It appears that the latter example is somewhat like what happened here. The old Oh-My-Fish project was some licensed project. It could have even been a WTF Public License[0] that _did_ allow contributors to fork and remove attribution. At some point, all the code in the repo was replaced with new code under the MIT license that served the same purpose, and the repo's name was changed. Moving forward, someone continued to merge in the new code to the old repo and tried to remove attribution to the new code, breaking the new code's license.
The Oh-My-Fish project could have done a classical fork, severing ties with the Wahoo project just before the merge of the re-written code happened and continue to work in isolation, but it seems that they did not.
http://www.jbkempf.com/blog/post/2012/How-to-properly-relice...
From what I heard about the discussion, it seems like the LICENSE file has been altered by Jorge without all the OMF's contributors agreeing upon.
I don't understand, why not? That's in fact what usually happens; projects usually have a list of contributors, providing attribution.
For example: https://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/CREDITS
The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all
copies or substantial portions of the Software.
In the DMCA it's stated that his copyright is not credited, so they are in violation of MIT. Which is what is happening here.My point is that if they agreed to merge projects and wahoo didn't keep their license on it, then that code at the time of agreement is no longer under the exclusive copyright of the wahoo author.
But this...
>> On August 26, 2015, I, @bucaran, and "oh-my-fish" collaborators, led by @bpinto, decided to replace the entire source code of "oh-my-fish!" with the entire source code of "wahoo", but keeping the "oh-my-fish" name.
... sounds like giving he consented to give ownership of the code to the oh-my-fish project, and is retroactively trying to apply the terms of the MIT project now that they've had a falling out. I think the takedown needs to be reversed.