seems to be always recording but experts with more knowledge on that topic than me might know how to turn it off.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by lhl on Sunday September 27, 2015 @02:30PM (#10287396)
It's not ideal, but FYI you can manually go into Privacy > Location Services and change to "While Using" for any app.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by superuser2 on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:25PM (#10287607)
I just checked this, and on that page some apps do in fact only offer totally disabled or Always. Seems like an oversight that could be fixed with a software update though.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by chadgeidel on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:26PM (#10287610)
Not for any app. As the grandparent pointed out, many many apps don't give the "While Using" permission. It's only "Always" or "Never".
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by gergles on Sunday September 27, 2015 @05:33PM (#10288008)
These are likely old apps. App Store review guidelines will force them to include "While Using" when updating it, I believe.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by EduardoBautista on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:11AM (#10286049)
You can pretty much deny access to the information you don't want the app to access though.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by wlesieutre on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:27AM (#10286079)
Not on Android, at least until 6.0 has a noticeable install base (years)
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by chisleu on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:52AM (#10286904)
Apps have feature capability that websites don't, unfortunately.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by benbristow on Sunday September 27, 2015 @07:40AM (#10286207)
> An app usually has read/write access to large parts of my device. The whole sd-card, raw internet access, the camera, the microphone, ask me for money etc. And it can keep doing so even when it's "closed".

The Play Store and installing APK's shows you a full list of permissions that the app will have access to before installing. If you're not happy with it, just don't install the app.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by ekianjo on Sunday September 27, 2015 @07:45AM (#10286214)
> The Play Store and installing APK's shows you a full list of permissions that the app will have access to before installing. If you're not happy with it, just don't install the app.

That's a shitty way to do things. You should be able to revoke access to things the app is asking and still use the (then crippled) app. There are tons of apps who ask way more access rights than they need (obviously not related to their core functions).

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by andybak on Sunday September 27, 2015 @08:40AM (#10286316)
Just to note - Android M moves to just in time permissions.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by CountSessine on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:31PM (#10287632)
Only for apps that use the new API level, unfortunately. Unless they do what cyanogen does and fake the data exposed, which I guarantee Google won't do.

It's going to be extraordinarily confusing for users who end up exposing their personal data, thinking that an old-API app will be constrained when running on their new 6.0 OS.

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by andrepd on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:13AM (#10286771)
You can do that, I think. After installing an app you can go the the app settings and disable specific permissions.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by CountSessine on Sunday September 27, 2015 @03:26PM (#10287611)
Where? I don't see that anywhere in my settings. I'd consider installing the Facebook app again if I could yank all of its privileges. I'm 99% certain that this is NOT an option anymore, post 4.4.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by andrepd on Sunday September 27, 2015 @05:55PM (#10288066)
I'm on 5.0 and it's under Settings > Security > App Permisions. I can select each permission in each app and switch individual permissions from the default of Allow to Deny or Ask. I'm on a stock ROM.
Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by CountSessine on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:20PM (#10288138)
I'm on 5.0 as well and I have no such menu. I have "Apps with Usage Access", but that just controls android.permission.PACKAGE_USAGE_STATS.

By stock ROM, you mean you have a nexus device and the original or OTA upgraded firmware on it?

Re:Mobile browser traffic is 2X bigger than app traffic, and... by andrepd on Friday October 02, 2015 @04:47PM (#10321216)
I have a phone with a clear 5.0 ROM, beyond a couple of Vodafone-branded shortcuts on the homescreen. Apparently this feature isn't present in Nexus ROMs, which is strange. Good on Vodafone for including this feature though.

PS: This is the device http://www.gsmarena.com/vodafone_smart_ultra_6-7313.php