News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by tedunangst on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @10:42PM (#10263059)
That's a peculiar way to disincentive success. Hope to be successful enough to make some royalties, but not so successful as to be traditional because then you get nothing.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by qq66 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @11:07PM (#10263131)
Well, I do believe that a work can become so important that it shouldn't be copyrighted anymore. The most notable example is Martin Luther King's "I Have a Dream" speech, which is a national artifact more important than anything in the Smithsonian. It should be freely distributable to everyone in America who wants to watch it, instead it is under enforced copyright. Perhaps the government should purchase the copyright using eminent domain in cases like this.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by jcranmer on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @12:39AM (#10263337)
Actually, in US copyright law, it is possible for works to effectively lose their copyright. One of the elements of fair use (note: most jurisdictions do not have a fair use defense, so this only applies to the US) is that some things can become so important to the public interest that any reproduction is effectively fair use. The most notable use of this claim is the Zapruder film of JFK's assassination.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by nightpool on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @11:12PM (#10263144)
Woah I haven't ever considered the possibility of applying eminent domain to copyright brb mind blown.

That seems... incredibly reasonable and helpful.

(no sarcasm)

Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by tedunangst on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @11:41PM (#10263207)
MLK could have dedicated the speech to public domain, had he so wished. Again, "if we like your speech we're going to take it" -> not a great incentive.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by pyre on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:01AM (#10263391)
On the other hand, are you going to argue that the existence of copyright is what caused MLK to write said speech? In the absence of copyright, we never would have had the "I have a dream" speech?
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by linkydinkandyou on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @02:19AM (#10263568)
Except Dr. King didn't write the speech. From Wikipedia:

"The speech was drafted with the assistance of Stanley Levison and Clarence Benjamin Jones[17] in Riverdale, New York City. Jones has said that "the logistical preparations for the march were so burdensome that the speech was not a priority for us" and that, "on the evening of Tuesday, Aug. 27, [12 hours before the March] Martin still didn't know what he was going to say"."

I'm not so sure these people would appreciate the fact that you think they should work without being compensated for it, or that somehow, compensation and/or ownership isn't a good reason to do something.

Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by salvadors on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @04:07AM (#10263838)
I suspect the primary compensation they hoped to get for that particular speech was _not_ financial.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by linkydinkandyou on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @09:11AM (#10264771)
People who write songs and materials for Churches do it to make a living. It's actually a big problem for folks who write songs and arrangements for Church Choirs--many of their customers don't feel they should be paid! I've been to conferences at Music and Musician trade shows where this very issue is discussed.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by 6stringmerc on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @09:49AM (#10264934)
Right, and work for hire means a writer gets paid one time to do the job, and the residuals are owned by whomever hired the person do write the speech / book / song / lyrics / tambourine solo.

Doesn't matter if it's churches or playing in jazz clubs, writing and making music for a living is a tough business. I've worked some churches that paid quite well - at least industry standard - and I could go online now on CraigsList and find 5+ requests per day asking for music volunteers because religion. In my experience, churches are simply another ill-informed group that frequently want all the benefits of live music without compensating for it. Same goes for well-meaning volunteer organizations.

Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by pyre on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:43PM (#10268459)
> many of their customers don't feel they should be paid

This happens to physical products too, I don't see how specific individuals not wanting to pay for something has any bearing on the existence / effectiveness of copyright.

Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by phaemon on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @08:25AM (#10264574)
Well, firstly speech-writers normally are compensated...they're paid for their work when they do it.

Secondly, they're not the beneficiaries of the copyright: it belongs to the King estate.

Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by pyre on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:34AM (#10265205)
The argument for Copyright is that is incentivizes people to create things (e.g. musicians to write songs).

Are you stating that without copyright no one would write speeches? Would people have just abandoned the Civil Rights movement because of a lack of copyright? That seems like an extreme view.

Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by anon4 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:45AM (#10264119)
If you get to the point where your song is sung at every single English-speaking home at every birthday, you have effectively captured all the market. You cannot get more successful. You reached the end game, the top score, there is no more growth to be had. The oil well has dried up and the gold mine is empty. You are standing at the end of profit.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by alricb on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:40AM (#10265245)
But it takes a good bit of time for something to become "traditional"; long enough that it becomes hard to figure out who, exactly, owns the copyright to what, as in this case. Limiting the term of copyright also has a function of promoting legal certainty: with relatively short terms, if there's a controversy, the court can have living witnesses and a fairly complete record, vs. a few strands of unconclusive evidence like here.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by realusername on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:08AM (#10264006)
I think strangely, we are not hearing so much about the original inventors from the 20's, we should ask them what they think about that.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by gohrt on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @11:48PM (#10263224)
Have you read the Constitution recently?

> To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, < by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors > the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.

The whole point of the system is to encourage products that are successful enough to make some royalties and then become public domain.

[deleted]
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by tedunangst on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @11:35PM (#10263196)
You do realize you linked to a page about trademarks and not copyrights?
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by curious_slinky on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @10:55PM (#10263090)
Well, you still get the satisfaction of creating a deeply ingrained cultural phenomenon.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by dror on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @11:08PM (#10263132)
No, you're successful enough to make some money, not necessarily a huge amount.