I'd argue we are seeing the same mechanisms at work in the private tech investing space, and that once companies start to go under, those who have not exited from their investments are likely to get burned big time.
Often attributed to Keynes, though may have originated with Shilling (or been in common use).
Imagine saying "Stock X is great, but the market can undervalue X longer than I can stay solvent"?
It's the PE of companies like Facebook and Twitter, who derive their earnings from questionable business models (notoriously hard to measure ROI on advertising, millions of fake/spam accounts, possibility of disruption ala Myspace) that I would be concerned about.
It's a chaotic system with an upward bias. Cyclical implies temporal predictability, and good luck with that :-)
Sure, I can say with 99.9% certainty that the economy will contract within the next 100 years. Shorten the time frame and my confidence level will drop accordingly. I'd probably have a 0.1% probability of guessing within 30 days of when the business cycle will reverse.
> If Clinton really wants to deal with short-termism, she’d be better off targeting the way executive compensation works, instead of the way capital gains are taxed. Ultimately, the solution to short-termism isn’t on Wall Street. It’s in the executive suite.
So my GGP's post is correct. Executives break companies by manipulating the financial short-term.
Saying "Amazon and Netflix and Tesla prove that the market is long-terminal" is silly. These companies are founder-run and there is a large part of the market (Hello Yahoo and HP) where revolving door CEOs just pillage the company to goose the short term numbers and cash out their stock options)
"a 2014 study of companies that cut R. & D. spending in order to meet short-term earnings goals found that their stocks underperformed after earnings had been announced—hardly what you’d expect if the market cared only about the short term."
meaning the market is not being fooled, and therefore executive compensation based on market value is not driving short term thinking.
Hillary's plan to make it more costly for people to switch investments will make the economy less productive.
The sorts of people who invest in Amazon are, anyway.
Still, it's true. Growth companies think long term. But the moment a company (or other organisation) gets into trouble it starts thinking short term. When you've got to lay off 20% of your workforce, you pick the ones whose absence won't be felt for many years.
But really, the reason that companies don't invest in pure science is not that the value is too far in the future but that the value is too diffuse to capture.
If you are better than other investors at knowing which companies are secretly eating their seed corn, you can make a fortune shorting their stocks.
CEO compensation is often tied to short term stock values. But those short term stock values ARE a reflection of the long term prospects of those values, not last quarter's profit. I've seen a lot of share prices tank when a blowout profit was announced, because along with it investors got hints that there were big problems looming.
I think so. A lot of the research at Xerox PARC and Bell Labs failed to generate much profit for their parent companies, although it was of great benefit to society, so why should companies continue to operate that way? It's a market failure. The federal government probably needs to pick up the slack and fund more basic research.
I hear this all the time, and it's absurd. The high P/Es of innumerable companies (like Amazon) are compelling evidence that investors are well aware of the long game companies play and they approve of it.
The charge that companies are eating their seed corn to satisfy wall street assumes that investors are monumentally stupid. Share prices are based on the collective best estimate of the future value of a company. Any hint that the company has sacrificed the long term for the short term will tank the stock value.