News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by uptown on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:23AM (#10265135)
I'd like to know how they expected to get away with this? Something like this isn't a decision made by one or two people. The layers of engineering, and number of people that had to be involved in pulling this off had to be enormous. I'm amazed that a whistleblower didn't come forward sooner.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by emcrazyone on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:33AM (#10265191)
Actually one or two people could have gotten away with this. As a software developer on large automotive projects, I was often writing code to do things I didn't understand. My coding came from hand written specifications that often had sequence diagrams which is basic software flows. I.E. Do this when you see these conditions. I typically didn't understand the conditions.

Additionally, modern ECUs in vehicles are modifiable at run time through something called XCP/CCP programming. You can think of of this as calibrating the ECU. ECU = Electronic Control Unit.

The thing that really bothers me about all this is from the article

"Carder said he's surprised to see such a hullabaloo now, because his team's findings were made public nearly a year and a half ago."

It seems nothing was done until the media outlets got a hold of the story?

Why didn't this blow up happen a year and a half ago before all these additional vehicles were put on the road?

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by scott_s on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:39AM (#10265241)
This didn't blow up a year and a half ago because VW had not yet confessed. The timeline as I know it is that these results were published a year and a half ago, which got the attention of the EPA. The EPA did their homework, and about a year ago, started pressing VW on this issue. VW denied for a year, and just recently finally admitted. It's an unfortunate timeline, but I think a reasonable one. Source, from molecule in this thread: http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/adva...

And great insights on the software side of this.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by kale on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:58AM (#10265384)
Here is the letter (PDF copy) that was sent from the EPA to VW, VW America, and Audi. It was sent last Friday, which is when the story "broke".

The initial investigation 18 months ago kicked off an investigation by the EPA. VW denied any wrongdoing but admitted to a "glitch" and started issuing ECU updates. This is why some people think there is already an ECU fix for this out there. There is a "fix" from last year that says it's an ECU upgrade for emissions, but it was a stalling tactic / red herring while VW continued to cover up the extent of the deception.

http://www3.epa.gov/otaq/cert/documents/vw-nov-caa-09-18-15....

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by jazzyk on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:53AM (#10265350)
EPA doing their homework is fine, but what exactly is reasonable in VW denying this for a year?
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by scott_s on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @11:03AM (#10265442)
Nothing. I'm assuming that VW is in the wrong and not reasonable. I interpreted the original question to mean, why did every one else (media, government, public) not pay attention to this until now? Given the timeline, it's reasonable that the media, government and public did pay attention when they did.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by a3n on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @11:19AM (#10265531)
I thought exactly that, for the software developers. They may not have known what the ultimate aim was.

But someone with managerial skin in the game decided, and it's hard to see someone up high enough to have that skin in the game being able to push their goals down to the developer. Which means there's at least a chain of people, and at each level there's probably a small number of peers who know what's going on.

Someone decided, and needed help to get it pushed down to implementation.

People who spec'd power requirements had a very good understanding of what's possible with power vs economy vs emission control. If they got the power they wanted, they must have known how they got it.

There must have been a lot of people who either conspired or looked the other way.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by creshal on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:32AM (#10265182)
> I'd like to know how they expected to get away with this?

The whole industry has been getting away with similar schemes for decades, why shouldn't they get away with one more?

Cars in Germany have to undergo emission tests every two years, and even older gasoline cars with rudimentary engine computers will perform vastly different when subjected to its standardized testing interval – and if they don't, it's all sorts of trouble for the owner and mechanic responsible. My dad is a car mechanic, and he has been complaining about engine computers occasionally not going into emission test mode for as long as I can think. It's an open secret and the testing agencies are actively helping their mechanics to make sure the cars pass.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by andremendes on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:37AM (#10265227)
>I'm amazed that a whistleblower didn't come forward sooner.

From the article: Carder said he's surprised to see such a hullabaloo now, because his team's findings were made public nearly a year and a half ago.

"We actually presented this data in a public forum and were actually questioned by Volkswagen," said Carder.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by frandroid on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:18PM (#10266401)
You're surprised with this? I'm surprised that it took so long for Chelsea Manning to come out when literally hundreds of thousands of people had access to the same information. Snowden also had access to stuff tens or hundreds of thousands had access to, although in his case he also had access to stuff much fewer people had access to. I know they were working for intelligence services, but there must be thousands of others that were disgusted by what they were seeing in the files...
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:41AM (#10265253)
Its a literal mindset. The car has to perform to a standard during a test. The test procedure is written that way.

So, ok, it will perform during the test to the standard. End of thought process. Not really cheating; just conforming as written.

You think that's too easy an answer? Let me tell you about our phone module on the old Unisys NGen series. It was a programmable answering machine, plug a phone line into it, then a handset (remember those?). All worked fine.

Then we tried to sell it in Germany. They had a regulation: phone handsets had to be connected directly to the wall. The idea was, presumably, they didn't want any other equipment failure to compromise phone service, which was arguably part of safety/emergency equipment.

But our answer was, build a special cable, runs from the wall to the handset. There's a dongle on the end there, that splits the signal to run on another wire to the computer. But internally, the wire connection ran from wall to dongle to computer, then back to the handset. Electrically, same as in USA.

This wasn't a subterfuge. Heck, the German qualifying agency helped us put it together. It was how you got things done in a highly regulated society.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by pyre on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:31AM (#10265177)
It just takes a different mindset. My father used to work in the auto industry and he still complains to no end about the EPA and emissions testing, and how in California the car exhaust is "cleaner" than the air going into it, so the cars are actually all "cleaning the air."

I could easily see people at VW resenting these tests, and actively working to thwart them.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @02:06PM (#10266792)
I'm not really surprised. I used to know someone who ran a small Printed Circuit Board manufacturing shop. His waste water had to meet certain conditions for environmental pollution before he could send it down the sewer. Because the incoming water was so dirty and had to be filtered so well before use, the water going out the sewer connection was actually cleaner than the city water coming in!
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by sliverstorm on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:29PM (#10267494)
As a car enthusiast it was pretty hard not to get frustrated with CARB. The rules are very draconian, and even things that would dramatically improve emissions are often not allowed!
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by SilasX on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:08PM (#10268250)
It's a common event for assessed fines to be too low to deter behavior (in expectation). Maybe they thought that the fine/risk profile didn't exceed the potential gain?

I know there have been several occasions (especially when it comes to banks) I've heard about a fine and mentally reckoned that it would be too low to make the behavior unprofitable.

It's still an open question whether the actual fine they end up paying will wipe out the benefit.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by spacecowboy_lon on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:32AM (#10265179)
This is the end result of political decisions 20 years ago in europe to prioritize reducing Co2 by pushing Diesel and to hell with increased NoX

I wonder if any of the Politicians and bureaucrats who made that decision will get asked hard Q's.

Apparently Mrs Thatcher Questioned this approach at the time.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by brisance on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @11:54AM (#10265788)
Hold on. It seems that the other manufacturers don't have this problem.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by spacecowboy_lon on Thursday September 24, 2015 @03:51AM (#10270383)
Apart from going along with the political status quo you mean?

I was talking about the underlying cause of the rise of Diesel and the health effects being ignored and the Technocrats and politicians avoiding any questioning