News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by ams6110 on Thursday September 24, 2015 @11:47PM (#10276279)
Li ion batteries still have a LONG way to go in energy density compared to Jet A kerosene.

Jet A, about 43 MJ/kg. Lithium ion, <1 MJ/kg.

Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by alkonaut on Friday September 25, 2015 @03:55AM (#10276839)
You have to consider the system as a whole. The kerosene tank with kerosene, plus the motor and gearboxes = X kg. The battery + The electrical motors and driveline = Y kg.

Example take a small aircraft as an example:

- Combustion: Motor 150kg (1kW per kilo) fuel 100kg (43MJ/kg) = 250 kg, 4300MJ

- Electrical: Motor 20kg (5kW per kilo) batteries 230kg (1MJ/kg) = 250kg, 230MJ

The amount of batteries carried is more than twice the weight of the fuel, so the difference in carried energy between those planes is now no longer 43x, its < 20x. Still a big gap, but the point is that it's much smaller when all things are considered.

Now consider any additional weight we didn't count here (gearboxes or other drive line components), the complexity of those planes, e.g. the number of moving parts. Also consider noise level, fuel economy, environment, reliability. For multi-engine craft it becomes even more pronounced. I don't think batteries will ever need to come close to the energy density of combustible fuels for electric flight to be viable.

Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by thedrbrian on Saturday September 26, 2015 @07:28PM (#10284825)
On the other hand batteries don't get that much lighter as you use the energy stored within. Also you're going to have to design quick capacity change battery packs or always fly with the maximum weight penalty.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by alkonaut on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @05:05AM (#10295233)
That's true, the average weight of the fuel is probably 60-70% of the takeoff weight or something, varying wildly depending on aircraft type and flight. Takeoff weight is probably the limiting design factor, so there you can compare the batteries to the full tank, which is what I have above.

On the other hand jet airliners are designed to be lighter when they land, landing gear and brakes don't have to manage a landing at full weight (which is why they have to dump fuel before making an emergency landing immediately after takeoff). An electrical plane would have to have brakes and landing gear designed for the heavy batteries, as it will be as heavy at landing as it was at takeoff. This might add quite a lot of weight.

Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by akiselev on Friday September 25, 2015 @12:58AM (#10276436)
Lithium ion might not be the battery tech for high energy density uses once we work out some other, non battery technologies.

Aluminum-air batteries [1] are well studied in the past decade and there is lots more research going on there. Currently the state of the art for such a battery is about 4.7 MJ/kg and the theoretical maximum is as high as 28.8 MJ/kg, at which point the mass of the turbopumps and other fuel handling parts might make up the difference.

Of course there are issues, primarily the fact that they're not rechargeable and have to be chemically recycled. It's currently too expensive to do that now, but once we can do it economically, each airport will just have to have a stock of batteries and a robot to swap them on the jet and we'll have electric flight.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium–air_battery

Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by PietdeVries on Friday September 25, 2015 @02:32AM (#10276665)
There might not be a need to equal the energy density of jet fuel in a battery. If the efficiency of the engine and propulsion improve significantly compared to fuel jets, an electrical system might not need that much energy after all.

See the hybrid car: the efficiency of a regular engine (VW Diesel not taken into account ;-) is relatively low. If an electrical engine can be twice as efficient, you only need half the energy...

Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by ohazi on Friday September 25, 2015 @03:48AM (#10276822)
Wait, what? A good electric motor is already ~90% efficient. How are you going to double that?
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by mhandley on Friday September 25, 2015 @05:58AM (#10277190)
The electric motor is around 90% efficient, but the thermal efficiency of a jet engine is (if I recall correctly) only around 30%. So the batteries only need to contain 1/3 of the energy of the jet fuel. Batteries are still a long way off from this, but that factor of 3x makes it somewhat nearer than it would otherwise be.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by doctorstupid on Friday September 25, 2015 @08:45AM (#10277795)
But jets combine the energy of air and fuel, whilst electric motors are solely powered by batteries.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by jkot on Friday September 25, 2015 @07:05AM (#10277417)
And what about dead weight of battery after its empty?
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by kruczek on Friday September 25, 2015 @04:01AM (#10276860)
By reducing wasted energy by half, thereby increasing efficiency to ~95%.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by mlonkibjuyhv on Friday September 25, 2015 @07:39AM (#10277542)
But you're still only increasing useful energy by a few percent. Surely that's the interesting quantity here.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by erikpukinskis on Friday September 25, 2015 @03:21AM (#10276760)
If the density doubles every 10 years that means we're 50 years to parity. And we don't need to get to parity in order for there to be at least one economically feasible design. there might be some cases where reliability and availability of fuel are at a premium and an aircraft could be viable in half that. Which means now is exactly the right time to start experimenting if you're a plane manufacturer.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by pasbesoin on Friday September 25, 2015 @12:29AM (#10276368)
Plus, you shed weight as you burn the former.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by tempestn on Friday September 25, 2015 @12:32AM (#10276378)
True, but you also shed a lot of weight by ditching the large jet engines, and you can distribute it more efficiently as well.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by waqf on Friday September 25, 2015 @12:50AM (#10276415)
How about solar-powered planes? I would assume not having to carry an energy source (except for emergency use) is a huge efficiency win. And it's always sunny in the stratosphere (well, not at night).
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by akiselev on Friday September 25, 2015 @01:10AM (#10276456)
There's a very strict limitation on solar planes that depends on the panel efficiency and other material science avances as well as the shape and, especially, its height.

The bigger you make the jet, the more of its surface you have to cover with solar panels. However, while the mass grows geometrically with the size because of volume, the surface area of the panels only grows exponentially (x^3 vs x^2). Just like with single celled organisms: at some point the surface area can no longer absorb enough energy to support the massive machinery.

There are tricks to increase surface area but the panels still have to face the sun so you're forced to make planes short vertically but very long horizontaly. I don't think existing airports would be able to support such a different design.

Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by obataroter on Friday September 25, 2015 @03:19AM (#10276757)
> geometrically [...] exponentially

Cubically and quadratically?

Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by ajuc on Friday September 25, 2015 @08:13AM (#10277657)
I suspect that you can also add a thin layer of solar panels with wiring stretched between wings and tail, increasing usable surface significantly, without big changes in volume, mass, or drag.
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by prodmerc on Friday September 25, 2015 @12:43AM (#10276399)
Yeah, battery technology really needs to improve. In fact, there needs to be some revolutionary discovery in order for electric planes (and a lot of other awesome things) to be feasible...
Re:Electrifying flight: very different aircraft may end up t... by blktiger on Friday September 25, 2015 @09:41AM (#10278045)
Well, that depends on the purpose of the airplane. We already have electric sailplanes which have basically just enough battery power to get the sailplane into the air, after that you don't need an engine. Plus battery storage has been improving at roughly 10% every year. Right now a flight of around 25 minutes is the point at which fuel makes more sense than batteries but as batter tech improves that number keeps going up. We are at the very early stages of electric flight and while it may never be a viable option for commercial cross country flight there is a good chance that it will take over a lot of the smaller, general aviation aircraft.