News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America's Military Supremacy Is Fading by supergirl on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:54PM (#10268816)
speculation. you can't know what was prevented. the chains of events are too many and complicated to predict. but what is the end goal anyway? preventing conflicts is good, so your goal is limiting suffering? then also consider how much more suffering exists now because of US and see what is the net effect.
Re:America's Military Supremacy Is Fading by classicsnoot on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @07:03PM (#10268862)
your assertion is equally speculative. the two things you say should be compared cannot concurrently be measured.
Re:America's Military Supremacy Is Fading by supergirl on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @07:11PM (#10268892)
correct. I meant that even if we pretend we can measure these things, then at least try to measure the whole effect.
Re:America's Military Supremacy Is Fading by sologoub on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @07:57PM (#10269074)
There is no objective measure that can encompass all. For example take Libya, under Gaddafi it enjoyed relative stability but individuals suffered from the regime. Now certain groups have more than what they had before, but as a whole Libya is in ruins and getting worse by the minute. How do you measure this impact? Is it unequivocally wrong because there is more visible suffering or is it right because there is a chance things will end up working out to less violence and more prosperity? (Which is far from guaranteed.)

These are philosophical discussions and large depend on your own perspective and bias in judging the outcomes.

My personal take is that some evidence exists in that last global open war with direct fighting on all fronts being 70+ years ago (WWII) the world is doing something right.

Edits to fix spelling.