Also, it does need to be stated, many of the employees were H1B workers with green card sponsorship. I'd say that they were behaving rationally by sticking with the company, especially since a couple of them were close to completing the process.
This and many other experiences have convinced me that while I generally look on immigration positively, I believe that workers need to be free and full agents in a labor market (this includes there right to change fields entirely, not just jobs, and it also includes the right to go without a job for a while). I'm convinced that a great part of the appeal of the H1B is that it creates a class of engineers who lack this freedom. Truth is, you don't need all your workers to lack freedom of movement, as long as the percentage is high enough to set a standard.
I would walk away from that situation. Any startup that's unwilling to do everything Sam outlined above is IMO not worth my time.
Hell, refusing to answer something as simple as "what percentage are these shares worth"?! I'd run, not walk, away from that one.
If you want to encourage workers by making them investors in the company, then treat them like it.
Having been around the startup block a few times now, there are some tells that are definitely warning signs for me.
The most ridiculous are things like demanding a NDA to even discuss the company. If a founder asks for a NDA just to have coffee, I am out - in my experience it's a 100% indicator of someone who has no idea what the fuck they're doing.
Secrecy around valuation, options pool, etc, are less damning but still very much a yellow flag when it comes to how they treat employees and how much experience the founders have. In general I find that inexperienced and immature founders tend to focus on secrecy in the wrong places (and conversely, lack of secrecy where it matters).
Indeed. I've seen this countless times, even occasionally in SV where people should know better. Starting a company is really really hard. It's fundamentally about deciding where to channel your energy when you have a completely green field but only enough resources to execute on 0.01% of your ideas. The focus must be pinpoint and relentless to even have a chance. The idea that the risk of someone stealing your idea is worth devoting any mental energy to indicates that you don't have your priorities straight. Hell, even in a worst case scenario where you have a great non-obvious idea, and someone steals it, if you want an NDA so you can sue them then you're essentially betting on their superior execution capability.
Run don't walk from this kind of hot air balloon.
And ultimately a startup is nothing but relentless, on-point, highly competent execution.
But in any case that may be ascribing psychology where there is none. Invariably though the founders I meet who are like that are also very inexperienced and 100% of the time have never built a product before, which is probably why they value idea over execution.
This is totally unacceptable
I'll say it over and over again - if you're asked to take a total compensation cut i.e. turn down public stock or salary from an established company to take options at a startup you are an investor. In fact a bigger portion of your net worth and income is invested then the typical VC's portfolio. And yet you don't get voting rights, you get screwed by liquidation preference etc, and the standard response is "well, you're not an investor, so you don't get preferred shares."
Engineers are often hilariously bad at finance and even worse at negotiation.