The average diesel passenger car emitted about 8kg of NOx in 2008 and a third less in 2015 according to [1] and [2], so on average that's 6.6kg per car per year. If VW emitted 20 times that much since 2009, as alleged, that's 6.6 * 20 * 6 years = 792kg. An average diesel engine would have emitted 40kg, so that's 752kg extra for VW.
Multiply by 500,000 cars = 376,000 tons of extra emissions. [2] claims that cutting emissions by 187,000 tons saves 4000 lives. Hence, 376,000 tons should cause about 8000 deaths. That's assuming NOx levels and deaths have a linear relationship, which is highly doubtful.
So it appears that my feeling/belief that 500,000 cars could not have caused 100,000 deaths is correct. But if all 11 million VW cars of that type worldwide have that same "defect", then of course the number of premature deaths rises to 176,000.
All of this is most likely complete bullshit, but you are right, it makes sense to at least try to run some numbers ;-)
[1] http://www3.epa.gov/otaq/consumer/420f08024.pdf
[2] http://www.arb.ca.gov/msprog/ordiesel/documents/OFRDDIESELhe...
[Edit] I already found a mistake in my estimate. The NOx numbers in [1] don't seem to be for diesel or not only for diesel engines. But other sources give similar averages for diesel engines (after the catalytic converter does its job of course)
Nothing at all.
First CO2 does not cause any deaths, unlike pollution.
Second the amount of CO2 is very small compared to global emissions, so it's quite irrelevant.
NOx emissions are highly reactive and in the presence of sunlight turn into O3, Tropospheric Ozone [2] the same chemical compound as that in the Stratosphere, but very different in it's effects.
In the Troposphere, Ozone is a highly reactive oxidizing agent and can have serious negative health effects.
You can look at a map of daily ozone generation [3] from pollution. Peak production of ozone occurs at the part of the day where sunlight is most intense following the highest levels of traffic. It then mostly reacts and then levels drop again at night.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NOx [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tropospheric_ozone [3] http://www3.epa.gov/airnow/2010/20100929/anim_aqi_sanfrancis...
I haven't heard of nitrous oxide (N2O) being much of a concern.
Its bad for health reasons which is why there are strict standards on it. But global warming is not the end-all be-all of problems.
They are not the same thing.
Essentially I bought it instead of a Prius because I wanted a little more oomph for driving, especially in the hills around here.
Now I find out they cheated to get those numbers, and I'm pretty disillusioned with the whole company.
"All the other carmakers control diesel emissions by spraying a urea solution into the exhaust stream, where a catalyst converts it to ammonia"
and supposedly VW have omitted this mechanism to get diesel engines into their smaller cars.
Prior to that the Golf and Jetta used a NOx catalyst that requires a periodic burn-off achieved by sending a pulse of unburned fuel down the exhaust. Same deal as the particulate trap--that stuff needs to be burned off every so often, too.
While the effects on the company are extreme, I think we should also consider the broader and ultimate consequences of this trickery.
The fact that those cars pollute a lot more than officially acknowledged. I've read figures like 40x as much.
Does that make those 11 million VW cars caught cheating the politically accepted pollution equivalent of 440 million cars ?
Another interesting question - if VW was caught doing it, who else is doing it ?
And if other companies (and factories, etc) are doing it, what is the purpose of the international pollution treaties ? How does it affect the plans to reduce pollution, given that the numbers that we base our calculations on might be off by factors of 40x ?