News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by linkydinkandyou on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @09:11AM (#10264771)
People who write songs and materials for Churches do it to make a living. It's actually a big problem for folks who write songs and arrangements for Church Choirs--many of their customers don't feel they should be paid! I've been to conferences at Music and Musician trade shows where this very issue is discussed.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by 6stringmerc on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @09:49AM (#10264934)
Right, and work for hire means a writer gets paid one time to do the job, and the residuals are owned by whomever hired the person do write the speech / book / song / lyrics / tambourine solo.

Doesn't matter if it's churches or playing in jazz clubs, writing and making music for a living is a tough business. I've worked some churches that paid quite well - at least industry standard - and I could go online now on CraigsList and find 5+ requests per day asking for music volunteers because religion. In my experience, churches are simply another ill-informed group that frequently want all the benefits of live music without compensating for it. Same goes for well-meaning volunteer organizations.

Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules by pyre on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:43PM (#10268459)
> many of their customers don't feel they should be paid

This happens to physical products too, I don't see how specific individuals not wanting to pay for something has any bearing on the existence / effectiveness of copyright.