News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by alkonaut on Friday September 25, 2015 @03:55AM (#10276839)
You have to consider the system as a whole. The kerosene tank with kerosene, plus the motor and gearboxes = X kg. The battery + The electrical motors and driveline = Y kg.

Example take a small aircraft as an example:

- Combustion: Motor 150kg (1kW per kilo) fuel 100kg (43MJ/kg) = 250 kg, 4300MJ

- Electrical: Motor 20kg (5kW per kilo) batteries 230kg (1MJ/kg) = 250kg, 230MJ

The amount of batteries carried is more than twice the weight of the fuel, so the difference in carried energy between those planes is now no longer 43x, its < 20x. Still a big gap, but the point is that it's much smaller when all things are considered.

Now consider any additional weight we didn't count here (gearboxes or other drive line components), the complexity of those planes, e.g. the number of moving parts. Also consider noise level, fuel economy, environment, reliability. For multi-engine craft it becomes even more pronounced. I don't think batteries will ever need to come close to the energy density of combustible fuels for electric flight to be viable.

Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by thedrbrian on Saturday September 26, 2015 @07:28PM (#10284825)
On the other hand batteries don't get that much lighter as you use the energy stored within. Also you're going to have to design quick capacity change battery packs or always fly with the maximum weight penalty.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by alkonaut on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @05:05AM (#10295233)
That's true, the average weight of the fuel is probably 60-70% of the takeoff weight or something, varying wildly depending on aircraft type and flight. Takeoff weight is probably the limiting design factor, so there you can compare the batteries to the full tank, which is what I have above.

On the other hand jet airliners are designed to be lighter when they land, landing gear and brakes don't have to manage a landing at full weight (which is why they have to dump fuel before making an emergency landing immediately after takeoff). An electrical plane would have to have brakes and landing gear designed for the heavy batteries, as it will be as heavy at landing as it was at takeoff. This might add quite a lot of weight.