Further, English has subject-verb agreement not subject-object agreement or verb-object agreement, hence "it is pancakes" is completely fine. Sure there maybe be some semantic anomalies, what with the singularity of the subject, the plurality of the object, and the copula which provides some sense of equivalence between them, but that's entirely a semantic issue and not a grammatical one.
Further further, setting off non-sentences by periods is common practice. You may not like it, but everyone else accepts it. You're just an idiot.
Further further further, "it's" is completely acceptable English, and isn't an official contraction only because there ARE no official contractions -- unlike French, with its (wholly impotent) French Academy, there is no authority on English, and thus no such thing as official English. The best we can do (as if we should care) is to reference the great authors of English literature (whoever they may be) and if you go by them, then you're most certainly wrong.
Further further further further, it's not your language, it's everyones, and I think the headline is fine; and they're not abusing it, they're using it in a completely standard fashion.
</actual linguist>
I'm upvoting your comment anyway because the concept of a subgrammar never occurred to me before and it's kind of neat. I'd be surprised if it weren't a well-known phenomenon among linguists though.
No, it is not. It's their language too. There is no central authority which hands down the rules of the English language, only common agreement and a shared understanding. If a collection of words and punctuation has clearly expressed an idea, then it has served its purpose.
Rules of grammar are useful, but getting too pedantic and authoritarian about them can do nothing but suck the joy out of your life.
The headline as it stands is trying to add some extra texture. "It's pancakes." - ie just pancakes, nothing fancy, nothing luxurious (though we have pancakes as a treat) they're just pancakes. I also find this to be a hint to a template of a salesmans patter. "In a can." - this evokes a staccato presentation on a TV shopping channel IMO and emphasises that all they did differently with their basic pancake batter was stick it in a can (even if that's not strictly true). "It's made $15 million." - the short sentence echoes the others and adds a little incredulity.
> It's pancakes in a can, and it has made $15 million.
How does this address #2: The words "[it is] pancakes" are incompatible because "are" is the plural equivalent of "is".
Not true. "It is pancakes in a can" is entirely grammatically correct, because "pancakes in a can" is a singular noun -- an idiomatic one, to be sure, but "pancakes in a can" is taken to mean "a can containing pancakes", which is obviously singular.
1) "it is pancakes" isn't a sentence (ambiguous in the extreme).
2) The words "[it is] pancakes" are incompatible because "are" is the plural equivalent of "is".
3) "in a can" is not a sentence (lack of a subject & verb).
4) "it's made" is "it is made" not the "it has made" it should be. (It's as "it has" is not an official contraction due to its obvious ambiguity.)
The unmurdered headline would be,−
</grammar-nazi>To CNN: Remember, it's my language you're abusing. Maybe you should care too? As a "big news agency" you should at least care enough to force your writers to learn basic English grammar!