News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by lionhearted on Saturday January 02, 2010 @06:20PM (#1027834)
Some reasons American medicine is very expensive:

1. Health insurance, but not treatment, is fully tax deductible. So if you buy your own penicillin, it's with after tax money, but if your insurance company buys it, it's pre-tax money. That's one of the reasons that health insurance is so widespred in America even for routine medicine like antibiotics and checkups. That's a major contributing factor in why the administrative costs are so high.

2. There's a shortage of doctors in America, and qualified doctors from other countries are not allowed to practice medicine in the United States. So there's good doctors from Canada, England, Japan, wherever that'd love to practice in the USA, but can't. This artificially inflates doctor's wages by restricting supply.

3. American doctors are typically required to get an undergraduate degree, medical degree, and do a below market, crazy hours residency in order to be able to practice medicine. That's 8-10 years of study and below market working to practice medicine. Now, medicine is very important and needs to be done right, but I don't believe for a second that a focused apprenceship couldn't teach a very specific kind of medicine - say arithscopic surgery - in just 2-4 years under a highly trained doctor, but this isn't an option.

4. The Food and Drug Administration requires new drugs to be proven not only for safety, but also efficacy. That's an incredibly high and expensive burden to meet - that means that drugs need to be proven to work to a certain standard, instead of just not harm. This adds years of development time and millions of dollars in cost to the new drug development cycle.

Those are all legislated reasons that increase the cost of medical insurance, doctors, and drugs. They'd be fairly easy to remove -

1. All medical and health expenses can be written off taxes regardless of insurance. Employees can choose to convert som of their wages to a medical or health plan tax free to both the employer and employee. (Currently, under most circumstances, only employer-provided health insurance can is tax free)

2. Allow any doctor in a country with reasonably competent medical standards to practice in the United States.

3. Require that doctors be able to demonstrate that they can practice their area of medicine capably. Be flexible in how they demonstrate that. Note: This will incur high opposition from medical schools and current doctors who are currently enjoying the wage premium and had to go through the very long, difficult, and expensive system.

4. Change the drug standard from "safety and efficacy" to only safety. Drugs will come to market much faster and cheaper. There's plenty of people and organizations that will test proven safe drugs for efficacy for free or nominal cost once drugs hit market, and efficacy will get understood with time. Put this way - a proven safe but questionably effective treatment against heart disease being held off the market for five years and costing much more to get to market is not a good thing. If it's certainly safe, then let people make the decisions with their physicians, instead of having the FDA take such a strong gatekeeping stance.

Technology has progressed such that we don't need government protection from ourselves as much any more. The current set of legislation has greatly increased the costs of doctors and medicine. Regardless of political position, and regardless of stance on other health issues, addressing these four points will make the medical system fairer, more effective, and and less expensive with relative ease.

Admittedly, there's some powerful entrenched interests that are winning in the current arrangement, and will oppose these simple improvements.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by scott_s on Saturday January 02, 2010 @07:01PM (#1027885)
Regarding point 4, what would prevent a drug company from claiming that, say, Aspirin could cure AIDS? I do not think that is a stretch, either. If companies can profit from selling pills to increase penis length, I see no reason why they wouldn't make other claims if they were legal.

I do not trust in the market to correct unverified claims; many people want to believe in miracle cures, and will buy snake oil despite others decrying it as such.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by dantheman on Saturday January 02, 2010 @07:08PM (#1027898)
They trust their doctors. In the rest of the world there are not the restrictions on drugs that are found in the USA. Also, what about all the people that could be saved by a medicine that have nothing to lose if it doesn't work since they have no other options -- right now they SOL. The amount of people that die because they cannot receive medicines that may work is staggering and a great injustice.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by scott_s on Saturday January 02, 2010 @07:13PM (#1027906)
Do you have data on the number of people who die because the FDA has not approved a drug that may save their life? Note that this is different from people who die because they can't afford treatment.

I would be more comfortable with point 4 if we once again banned prescription drug advertisements.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by neurotech1 on Saturday January 02, 2010 @08:43PM (#1028033)
In life or death cases, the FDA can grant a Humanitarian Use Exemption. eg. Experimental cancer treatment drug.

The key difference is in the "experimental" part, as that drug cannot be marketed until its fully approved.

The doctor would have to get permission from the patient, and their hospitals "Ethics Review Board"

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by jacoblyles on Saturday January 02, 2010 @09:08PM (#1028064)
I believe this is a question often studied in Economics journals, you may want to look there. If I remember correctly, it is referred to as "Type I vs. Type II" error. One type of error is when a drug is approved prematurely and people are harmed because of it. The other type of error is when people are harmed because a useful drug is kept off the market. Some economists theorize that the second type of error would be more common, because the first kind of error is more visual and visceral. I believe there have been studies attempting to find evidence for the theory, but I'm not an expert and have never kept up with the latest journals in economics.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by onoj on Saturday January 02, 2010 @10:39PM (#1028148)
Remember that the FDA in the US only requires that a drug be better than placebo to be "effective" in many cases the drug company just has to show 0.1% better than placebo to get passed.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by 3pt14159 on Sunday January 03, 2010 @01:17AM (#1028283)
They need to prove statistical significance. Getting a 0.1% better drug past would require a pretty large control and sample group, making the drug more expensive to continue to test. Also, the doctors are given the drug's effectiveness vs placebo, and no doctor is going to give a drug that give the patient a 50.05% rate of recovery when 50% is the base.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by dantheman on Saturday January 02, 2010 @11:26PM (#1028197)
I don't have any hard numbers, but here is a good article from 2007 that may provide insight into the problem.

http://reason.com/archives/2007/07/25/dying-for-lifesaving-d...

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by lionhearted on Saturday January 02, 2010 @08:11PM (#1027982)
> Do you have data on the number of people who die because the FDA has not approved a drug that may save their life?

That question wasn't directed at me, but finding out some data wouldn't be too difficult - you'd look up what life saving medicines had come to market since the stricter FDA regulations were enacted, what year the medicine entered trials, how many people died while they were in FDA trials before release. You could come up with some rough numbers for that, but the FDA doesn't post any information on added costs and deaths during trial periods. Obviously the safety trials save some lives, but the efficacy standard the FDA has is extremely high and adds millions and years to costs.

> I would be more comfortable with point 4 if we once again banned prescription drug advertisements.

The tough question is for drugs that people not be aware there's solutions for - erectile dysfunction, for instance. A lot of men just assumed that was something you had to live with when you got older before Viagra came out. Advertising for Viagra was probably a win for everyone involved - it educated doctors and patients that it's available, and obviously men and their partners were quite happy with its effects.

So some advertising definitely has positive benefits, but I see what you're getting at with snake oil claims if the FDA isn't as strict about playing gatekeeper. Something to think more about.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by gcheong on Saturday January 02, 2010 @08:34PM (#1028021)
I think the effect of eliminating the efficacy standard would just be to shift the cost from one that is paid upfront by the company and then borne by the consumer to one that is wholly borne by the consumer. The cost of finding effective treatments would not be reduced, but just more hidden in the cost of having the market weed out more medications, misinformation around claims, etc. Just look at the supplementation market which the FDA does not regulate much. How many people waste their money chasing claims that have little or no effect?
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by tokenadult on Sunday January 03, 2010 @09:31AM (#1028537)
In the rest of the world there are not the restrictions on drugs that are found in the USA.

I have lived overseas long enough that I have been treated by licensed medical doctors in another country, who prescribed to me drugs that are not permitted in the United States. That was not a happy experience. I eventually had to have FDA-approved drugs that ACTUALLY WERE SAFE AND EFFICACIOUS sent over to me as I continued my stay in that country. There are prescribing and dispensing biases in other countries that frequently cause the most safe and effective medicines to not even be available in those countries at any price, even long after FDA approval of the best medicines in the United States.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by tokenadult on Sunday January 03, 2010 @09:28AM (#1028534)
2. There's a shortage of doctors in America

To the contrary, the United States has an unusually high number of medical doctors per 100,000 persons in the population. Economist Martin Feldstein discovered a long time ago, in comparative studies of the United States and Britain, that doctors refer patients to other doctors, so that increasing the percentage of doctors in a country can actually result in more use of medical treatments per patient without any improvement in patient outcomes. After he made this discovery, the United States figured out that promoting the opening of more and more and more medical schools was not going to result in doctors serving underserved areas such as isolated rural areas. (Doctors like to live in communities similar to where their spouses are accustomed to live, as other studies have found.)

The other suggestions in the parent comment have been carefully considered by policy makers around the world and have been found to be policies with some ill trade-offs as well as good, and not just in the United States.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by mtts on Sunday January 03, 2010 @09:38AM (#1028545)
1. I doubt the effect of this is as strong as you seem to think, but ok.

2. There's a reluctance to allow doctors educated elsewhere to practice without undergoing a rigorous accreditation process of some sort in nearly every country in the world except possibly in some of the most destitute third world countries. This isn't unique to the US.

3. All over the world doctors have to train for at least 8 years or so before they can practice. Again, not unique to the US.

4. There's a reason for that. It means the worst quackery is kept off the market. I'd say that's a good thing (also, it's not unique to the US, although the FDA is indeed a world leader in its stringency). Note, however, that the entire world is using (and paying for!) drugs that have been through the rigorous FDA testing process, so again this is not a reason why medical care in the US is more expensive than in the rest of the world.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by gabrielroth on Saturday January 02, 2010 @06:57PM (#1027880)
I agree with your overall point that the U.S. medical system suffers from overregulation. We could (and should) allow more primary care to be performed by, for instance, qualified nurses, RNs, and nurse-practitioners. As you point out, the existing guilds hate this idea.

But your first point needs some correction. Health insurance is only tax-deductible when it's paid for by your employer. [EDIT: Just noticed you mention this lower down, but your first paragraph gives a misleading impression.]

This is perverse in multiple ways. There's the way you mention: that it subsidizes health care over other forms of compensation, so we wind up spending more on health care than we would otherwise.

But also, with particular relevance to HN, it subsidizes employment over other kinds of work. If you leave your job to start a startup, you lose a substantial tax advantage.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by ams6110 on Saturday January 02, 2010 @08:01PM (#1027969)
If you are employed but your employer does not offer insurance, ask if they would pay for an individual plan out of payroll withholding. I've done this and it lets you buy insurance pre-tax even if your employer does not have a plan. This is a significant savings.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by russell on Saturday January 02, 2010 @07:35PM (#1027927)
If you are self-employed you can deduct your insurance as a business expense, Schedule C.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by niczar on Sunday January 03, 2010 @04:56AM (#1028394)
Look outside the US, and you will find that your solution (primary care done by nurses) isn't unlikely to be the right one.

In France, going to the doctor (general practitioner) costs €22, before insurance (it's €5 or €1 after insurance, the co-pay as you'd call it). It's much cheaper because:

- he didn't have to spend 200k to go to med school, it's free

- he doesn't need 5 employees to fill insurance forms, or waste 2h a day calling insurers -- it's all automagic, no paper involved.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by xtho on Sunday January 03, 2010 @02:27AM (#1028323)
Most of this points (at least 1-3, I don't know about #4) are also true in other countries (like mine). So they are not reasons for why the US health care system is expensive but rather propaganda.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by igrekel on Saturday January 02, 2010 @08:00PM (#1027966)
About point 3, teh shortage of doctors is not strictly a US thing. I know in Canada doctors often migrate to the US for a better pay, putting pressure on salaries.

Point 1 is not really different in many other countries.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by w00pla on Sunday January 03, 2010 @03:51AM (#1028366)
> 2. Allow any doctor in a country with reasonably competent medical standards to practice in the United States.

Not even that. Canada gets many South African doctors (most of which are fairly competent). In addition to this, they continually monitor doctors. So, if an incompetent doctor slips through, he is quickly caught and his license is revoked.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by zhyder on Sunday January 03, 2010 @01:56AM (#1028311)
3. could get fixed much more easily by dropping the 4-year pre-med undergraduate degree (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-medical), and adding about 1 year of instruction to med school.
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by shawndrost on Saturday January 02, 2010 @07:37PM (#1027931)
Regarding point 3, do most other countries have more relaxed licensing requirements?
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by joe_the_user on Saturday January 02, 2010 @07:34PM (#1027925)
1. The structure of an unstrained free-market medical system is well-suited for rent-seeking rackets. Doctors and hospitals tend to be monopolies. Even with competition, few are competent at choose between competitors, etc. This situation has historically been restrained by modest regulation and by the fact that most people entering health care are motivated by the desire to help others. These restraints are gone.

2. The current situation is neither "over regulation" nor "under regulation". It is mis-regulation. But all the regulation or lack-of regulation in the world won't really prevent a determined group of racketeers/rent-seekers aiming for their accustomed level of sales and profits through their monopoly position. There just aren't enough honest dollars in health care to incentivize the currrent system into being efficient. Making the existing system "work" is akin buying La Cosa Nostra spreadsheets and hoping this will turn it into an honest business. Reform at this juncture is like saying "can't you only restrain the growth in fraudulent loans just a bit". When the housing bubble was high, even the growth couldn't be stopped. Now, the decay can't be hidden.

3. It's not "The Doctors" or "the insurance companies" or "the hospitals" that are the problem but all of these and none these. There are indeed "good parts" and "bad parts" in the drug, hospital, doctoring and insurance industries. But the "bad parts" are far to too adaptable for efforts at restraining them piecemeal to work. From the chart in the article, you'd have to deduce the parasitic parts of US health care get at least twice the sales of the parts needed for a sane health care system and quite possibly four or five times that.

4. The point is NOT how we will correct the excesses of the current health care system. The question is when the growth of the current excesses will reach the point when they are truly unsustainable. The current "reform" wave seems aimed to enlisting the state primarily in the task of squeezing more money out of those who weren't paying into the racket (the uninsured). Well, once they've run of people to squeeze and health care cost go from 20% to 30% of GDP, there won't be any further place for the cancer to go but down. I'm guessing that's five to ten more years. Will our economy last that long? We'll see.

5. There are free market solutions that could work and single-payer solutions that could work. It's shame we won't see either kind of sanity for a while.

Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by joe_the_user on Sunday January 03, 2010 @02:44PM (#1028974)
I honestly wish someone would reply and refute my argument above, it's so depressing to think about the consequences...
Re:Cost of Health Care By Country, as Compared to Life Expec... by DanielBMarkham on Sunday January 03, 2010 @03:03PM (#1029013)
It is depressing. If I am about to die, I will pay whatever you want to charge. And if you collude with others, my negotiating position is toast. In addition, as a free citizen I am always able to invent a treatment that is so expensive that my fellow countrymen can't afford it. That's the nature of being a free person. Yet my fellow countrymen seem to be pretty pissed at this and are threatening to take whatever treatments I might invent and distribute them to the needy. You can call it socialism, but it's also just populist politics.

All this means that traditional market principles don't map exactly in the world of health care (I think they mostly map, just not exactly)

If I am not about to die, but I'm not paying my bills, then you're no longer providing me a service -- you're providing it to whoever is paying. And they're just playing numbers games trying to keep making more than they are spending.

There are some real, serious, foundational problems with health care. None of the current proposals by any party will even begin to fix them. What we're going to end up with, unfortunately, is a situation like every other big political problem -- the politicians will get more votes arguing about it and keeping it broken than they will actually fixing it. So it will remain broken.

Sorry -- not cheering you up so far, huh?

I could spitball some possible solutions. Make it illegal for anybody to pay my medical bills except myself, my family, and charities. Require all doctors to perform 2 years of public health service instead of some of the internships they are currently doing. Have a national standard definition of all medical procedures and require all health providers to publicly post prices for those procedures. Take the percentage of people who cannot afford treatment each year and require all health providers to provide that percentage of free service.

Of course none of that will ever happen.

I will say something political simply because it amazes me: the party who is on television right now demonizing the insurance and pharmaceutical companies is also the party that cut deals with these same industries to limit imported drugs and not have a public option. This virtually guarantees that those industries will be printing money for the foreseeable future. If I told you this five years ago you'd call me a fantastical liar. It's incredible.