Like: a browser plugin that would randomly click ads in a different browser profile, maybe through an IP-masking proxy, without ever displaying them or the pages they load to the user (hey, maybe without ever traversing the last mile from the proxy to the user's computer.)
In this way, and assuming the clicks can be made indistinguishable from actual for-real user clicks (maybe a tall order if a proxies are involved?), the whole ad market automation circle could complete while still retaining a usable web. The online ad economy spins off to become a self-sustaining fully automated exchange bubble, visible to the external world only at its interface to participants' billing systems and analytics.
Publishers and ad networks win because clicks, network infrastructure providers win because traffic is lucrative and content providers can flourish, users win big time because they have all the benefits of an ad-supported free-beer web with none of the down side (actually seeing and being tracked by ads, that is.)
So long as the advertisers (or, more specifically, the campaign managers' bosses) don't catch on, what could go wrong?
Unless your automated system actually spends money then it will always be distinguishable from the real thing. Advertisers, no matter how wealthy they might be, cannot afford to pay for a "fully automated exchange bubble" that gives them zero returns.
So Google already detects and refunds advertisers for fraud.
I'm not worried about Google. I'm worried about user experience on the web as advertisers and publishers try to compensate ever more aggressively for the growing ineffectiveness of their business model (or is it greed?)
Average user experience on media sites is in rapid decline right now. If there isn't a whole page ad you need to click away, you can be sure there will be a popup for some customer experience survey or something else that acts like what we used to call a modal dialog box.
If I were in the business of defacing websites, I would like to replace all of those by an old Windows 3.1 modal dialog saying:
"General User Protection Fault"
That's not to say Google will survive in perpetuity. Disease has a way of iterating and evolving. But big G won't go down without a fight.
I actually flew out to New York and showed Douglas de Jager this specific trick back in June, and he said that it's not their problem, and until media buyers agree, he's probably right.
It makes me wonder about companies that get a large part of their income from advertising (Google...). Once the ad market descends into a cesspool that no legitmate company will dip their toe into, can companies that depend on advertising revenue survive on the self-serving, artificial, and mostly automated, ad market?